Gather at the St Elmo
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$$ •
1 Pratt Ave, Chautauqua
(716) 237-7029
About Gather at the St Elmo
Gather at the St Elmo Reviews
The Barada and farmers market salad are some of the best you’ll find anywhere! And the key lime pie is the most delicious dessert within 20 miles! If you haven’t tried intermezzo, for whatever reason, like the crazy name, social club, you are missing a bet I mean a delicious dinner!
Not our best last ditch effort. Had planned another restaurant that was over booked so wandered in. Gives VFW vibes and the food was not so hot. Small portions, basic (not in a good way) ingredients. Ordered salmon which was freezer quality at best and “ Wagyu beef” that may have previously moonlit at Applebees. The best part were the McDonald’s style French fries. The bartender was super kind, even with it being her first night. Was hoping for a better experience
We just had a phenomenal dinner at Intermezzo and we could not be more pleased. The service was the best we have experienced in Chautauqua ( and outside of CHQ). The specialty cocktails were all delicious and well crafted. We had an appetizer of tuna tacos that was huge and flavorful. One of us had the shrimp “cargots “ (also a app)which was accompanied by two huge slabs of bread for dipping. Two of us had the shrimp and grits which was divine. One person had the buratta...read full review
Menu
People in Chautauqua Also Viewed
Gather at the St Elmo offers a pleasant dining experience with a good variety of dishes, including appetizers, salads, pizza with cauliflower crusts, and entrees. The menu is small but satisfying, featuring favorites like the Psycho Shroom pizza and baked goat cheese. The Barada and farmers market salad are highly recommended, as is the key lime pie, considered the most delicious dessert nearby. The service is friendly and courteous, making large parties feel welcome. While the restaurant is known for its atmosphere, history, and social setting, the food adds to the overall experience. The owner is friendly and engages with guests, enhancing the welcoming vibe. Gather at the St Elmo is a great choice for a nice dinner in a charming environment.