“food has always been incredibly delicious never had a bad meal the only complaint is the pieces of Dessert have gotten smaller without the price coming down in som case just the opposite besides that the food has stayed consistent and delicious throughout the last 5 years my wife and i have eaten there mostly ordered out some of the favorites r eggplant parmigiana same as chicken calzones excellent also surprisingly philly cheese and steak excellent for a Nupstate N.Y italian mexican restaurant“
“I love this place! When Brian's cooking everything comes out perfect to or better than perfect. Not to say when the other guys cooked it isn't perfect. But Brian is the best. There's always a healthy amount of toppings when ordered, the Pizza is never Burnt, or under cooked.That being said I do miss one amazing thing, when they first opened they had a family-size calzone it was absolutely amazing. I really do hope they bring it back.Check out this place on Mondays and Tuesdays between 5 and 8 I think, he usually has an all-you-can-eat buffet, I think the best menu I had in there was any pizza slices you wanted Buffalo macaroni and cheese perfectly cooked beef slices in gravy and spaghetti and meatballs. It's a small buffet but it's delicious. Usually consisting of four five items on the menu. Not bad for 12 bucks... My family two kids and a wife eat there often and we order out to our job frequently.Stop by look for Brian, tell him cowboy sent you!Kid-friendliness: I have a 10 year old and a 16 month old. They both enjoy this place because of the cool car game cruisin USA and that stuffed animal toy crane thing.“
“Best pizza and Mexican food in Greene County Ny!! The pizza is delicious and they use fresh ingredients. They also have Mexican food which is delicious too. They’re happy to deliver within reason and it’s an excellent family owned business. Support your local businesses yallVegetarian options: Veggie tacos, veggie pizza, vegetarian appetizersDietary restrictions: Accommodating for dietary restrictionsParking: It’s located next to Price Chopper in Catskill so it shares the same parking lotKid-friendliness: Food for kids available. Generous portion sizesWheelchair accessibility: Sidewalk is wheelchair accessible“
“Can't speak about the beer, but the cranberry spritz and cranberry mule were delicious! Overall, I was happy with our food. I just wish the service was a bit faster but looked like they were short staffed. Regardless, I'd return.“
“Amazing food! I’ve been here a few times now and the food is always fresh, hot and delicious! The owners are very friendly and outgoing. Great atmosphere for indoor dining. Highly recommended whether you’re looking to eat in or take out. I’ll be back, many times!“
“Great food and atmosphere. Hollowbrook has a very nice wrap around porch that looks over 32. I have had multiple dinners here and the ambiance is always great when have a nice meal with some red wine. Definitely a go to spot for the area. Also the staff are very friendly.“
“We have ordered from here a few times. Tonight my pregnancy craving was a white veggie pizza. They usually put sauce on their veggie pizzas, but complied with my request. It was delicious. And my family was loving the supreme pizza, and bacon pizza with half mushroom and half olives. And the staff was very nice and personable. Very satisfied customers. Highly recommend!“
“Very basic steak it was a good attempt at Brussels and sweet potato fries but nothing had flavor or was cooked to perfection nor seemed fresh. I was starving and there wasn't much else around so I understand some of it but to have cows in every direction and then sell a dinner new york strip cut steak that was chewy and boiled was a bad decision. Just a heads up I am sure they have great bar foods like wings or burgers but I can't speak to it personally. Staff was kind and very overstretched across the restaurant“
“Absolutely delightful pizzeria with mouthwatering offerings. We tired the traditional cheese slice, white slice, a meatball slice and a Sicilian slice... all of them were simply out of the world.... the day's special shrimp chowder was decadent and the made to order calzone with sausage and pepperoni filling was definitely worth the wait....“
“I placed a large catering order for a party and the guy behind the counter was very helpful as well as polite. I wanted an item that wasn’t on the catering menu yet they still did it for me. The food was excellent especially their tortellini in cream sauce with prosciutto and garlic knots. Everyone at the party loved the food and wanted to know where it came from. Very satisfied with Mateo’s! They’ll continue to get my regular business as well as all parties.“