15 Best Italian Restaurants near Catskill

“This is THE BEST pizza!!! I won't go anywhere else, even if they were closer than Vesuvio. Not only is the pizza (regular & sicilian) great, the owner is so nice! Definitely a 5 star rating! ***I forgot to mention the prices are great too!!!“

“Delicious garlic knots, pizza, beer. Great staff, service. Our go to every time we’re in the area. Excellent!“

“EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICE
Donna & Nyrel the Wait Associates are absolutely amazing, welcoming, friendly. Hadn't been there in over 25yrs(showing my age-LOL) felt like home again, the Chef (forgot his name) made an amazing meal was great!. Me & my hubby celebrating our wedding anniversary ❤️ 27yrs together & they made it so special 💖 going to try to make it a tradition. GOD BLESS 🙌
BTW-we showed up close to closing & they still had the energy to provide excellent Customer Service 👍“

“I went to Pomodoros for lunch with some family members, and overall it was a really good experience. Everything we tried—from the salads to the entrées—was well prepared and flavorful. The sausage rolls and the burger especially stood out, and everyone at the table seemed to genuinely enjoy their meals.

It is a little on the pricey side, but honestly that’s pretty typical for dining out these days. Considering the quality of the food and the overall experience, it felt worth it. I’d definitely come back again.“

“Celebrated my birthday here yesterday and I was in heaven! The staff was attentive and fun, friendly. The atmosphere, food,and drinks are a 10/10 the wait staff brought out a cupcake with a candle for me without being asked and really went above and beyond!“

“Best pizza in Catskill, we stop in every time we visit N.Y“

“Amazing food, Top Notch service beautiful decor and the best dinner music! Very highly recommend!!“

“This place is the best around the owner and Chef are top-notch. I highly recommend this place.“

“I just had Mirabella’s cater my husband‘s 70th birthday. Let me tell you the food was so good and very good quality. Brandon did an awesome job price was very reasonable and everybody loved it. We had lots of leftovers so if you were going to have a party, I highly would recommend this place called Mirabella’s and asked for Brandon. He’s a great guy. He will take care of you. I am giving him 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I ordered dinner last night since it was too hot to cook and everything was really good. Their sauce is fantastic! I got a chicken parm sub that was full of chicken and the best chicken parm I've ever had. We always get the vegan pizza for my boyfriend. It's awesome that they have that option(even if it doesn't have vegan cheese.) And they always give a ton of fried dough. They give you plenty of food and it all tastes fresh and amazing 👏“

“We played at Anthony's last night for a private event. If you are looking for a very clean, friendly, great food, and an absolutely beautiful place to have your event, we highly recommend it. Anthony is a great guy, and the staff was amazing too! It's very spacious. Even the restrooms were very big compared to most places. Not to mention there were 3 types of soap in the bathroom. We hope to play there again!“

“love their meatballs.their sandwiches. ordering a pizza for my birthday to night.“

“I stopped in for a couple of slices on my way to Middleburgh. Didn't expect much but figured they had to be better than McDonald's and it most certainly was.

Pizza slices were perfect and the flavor was great. The service was prompt and my appetite was satiated. I will definitely stop back in when I am on my way through upstate again.“

“I had an amazing meal this past Monday at two brothers Pizza deli when I was there with my family. I’m from Oregon and on the West Coast. They’re just aren’t many restaurants that offer good Italian style food. My cousin recommended this place because she had ate there before over the years, and I automatically felt like I was family when I went there to eat. I had the chicken Parmesan with ziti as a side pasta dish, and it was amazing. I had asked for a little butter to go with my bread and the owner kind of giggled but gave it to me and my cousin reminded me that Italian restaurants the sauce that they give you is for dipping. It was all good though. I definitely want to go back and eat at two brothers pizza and deli. The next time I come back to the mid Hudson Valley. I definitely think the service and the food at this place is amazing.“

“My go to pizza place. Any time I’m in town, I stop in. The five cheese pizza is awesome!“