15 Best Cafes near Fishers Island

The West End Cafe • $
66 Hound Ln, Fishers Island

“Love this place! Makes me wish I didn't live so far away! Lily has a great thing going here, and her staff were lovely to my friends and I while we were on the island. The sandwiches and baked goods we tried were all good, and the whitefish dip was addictive. I'm excited to return!“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Food Arts Cafe Cafe • $$
810 Equestrian Ave, Fishers Island

Customers` Favorites

Cookie

“We enjoyed our food very much. Got the turkey club and the Jamie (roast beef). Came with a little cup of soup and it's great. Family run business and everyone is so nice. Even bought coffee beans which the owner selected the blend to take home.“

4.8 Superb5 Reviews
Dog Watch Cafe American • $$
194 Water St, Stonington - 8.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brownie Rockslide & Vanilla Ice Cream
Fish and Chips with Coleslaw
Scallops Wrapped in Bacon
New England Clam Chowder
Truffled Scallop Risotto
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Tuna Tartare Featured
Lobster Salad Roll
Whole Belly Clams
French Onion Soup

“02.12.25 'Big Al's Reel Reviews' dropped into a Spot located in the Town of Stonington called Dog Watch Cafe. I dropped in unannounced late this afternoon to find out if this spot is serving up Great food, great service with a great atmosphere. Absolutely everything about this place is amazingly Dope!! I absolutely loved the full experience from the service, the atmosphere and most importantly the delicious meal! Dog Watch Cafe is without a doubt a Top Notch restaurant! This place is Off The Hook!! 💣💣💣 Thank you Dog Watch Cafe 👍🏾 194 Water St. Town of Stonington, CT See you on the rebound, ☝🏾❤️- Big Al Mayo“

4.6 Superb897 Reviews
Dog Watch Mystic Barbeque • $$
20 Old Stonington Rd, Stonington - 7.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Platter with Cole Slaw Collard Greens and Cornbread
Smoked Fried Chicken Sandwich
Brisket Grilled Cheese
Dog Watch BBQ Nachos
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pulled Pork Nachos
NE Clam Chowder
Brisket Platter
Fish and Chips
Pickle Fries

“We had a baby shower for my daughter and son-in-law at the Dog Watch Mystic, and I could not be happier with them. The tent and grounds were perfectly appointed, the food was fantastic, and the entire staff was wonderful. Thank you, Dog Watch!“

4.5 Superb389 Reviews
Nana's Mystic Cafe • $
32 Williams Ave, Mystic - 7.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Nana's Hot Sourdough Doughnut
Seacoast Mushroom Flatbread
Mozzarella & Risotto Balls
Nana's Breakfast Sandwich
Mushroom & Egg Toast
Wild Mushroom Pizza
French Toast Sticks
Classic White Pizza
New England Pizza
Margherita Pizza

“Everything I've had at Nanas has been excellent! my favs are the drinks, risotto balls, pizza and hot donuts! The staff is the best!“

4.6 Superb165 Reviews
Somewhere In Time Cafe • $
3175 Gold Star Hwy, Mystic - 10.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Scrambled Eggs Home Fries with Bacon and Gluten Free Toast
Sausage Gravy on Sourdough Bread
Western Omelette Witn Homefries
Apple Cinnamon French Toast
Banana Bread French Toast
Toast and Home Fries
Breakfast Quesadilla
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Buttermilk Pancakes
Biscuits and Gravy

“Fantastic food! A must for breakfast and lunch! Fast service too!“

4.6 Superb150 Reviews
Lighthouse Bakery Bakery • $
21 E Main St, Mystic - 7.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Egg & Cheese w Bacon Ham Sausage
Sandwich on Ciabatta
Breakfast Sandwich
Breakfast Burrito
Raspberry Pastry
Tiramisu

“The Early Riser breakfast sandwich-💯“

4.7 Superb85 Reviews
Muddy Waters Cafe Cafe • $
40 Bank St, New London - 7.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Egg and Cheese
Half Sandwich and Soup
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Nova Lox Sandwich
Chocolate Chip
Iced Latte
Croissants
Lust Salad
Love Salad
Pastries

“Everything is exceptional!!! Food, atmosphere, and staff are the best!! Their coffee can’t be beat!!! Giovanni and the whole crew make it an awesome experience!!“

