5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carle Place

“A winning spot for pizza lovers! We first tried Anthony's during their Super Bowl promotion and were hooked! Subsequent visits, including a dinner date and team lunch, only reaffirmed our delight. The atmosphere is decent, service is good, but the real star is the food - their pizzas and garlic knots are absolutely delicious! Consistency is key, and Anthony's delivers. A great spot for casual gatherings or dates. 4/5 stars!“

“Love this place, always friendly people to welcome you in, All the food is Amazingly Delicious, take out or eating in. I tell all my friends about this place.“

“The pizza at Louie’s Pizzeria & Restaurant in Carle Place is honestly the best I’ve had in a very long time. Thin crust and crispy! I was there twice 2 days in a row this week alone for a pizza lunch… and I live 40 mins away! The pizza is truly worth the drive! I rate this place A+ Five Stars.“

“I’ve lived in both nyc and long island. And Gino’s is hands down the best pizzeria I’ve gone to. The food is incredibly delicious, always fresh and always on point. I moved to Florida about a year ago but whenever I come back to visit I order Gino’s literally every night that I’m here, it’s just that good!! Customer for life here ?“

“Service is excellent. Staff is courteous and friendly. Food is terrific. Everything is fresh and delicious. This restaurant never disappoints. Best Italian wedding soup I ever had. Had balsamic chicken mashed potatoes and asparagus tonight absolutely delicious. Tenederist chicken ever. Service is always top notch. My go to for delicious Italian food“