8 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Hyde Park

Previti Pizza & Papazzio Dining Pizza • $$
2085 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Linguini Carbonara with Bacon Peas & Onions in a Light Cream Sauce
Artichoke Spinach Focaccia Square Slice
Artichoke Spinach Focaccia Pizza Slice
Classic Cheese Focaccia Pie
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Eggplant Rollatini
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Francaise
Papazzio Tuscany

“Our goto place when we’re hungry and nothing comes to mind. Where the food is excellent, and there are plenty of delicious choices of pizza and pasta’s, the prices are good, but the employees are all friendly and go out of their way to make sure your dining experience is top shelf.Thanks to allParking: Plenty of parking either in the front or back“

4.7 Superb44 Reviews
Eddie's Pizza Pizza • $$
2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Onions and Peppers
Chicken Wings to Die For
Bar Pie with Meatball
Mozzarella Sticks
Everything Pizza
Pizza Skins Pie
Eddie's Special
Chicken Wings
Plain Bar Pie
Garlic Bread

“This place is a slice of nostalgia for me. The inside is very much a bar, which is why they serve (and specialize) in bar pie. Service has always been decent, nothing to complain about, but nothing stand-out either. The pizza is thin and crispy. It eats light, even with toppings. My favorite topping is probably their meatball, which they thinly slice. It goes great with their sauce. Don't get me wrong though, a regular cheese pie is great too. It's also only 270 calories. You can't really beat that. There's some debate over whether it's been open since the 30's or 40's. No matter how you look at it, it's been around for a long time and a long time for a reason, a very solid bar pie.“

4.2 Good89 Reviews
Angoletto Pizzeria Pizza • $$
1598 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Each Additional Topping on a Whole Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Grandma Sicilian
Fried Calamari
Slice of Pizza

“These are genuinely good and caring people. They are willing to go off menu to satisfy their customers and the servers are attentive yet not overbearing. Food is exactly what I would have found in a 70s pizza place in Brooklyn except with a much wider and varied menu. I like this place a lot.“

4.2 Good55 Reviews
Alessio Pizzeria Pizza • $$
2054 Lakeville Rd, New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Slice and Sausage Pizza
Grilled Chicken
Garlic Knot

“Although the atmosphere is average, the staff there are overall nice and chill. I ordered an 8 pc of barbecue wings for $9.80, and they were GREAT. The wait time was 20 min. The usual sides with barbecue wings (celery and carrots) were fresh and juicy. The wings itself were cooked nicely, of course weren’t dry, but juicy. For those of you that don’t like how chicken are sometimes slimy or have a slippery texture, the wings that are sold here don’t have that texture. For my fellow gym people, the food here are great for bulking up. For those of you that want to eat on a diet… well, I’m sure they have some vegetarian options that contain fresh vegetables. The pizza they have and the knots all look delicious.Go try their food! Always live your life with great quality.“

4.1 Good25 Reviews
Umberto's Of New Hyde Park Pizza • $$
633 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Margarita Pizza Italian Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Marsala
Margherita Slice
Sicilian Pizza
Fried Calamari
Grandma Pie
Baked Clams
Pizza Pie
Tiramisu

“Reading these reviews wondering did I make a mistake? Is this a franchise ? Really ? Pizza from here is always fantastic and I am from Brooklyn . Old shool and I just had a slice LOVE IT ! I hope some one reads this that is looking for the Best New York pizza come here hands down. I ordered Baked Ziti to take home hope it is not a mistake I already are the slice three words if I may off the hook.“

3.8 Good181 Reviews
Piccolo Gourmet Italian • $
1632 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

“I don't know why I've never noticed "Piccolo Gourmet" before; I mean I'm in area a lot. It wasn't till someone told me to go, that I noticed it. But, I was hungry and a hero from Piccolo was on the menu. There was plenty of parking outside, and looking from the parking lot, at the building, I had a feeling, this place was going to be worth the trip. Inside, didn't disappoint, it was as beautiful on the inside as it was on the outside. Organized, clean, and big, that's everything this deli slash pizzeria represents. Even better than the building was the staff. They were extremely friendly and helpful. The lady at the cash register more so. They didn't have something I wanted, so she was ready to check in the basement for me. I kindly told her "No thanks" but she still wanted to look for me anyway. After telling her, it's fine, she finally relented. My hero and egg salad were done, so I left. Mental note; I have to go back. I ate my hero without taking a picture. Was it because I was so hungry, or am I slipping with Yelp? I like to think I was hungry. The hero was fresh and delicious. I did have the sense to snap a shot of the egg salad, also delicious. So all said and done, this is a place I would recommend if you were in the area. Just take time and snap a photo before you eat...maybe take one for me.“

4 Good20 Reviews
Gino's Trattoria & Pizzeria of New Hyde Park Pizza • $$
1113 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti with Meatballs
Homemade Tiramisu
Garlic Knot Pizza
Homemade Zeppoles
New Hyde Park
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Plain Cheese

“We've been getting pizza from Gino's for a few months now and it's gotten to the point that if we're offered pizza from anywhere else, we ask if they've ever had Gino's. It's not "traditional New York pizza", it's better! The seasoning you normally add to a plain slice, is added to the pizza during the cooking process. For god sales, they have perfected the garlic knot pizza!!!“

3.8 Good58 Reviews
Gigi's Pizza Pizza • $
673 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parm Hero
Garlic Bread
Garlic Knots
Marsala

“my pizza club randomly choose this pizzeria to visit and we were blown away. Rudy, is the man. There was about 6 of us and he treated our group with a 5 star restaurant service. He was attentive and knowledgeable about the pizza. he recommended the house salad with avocado and homemade balsamic dressing, truly amazing. the salad and dressing almost stole the show. Then our group had the plain, buffal chicken, grandma, chicken bacon ranch Pies. Everyone had their favorite pies. All really delicious. Rudy constantly checking in on us, we had real utensils and plates and he cleared the table. We asked about the pizza sauce because it tastes different and Rudy confirmed he made special sauce. This place is a true find. Our group loved it. Be back! Thanks Rudy!“

3.5 Good64 Reviews
Loading...

New Hyde Park’s Other Flavors

map Map