Browse menus, reviews and photos of New American Restaurants near Fire Island.
Bistros · $$$
159 Dock Walk, Cherry Grove
Customers’ favorites
“There are many good things to say about this restaurant. Bottom line, the food is outstanding. Best quality ingredients makes everything taste so delicious 😋”
New American · $$$
67 West Main Street, Patchogue · 10.62 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Excellent Brunch for Mother’s Day! We never go out to eat on Mother’s Day as the restaurants are usually too overwhelmed. I am so glad we came to Shands General this year. The service was excellent and everything was extremely coordinated. The food was delicious and our party of 6 had a great time. Highly Recommend!”
New American · $$$$
135 Maple Ave, Bay Shore · 6.82 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Yesterday I had my daughter’s bridal shower at the Lakehouse. The event coordinator, Annalisa was a pleasure to work with. ALL of my guests raved about the food, service and atmosphere. Some of the men stayed and Annalisa set them up outside on the deck for lunch instead of inside the bar since it was a beautiful day. She also suggested having dessert served outside which could not have been better. My guests enjoyed the beautiful view and all of the outdoor seating. I would highly recommend having an event here.”
American · $
298 West Main Street, Bay Shore · 7.44 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I just had another amazing lunch at Zest. The portions are VERY generous and the food is always amazing. The chef is a culinary artist.”
New American · $$$
124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore · 6.84 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Love John the bartender. Great food and atmosphere”
Bar · $$$
5 Third Avenue, Bay Shore · 7.43 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Been here a couple of times. Once on a date night Thursday with my wife, another time for birthday party on a Saturday night with DJ C Natryl. He created a sick vibe. Can't wait to come back to hear him play again!! Nice little room that really is a gem. :)”
American · $$
45 Foster Ave, Sayville · 6.94 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My new favorite restaurant! Everything is delicious and the staff is incredible.”
American · $$
298 West Main Street, Sayville · 6.5 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The food is always fresh and deliciously prepared. Staff and owners are very friendly and accomodating for dietary restrictions (gluten free). Good bar too.”
Cocktail Bar · $$
64 East Main Street, Bay Shore · 7.38 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Thank you Gabby and Anthony for being the best service oriented hosts. Great drinks and comversation.”
American · $$
927a Montauk Highway, Oakdale · 6.44 miles
Customers’ favorites
“update below: Went for a Disney bingo which was so fun but we ordered a special on the board (both the same) and we both got sick. I wrote and email expressing my concern , which they responded quickly and tried connecting on the phone but they dropped the ball and did not respond to my follow up call nor my follow up email week has gone by. It’s nice in there I would’ve considered returning. Tim, the manager called again and we had a nice conversation that I much appreciated. Offered gift card which was very kind. Sometimes things happen, if I business is willing to make it right and show humility it’s a good business. I’ve updated this review in high hope of returning and having a good experience and updating to 5 stars!”
Pubs · $$
255 Blue Point Ave, Blue Point · 9.23 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I have to visit when I’m the area. Very cozy and friendly place. The food is great!”
Fine Dining · $$$
41 E Main St, Bay Shore · 7.41 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Delicious cocktails and food! We all had a difficult time deciding on a meal, everything sound so good! Friendly helpful staff, would totally recommend!”
New American · $$
501 Montauk Hwy, Sayville · 7.86 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Haven’t had a burger that good in quite a while…”
American · $$
335 E Main St, East Islip · 6.22 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Service and cuisine was excellent. Staff was very friendly and eager to please.”
Seafood · $$$
500 Shore Drive, Oakdale · 5.49 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The food is delicious in large portions, waitress is attentive and knowledgeable, very nice atmosphere.”
Seafood · $$$
61 W Main St, Bay Shore · 7.39 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My Husband and I stumble across this place tonight and couldn’t be happier about it! From the moment we walked through the door on a busy Saturday night at 7:00pm we walk in simply based on a great name! The hostess Deanna was lovely and welcoming we were able to sit right away! The food was absolutely amazing and so were the drinks!! But the star of the show was the staff our waitress Emily was the best we have ever had! Just the right amount of attentive that we never looked for her and always felt taking care up. The busser also did an amazing job never a dirty plate on our table. We go out alot and I can’t remember the last time a restaurant covered it all flawlessly Service drinks and food. We have already texted friend excited to bring them here! Can’t wait to come back keep up the amazing work!”
American · $$
780 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach · 0.54 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Walk off the ferry in Ocean Beach and walk into the best restaurant on the Great South Bay. The location, service, and food are unsurpassed. The Curry Shrimp is spiced to perfection. It is a generous portion, but you will want more. Lunch or dinner is a Five Star experience.”
Hamburger · $
30 Hanson Pl, Sayville · 7.34 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The burgers are to die for!”
Irish Pub · $$
60 East Main Street, Bay Shore · 7.38 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Large bar, big place, lots of tv’s, great space upstairs for private events, cold 🍺 and great food = good times 💫”
Bar & Grill · $$
479 Bay Ave, Ocean Beach · 0.57 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Came here for Sunday of the holiday weekend. Great atmosphere and awesome service. There were two bartenders, both super friendly. The guy bartender was dressed in an awesome 4th costume, and made us the BEST rocket fuels. I would come again just for him. He made our experience amazing and was not only friendly but very accommodating. Come here!!!”
American · $$$
106 Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove · 3.05 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Location, location, location! Fabulous staff ! Fantastic food! Delicious cocktails what else could you ask for?”
Acai Bowls · $$
90 East Main Street, Patchogue · 10.64 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Just found out the cafe has a menu full of gluten free options and tried it out. Amazing place and food was delicious! They have gluten free toast, buns, soups, desserts. My husband was excited to be able to have so many choices in a beautiful restaurant. Thank you! We'll be back for sure!”
American · $$
82 Brightwood Street, Patchogue · 9.82 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Excellent food no matter what we order love the steak tidbits ..tried the shrimp tacos too !!! Drinks are great as well !!! Our new go to by the water !”
Chinese · $
3283 Sunrise Hwy North Service Road, Islip Terrace · 7.05 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Sui's is a solid choice for standard chinese- american food. As a spare ribs, broccoli and fried rice guy, I can say that Sui's does the 'regular' dishes aa well as pretty much anyone else - glad that they are my neighborhood chinese place.”
Bar · $$
49 East Main Street, Patchogue · 10.7 miles
Customers’ favorites
“While the food was very good, it was absolutely freezing in the restaurant which ruined the experience. Everyone in the restaurant was wearing their coats, and we couldn’t wait to leave 😡”
New American · $$$
641 Medford Ave #112, Patchogue · 12.23 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Hosted a Bridal Shower for my Niece/Goddaughter in March and everything from start to finish was amazing. Food was very tasty and plentiful. George helped us plan our menu he was very professional knowledgeable and very kind. Thanks George ,Staff and Ristegio’s for a GREAT DAY❣️❣️”
Bar & Grill · $$
327 River Ave, Patchogue · 9.88 miles
Customers’ favorites
“One of the greatest outdoor bar/ music venues since the 80s! You can tell the employees are happy to work there and they take pride in what they do. They have a small kitchen but they sure do have some great food!🍔 I've never had a bad meal there! You got to go check it out the place is a lot of fun! 🍸”