What are you looking for?

Pizza Restaurants in New Hyde Park

4.2 - 152 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

2085 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 354-2354

Papa Johns Pizza

Best pizza ever , best driver’s in long island are working in that place I’m 100% sure More reviews

4.1 - 190 votes

Hours: Closed today

2048 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 354-9780

Papa Johns Pizza

Solid pizza pie. It's super thin. The prosciutto was a delicious addition, and the staff are super friendly.Definitely coming back. More reviews

4.2 - 85 votes

Hours: 7AM - 6PM

1632 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 326-8509

Papa Johns Pizza

I was extremely disgusted when I saw two workers making out on the station where they cut our meats. It’s disgraceful. They are not clean at all and I’ve... More reviews

3.9 - 590 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 9:30PM

633 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park
(516) 437-7698

Papa Johns Pizza

The food was amazing; So much flavor, we were overwhelmed. The ambiance and dining room, is another story; It can use some sprucing up. The bathrooms are... More reviews

4 - 136 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

1598 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 358-2010

Papa Johns Pizza

The place it’s self it’s Nice the Food was Good My Only Problem was The Old Spanish Guy that Works Picking up the Phone didn’t wanted to Give me Salad ju... More reviews

4 - 91 votes

Hours: 10AM - 8PM

2054 Lakeville Rd, New Hyde Park
(516) 326-2953

Papa Johns Pizza

If you’re ever in the area of New Hyde Park and you’re in the mood for pizza this spot is a place you need to try. I recommend one of their specialty sli... More reviews

3.6 - 162 votes

Hours: 10AM - 9PM

1113 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park
(516) 488-1366

Papa Johns Pizza

Love it. It’s a big slice of pizza with load of meat and cheese. Big plate with reasonable price i would say. More reviews

3.4 - 148 votes

Hours: 12 - 10PM

673 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 326-7879

Papa Johns Pizza

I got a regular slice and it wasn’t good at all, the dough was as thick as the crust. Too doughy and chewy that it takes away from any flavor the sauce a... More reviews

3.2 - 81 votes

Hours: 11AM - 12AM

909 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 437-8000

Papa Johns Pizza

Gets the job done when you're hungry. Don't compare to coal fired or brick oven pizza but what do you expect for $13.99 large pie with 5 toppin... More reviews

2.4 - 138 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 1AM

1017 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park
(516) 775-0254

Papa Johns Pizza

The variety of food offered by this restaurant is great! They also value their customers, always making sure that our needs are met and we are happy with... More reviews

View on map