5 Best Cafes in Montauk

“Great vibe casual dining great smoothie and breakfast burrito 🌯 nice staff“

“By S. Carrelli: Naturally good looks just like a normal small grocery store from the outside but is much, much more than that.
Naturally Good sells all kinds of groceries that are super healthy… and some not so healthy. It is the perfect place to stop for weekly groceries, or a quick snack. They also sell fresh things at the checkout, and juices, coffee, and smoothies, all fresh and organic.
Along with that, they also have take out breakfast and lunch options, and they recently started doing dinner also on Fridays and Saturdays. Their food is very good, and it is great they do take out because they have the greatest outdoor seating area were they have benches and couches.
Some food options they have for breakfast, lunch, and dinner are the pancakes and the oatmeal with fresh fruit, the multigrain bread grilled cheese and cheese quesadillas, the curly red sauce pasta and barbecue ribs.
Naturally Good is the perfect example of a community grocery store, especially because all of their food is…. naturally good.“

“Acaí done right. The acaí is blended the proper way and remains thick, not soupy. The fruit is always fresh, the granola is always crisp.“

“The cutest little “grocery” store & cafe. It’s on the main drag in Montauk. They have plant based / vegan options. A bathroom, coffee (and non-vegan options for those who want eggs or fish). If you’re looking for a nicer vibe there are other more fancier spots, but for a nice meal, amazing service, and a comfy place to sit, this spot is great.“

“George’s Lighthouse stands as a charming coastal beacon, quietly telling stories of the past while offering serene views of the sea. Located in a picturesque setting, this lighthouse is more than just a navigation aid — it is a peaceful retreat for visitors who want to escape the rush of everyday life. The structure itself, though simple in design, has a timeless beauty. Its whitewashed walls and red-capped roof reflect classic maritime architecture that blends harmoniously with the surrounding natural scenery.

What makes George’s Lighthouse truly special is the calm atmosphere it creates. Whether it’s the sound of crashing waves, the occasional cry of a seagull, or the golden hue of the setting sun behind the tower, every moment spent here feels meditative. Visitors can climb to the top for a panoramic view of the coastline, and on clear days, the horizon seems to stretch forever.

Though not as famous as other lighthouses, George’s Lighthouse offers a more intimate and soulful experience. It's perfect for quiet walks, photography, or simply sitting on a nearby bench and watching the sea. Anyone seeking beauty, history, and peace by the shore will find George’s Lighthouse a hidden gem worth discovering.“