44 Best Pizza Restaurants near Circleville

“I had pizza from this place for the first time and “OMG”, it was one of the best pizzas I’ve had!! The dough was crunchy and crispy. It was thick but airy the crust was a French bread homestyle taste. It felt as if I was eating a homemade dish made by grandma! I’m not from around there. My son went to the barber shop next door and decided to get some pizza to bring home. We live about 40 min away and this place by far is the best pizza place. This became our pizza spot!!“

“Pizza & service was great! I recommend trying the chicken bacon ranch slice!“

“We were staying at the Legoland hotel this week and for our last night we wanted to play it easy and relax instead of going out or getting anything from the buffet. After looking on door dash, we saw this spot come up for pizza and searched for the website to order direct. I called and placed an order for their family special (cash only), but hands down it was absolutely worth it. So delicious and one of our picky eaters enjoyed the food too. Would absolutely order again and strongly recommend for families staying at the hotel looking for something different and easy.“

“Ordered Maria’s Rice con Dondulos and Pegnil. Wow! Keep an eye on their Facebook page for this occasional special! It is primo Puerto Rican fare!“

“Great atmosphere delicious food. Everything is freshly made, and the owner are humble sincere people will sit down and talk to you. Great place to go eat.“

“Delicious New York pizza 🍕 I was exploring the area and searched Maps for pizza joints. This one was close the the area I was photographing and highly rated, so I stopped in and placed an order!
The interior is classic pizza restaurant. The service was fast and friendly, answered my menu questions. Wait was relatively short and the pizza was served hot with gooey cheese 😁
I decided to eat on a table outside the shop and enjoy the people watching.
I forget which slices I ordered, but do know that one had potatoes. Both had chicken and peppers. Both slices were delish 😋
If you're in the area, definitely give them a try 💯“

“Delicious food! Great service.“

“I’ve been going to Mike’s Deli and Pizza since I was little, like, really little. So yeah, I’m a little biased—but honestly, it’s easy to see why it’s stuck around.

They’re a bit pricey, not crazy, but you’re paying for quality. The meats are solid, the subs are good, and the pizza? Definitely good.

For a pizza shop, it’s run by actual Italians—well, Italian-Americans—but you can tell they know what they’re doing.

The owner, Mary Ann, is a very sweet lady. She’s always treated me nice. Overall, it’s a reliable spot, and I can’t imagine going anywhere else for deli or pizza around here.“

“My first time here and it won’t be my last. I described a salad I was in the mood for and he the owners made exactly that. It was fresh and delicious. I recommend this restaurant and look forward to returning and trying different dishes.“

“Our family was looking last minute for a place to have a family dinner to celebrate our daughter’s ninth birthday after our original reservation fell through at another place. Pelligrinos is our favorite pizza spot so I called them. It was 5:30PM on a Friday night and I asked if they could accommodate our party of nine at 7:00. They were happy to prepare a table for us! I was shocked. They brought us the most incredible plate antipasto and placed it in front of our daughter and said happy birthday! Then we have the most delicious apps, pizza and an incredible pasta special for dinner. We couldn’t have been happier! They then brought complimentary fried dough for dessert for the table! What an incredible experience! We were so grateful that they not only came to our rescue at that late hour, but they went above and beyond to make sure we had a great night. If you want a five star experience with both food and service, go to Pelligrinos!“

“I was craving some real pizza. Not the chain stuff like Dominos or Pizza Hut. I've tried all the others and I drove past Bella Lenas and stopped in. i had guests at home so I ordered the XL pie, half buffalo half cheese pizza. the pizza was slamming. Not drowning in sauce and just the right amount of everything. Everyone loved it. And it's a family business. Big plus in my book. The owners were wonderful.“

“best all around“

“Brother Bruno's Pizzeria is a great restaurant with many choices for tasty Italian dishes. Today, I bought the chicken parmesan for my husband. It was huge, delicious and very hot, so we knew it was freshly made! You will not go wrong with any purchase you make at this pizzeria! The prices are extremely reasonable. Thank you Brother Bruno's!“

“Firstly, they were open on Labor Day so kudos for that! Secondly, I ordered a large cheese pie tonight it was done right around the time they said it would be, I picked it up and they threw a few zeppole to me on the house to go with it! Staff was friendly, price was good and the pizza was awesome and the zeppole not bad either would def recommend!“

“We had a “mistake pizza” another customer didn’t want…. Let me tell you that was the most delicious pizza I’ve ever had!😍😍😍😍😍“

“Soprano’s is amazing. Highly reccomend trying!! Staff are great and friendly. Fast but fresh, awesome pizza and awesome food.“

“Good job for driving and fast!!!And good pizza“

“Caputo’s chicken cutlet gets a 6/10—mediocre when fresh, with a buffalo chicken taste that clashed with the veggies, but oddly better when cold. Their pizza’s solid, a go-to for me, but the rice and beans were bland yet still satisfying. Reliable spot, but not without its flaws.

