What are you looking for?

Pizza Restaurants in New Hyde Park

4.3 - 152 votes

2085 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 354-2354

Papa Johns Pizza

Literally, Best pizza in the area! This is our go to place get the pizza, at least once a week.Food: 5/5 More reviews

4.1 - 185 votes

2048 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 354-9780

Papa Johns Pizza

Eddie’s an all time classic pizza place and bar. The inside vibes are an old school little pizza joint. And their bar pies are a must, super thin and cri... More reviews

4.2 - 87 votes

Hours: 7AM - 6PM

1632 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 326-8509

Papa Johns Pizza

Horrible service, the owner is a horrible human being who doesn’t know how to treat customers. The sandwich I ordered tasted spoiled, when notified I was... More reviews

3.9 - 597 votes

633 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park
(516) 437-7698

Papa Johns Pizza

We went to Umberto’s last night with friends for a kickoff dinner to start the holiday season. The place was packed but the service was top notch. Our ... More reviews

4 - 133 votes

1598 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 358-2010

Papa Johns Pizza

We usually go for take out.the food is excellent. We are never disappointed whit what we order. It's good ? to have places like this.Angoletto is ou... More reviews

4 - 90 votes

2054 Lakeville Rd, New Hyde Park
(516) 326-2953

Papa Johns Pizza

If you’re ever in the area of New Hyde Park and you’re in the mood for pizza this spot is a place you need to try. I recommend one of their specialty sli... More reviews

3.6 - 158 votes

1113 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park
(516) 488-1366

Papa Johns Pizza

Was feeling under the weather after Thanksgiving so I had soup. YOU MUST TRY THE FISH SOUP! Delicious and satisfying. Calamari and shrimp with a very tas... More reviews

3.4 - 146 votes

Hours: 12 - 10

673 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 326-7879

Papa Johns Pizza

Great staff that is friendly and fast service. Just remember it is cash only. Been going here for years. Great pizza More reviews

3.1 - 83 votes

Hours: 11AM - 1AM

909 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 437-8000

Papa Johns Pizza

Gets the job done when you're hungry. Don't compare to coal fired or brick oven pizza but what do you expect for $13.99 large pie with 5 toppin... More reviews

2.4 - 142 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 2AM

1017 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park
(516) 775-0254

Papa Johns Pizza

Want to hear how this dominos lost a $1,500+ order? Well here we go. I was tasked with preparing to cater pizza for a holiday party for approximately 400... More reviews

View on map