14 Best Italian Restaurants in Commack

“The food is out of this world. The servers are professional and patient. My husband and I felt great, relaxed and we were able to talk unlike other restaurants that you can't hear people on your table.“

“Delicious home cooked Italian food. Relaxing warm and cosy atmosphere.“

“Great consistent food. Priced very fairly. Great atmosphere. Enjoy seeing Todd O and Richie. It's like the 90s and Sprats. We are just missing Danny S.“

“Service was outstanding!!! Nice atmosphere.. First time there, food was amazing definitely going back..“

“We walked in and immediately were welcomed by a warm, smilng, cheerful gentleman who took our order. It was after 4pm, so there were some people in the restaurant, but the counter was busy with customers coming in and out picking up orders. We had a simple meal of 2 Sicilian slices with Coca Cola. All was excellent and tasty. We took a menu as we left. We plan on either Frederick take out, or go back.“

“Every time I come, I’m always welcomed. The food is excellent. The service is excellent. The atmosphere is extremely nice for a pizza place with a restaurant. Consistent which is also something that’s not normal these days.“

“Delicious!! Tried a bunch of different slices. Can’t wait to try their catering. Give them a try! 🍕“

“We have enjoyed several of their pasta dishes and we are in love with their Grandma Pizza , the most delicious we have ever had“

“Fantastic Food! My nephew ordered from here for my sisters bday dinner and food was yummy😋 thank you!!!!“

“Food and service were incredible! our waitress Vita was the best!“

“This is probably one of the best, most caring, and conscientious restaurants that I have ever had the pleasure of dealing with. They are affiliated with Too Good To Go so they are super conscious of food waste and helping out their community which is how I came to know of this place. I ordered their Surprise Bag. It was full of amazing food. The first visit was 6 slices of specialty pizza and a dozen knots. Every single item was well made and delicious. My second visit was a tough one and not because of this wonderful place but they made sure that I not only walked away happy and satisfied, but amazing well-fed. I was having a terrible time trying to get Uber to do my pick-up, it just wouldn't go through. My friend called them and said would you please just put our order outside and we will have someone get it (as they were at closing time). Instead the staff went above and beyond. They personally delivered my order and not only that but gave me this abundance of food I was incredibly grateful for. They have definitely earned my loyalty. I will forever be a customer here because their skill in the kitchen, their kindness, generosity, and understanding is an example to us all and deserves to be supported.“

“I never typically write reviews but I felt absolutely compelled to with the incredible service I received, the bartender Madison was incredibly helpful and attentive, not to mention the drinks were fantastic, my only complaint is that I’m sure the service I received today will ruin any other experience with waiters/ waitresses and bartenders in the future. 6/5 stars will 100% be returning“

“Everything was perfect 👌🏻 its a must try spot, once you do you will never go any where else for pizza!“

“We ordered takeout from Emilio's and the experience is just as good as dining-in. We had a chicken parm dinner and a chicken francese dinner. They were both outrageous. The flavor and the amount you get is unbelievable. Looking forward to dining-in soon as well.“