I always get it delivered“

“I was at the resturant and to my opinion this was the worse ribeye I’ve ever had in the last few years,don’t say that it’s a ribeye if it’s not, whoever made this steak was either new or just didn’t know a ribeye,I would never eat a steak there again and I’ve eaten there a long time.Never“

“Best pizza ever Frank is always smiling 😃“

“A HUGE THANK YOU to Siena’s Pizzeria & Restaurant!!!! I ordered various full pan and half pan dishes along with a 3’ sub for my son’s 30th birthday party 9/22/24. Everything was absolutely delicious and guests raved about the food! Great & friendly staff! 10/10!!!“

“Great food and service. Went on a Sunday for lunch. The gnocchi was delicious, as was the smash burger. We will be back.“

“They are friendly and accommodating, I called a little after six on Christmas eve and found out they closed at six, however they assured me it was ok and took my order and had it ready right away. They went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of with hot delicious pizza and cookies! Thank you.“

“We have been going here since we moved to Middletown in 2016. Hands down the best pizza place in Middletown. Donaldo and his team are awesome!“

“We love Napolis! The food is great and everyone is so friendly. They greet you the second you walk through the door and everyone is always so happy to help, which isn't always the case everywhere.“

“I am so Addicted to this place great food sweet people don't take my word order from them everything is so good and I'm very picky“

“Best food, I hardly recommend this place!!!! Very friendly. LOVE IT 😍“

“one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. We came on vacation from Maine and wanted pizza.Seen this spot while shopping. glad we did. highly recommend 👌“

“Great pizza— get the XL! Sandwiches w/Boar’s Head, the best. Keep an eye out for amazing weekly specials! Super friendly, too.“

“Highly recommend Carlos Cucina in Goshen,NY. The food is wonderful, they have gluten free options, their staff is very friendly and attentive, and the restaurant has a bright and welcoming atmosphere.“

“My husband and I went there today for lunch and omg sooo good we got pizza we got cake we got it alll lol all of it was delicious“

“Very good food. Healthy options“

“Usually the food is very yummy… and normally I would give 4-5 stars. I think they had an off night tonight and our pizza was kinda crappy… every slice had big bubbles… one slice was just one big bubble with no sauce or cheese. Fried dough and fried Oreos were yum though!“

“amazing service. amazing food. would travel to NY again just for this pizza.“

“Food is amazing! Fast service and possibly the best Bacon, egg & cheese sandwich I’ve ever had! Kudos for having a generator and not skipping a beat when the power goes out!“

“I mean it’s little Caesar’s
You know the expectations
But this place is respectful clean and love coming here when I go up state and need some pizza
Show some love if your a local
And
Out of respect give this place a 8.5/10 not cause I hate it
Just cause it’s little Caesars and I gotta be honest with the people“

“I would totally recommend this family business. Right from the very beginning we were welcomed in with open arms. They are super friendly. The appetizers was delicious- we had cheese -garlic bread and mozz sticks. The meals were so good and you could taste the freshness in the chicken parm and the meatballs were everything and more!!! Our server, Jennifer was a sweetheart. She was super friendly and just so nice. You feel like you are home. I’ve always ordered to go but dining is a great experience. It felt great supporting local in that way. Thank you for your service.“

“It was my first time coming here and I loved it! I got a plain slice and it was larger than any slice I’ve ever gotten and also for a good price. Besides that, the cheese and sauce were flavorful and the crust underneath has a great crisp with each bite. It’s my new fav place to grab a slice“

“I was in Middletown, on my way home ordered 4 large pies, calamari, fries on one of the hottest days of the year and the pizza looked and tasted just right . I ate 4 slices, had to stop myself !!! Calamari was light and crispy, the people are so nice I’ll go back again“

“Greatest Stromboli and pizza“

“Writing this review because just like last year. I wrote a bad review.. Because the pizza and the service was horrible. This year. You must be under new management. Because I just got a delivery and a pizza was excellent it was so fresh thank you very much and the delivery was super quick hats off to you.“

“Customer service was 100 and food prep and quickness was also 100. The cook and the cashier were super friendly and I would definitely go back again. Food is great, couldn’t put it down.Its like buying halal from the food trucks in NYC but it’s an actual restaurant you can sit down at. Definitely recommend! Also it not expensive and you get a good amount of food.“

“I order and white pizza with broccoli. It was absolutely delicious. Thank you so much. I live in the hills will definitely be back.“

“Maybe it depends who's working at that time. I placed an order for penne with sausage and one with meat sauce for my husband .
It was ready when we got there, and still hot when we got back to the campground at Spring Glenn.
The Employees will make or break the business.“