4.5 Superb136 Reviews
Mañana Cafe Cafe • $$
970 Poquonnock Rd, Groton - 6.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tex Mex Chicken Burrito with Black Beans
Chimichanga Chicken Burrito
House Made Chips and Salsa
Jalapeno Margherita
Chorizo Quesadillas
Chicken Chimichanga
Braised Pork Tacos
Chicken Taco Salad
Carne Asada Tacos
Enchiladas Verdes

“Food is always fresh, delicious, and quick. The atmosphere is friendly and laid. Try a mango jalapeños margarita!! (It’s not on the menu but it’s delicious)“

4.5 Superb83 Reviews
Mystic Depot Roasters Cafe • $
2 Roosevelt Ave, Mystic - 7.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Scrambled Eggs and Toast and Hash Browns
Draw Bridge Breakfast Burrito
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Breakfast Sandwich
Brownie Muffins
Cheesesteaks
The Mystic

“Great food, wonderful atmosphere and the staff are very friendly“

4.5 Superb68 Reviews
Indulge Coffee and Sandwich Co. Sandwich Shop • $
17 High St, Stonington - 8.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coffee Cake
New Yorker
Tuna Melt
Sandwich
Bagel

“Exploring the local area and yelp searched for a coffee shop and found this lovely little shop! Coffee was super delicious and the croissant sandwich was delish!! Sweet vibes here and super cute!“

4.4 Superb66 Reviews
The Yolk Cafe Cafe • $
825 Montauk Ave, New London - 5.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Peach Cobbler Stuffed French Toast
Banana Foster Stuffed French Toast
Apple Crisp French Toast
Pancake Eggs and Bacon
Andouli Shrimp Scramble
Chorizo Egg Scramble
Corned Beef Hash
Chorizo Scramble
Rueben Sandwich
Scrambled Eggs

“I went here with my family and let me tell you, it is the definition of FEEL GOOD PLACE! It is a cozy little cafe with 80’s or maybe earlier, handheld games spread throughout the cafe. While we waited we enjoyed playing many games I hadn’t played in years! While we were just chit chatting, all the sudden marshmallow come flying at us! My daughter thought it was so cool, we looked over to see one of the ladies shooting them from behind the counter. She came over a little while later to squirt ketchup and mustard at us, it was a prank but very funny! It was really just a string. To top it off, she brings a small claw machine so my daughter could play it and win some prizes. We found out that they feed squirrels that come up to the window, so we inquired and one of the women tried to get the squirrel to come so we could see it. Unfortunately it did not happen but honestly, just left feeling like my soul was warmed. The food was amazing! The coffee was hot and all the women working there were truly a delight! I wish I lived closer, I’d definitely become a regular. Best part- aside from taking some photos for memories, no one was on their phone. Just really enjoying the cafe and experience.“

4.2 Good121 Reviews
Washington Street Coffee House Coffee Shops • $
13 Washington St #1, New London - 7.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sesame Ginger Wrap with Mixed Green Onion and Carrot in a Whole Wheat Tortilla
Veggie Breakfast Burrito with Sauteed Veggies Scrambled Eggs and Goat Cheese
Breakfast Quesadilla
Breakfast Sandwich
Bahn MI Sandwich
Grilled Cheese
Caprese Salad
Egg Sandwich
Veggie Wrap
Bagel w Lox

“Tasty coffee! Highly recommend!“

4.5 Superb142 Reviews
Starbucks Cafe • $
220 12, Groton - 8.02 miles

“Kathie & Brittany were super friendly to all as we waited in a long long for our drinks.“

3.5 Good38 Reviews
Hamilton Street Market Deli • $
639 Broad St, New London - 9.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hamilton Heart Stopper
Pastrami Sandwich
Roast Beef Grinder
Turkey Sandwich
Cheese Burger
Chicken Cutlet
French Fries
Bacon Sub
Italian
Combo

“There is one thing and one thing only you're going to do here: Get an amazing grinder. Sure, they have other sandwiches that are good, and an array of breakfast items and homemade mayo-based salads that are also top-notch, but their grinders are legendary in an area that literally invented the grinder (really, look it up).

They're absolutely huge and crammed full of fresh ingredients. The mother-and-daughter team that runs the place are friendly and provide rapid fire service... necessary in a tiny place that routinely has lines out the door.

Be aware of the one drawback: Hamilton Market closes at 3 pm and does not open on weekends. This place is strictly breakfast and lunch, and most of the clientele consists of folks on their way to work or on their break. However, if you do want the magic of their grinders outside these hours, they do a big catering business too.“

4.9 Superb61 Reviews

You May Also Like