38 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fishers Island

“The Pequot is a very special place and Ian is a great manager“

“Pizza is great they are very friendly“

“I got the Fish and Chips last night 09/03/2024. Everything was cooked perfectly and the portions were quite big. I usually don’t get to have seafood because I moved down south near Asheville, NC but this place made one of my favorite meals (that I don’t get to have too often anymore) perfectly even the fries were cooked perfectly. Thank you very much!!“

“Not only is the food fantastic but they’re so hospitable friendly but they don’t invade when you’re eating just kind hearted people their love shows in their food please visit I try something different every time“

“My favorite ❤️ place for pizza“

“Ordered delivery on a taco pizza, pepperoni pizza, onion rings and a lb. of chicken tenders. Everything was made with fresh ingredients and tasted delicious. Delivery was fast. Highly recommend!“

“Amazing people, wonderful food. They make you feel like family“

“Great pizza, friendly service, 2 NY Slice Pizza Slices and a drink for 8 bucks, you can't beat that. Best Pizza Around!“

“Mystic Pizza has by far, some of the best pizza I've ever eaten. the staff was great and very friendly. Ask for Alex, she was wonderful.“

“I came in with my daughter today really just dying for a slice, we live in Niantic and were in the neighborhood and stopped by. This felt like home (originally born and raised in NY) the vibe of the people the atmosphere he knew almost everyone’s name walking in and genuinely seemed to have cared to give such good attention and service. The gentleman upfront took care of us, instead of a couple slices gave us a small pie and it was absolutely delicious. Definitely will Be back again !!“

“Best pizza I have had. The staff was amazing, pizza even better. Highly recommend The Rolling Tomato.“

“went to pick up a pizza a few weekends ago. i swear to god, the guy behind the counter must have been a magician because i watch him check out FOUR different pick up orders at the same time. i had to wait a bit for my order, but they were obviously insanely busy so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ i asked counter guy his name bc i wanted to include it in this review, but i've since forgotten (maybe nick?). regardless, 11/10“

“My first time here. Walked in and was greeted by several friendly ppl. Ordered a grilled cheese with tomatoes and fries (extra crispy pls). Took my order home and proceeded to eat it. Let me tell you something- that grilled cheese was DELICIOUS. It had been made with thick bread, nice and buttery with the perfect crunch when you take a bite ? grilled
to perfection! To boot, the fries where cooked perfectly! I’m looking forward to trying out the other food!“

“The food is always good and the staff always friendly and accommodating!“

“Had the Solis Special tonight. Fantastic!“

“Salt and pepper shakers were sticky and nasty to touch. Food is good otherwise. They need waitresses or waiters. Not the dude with a hoodie on all the time.“

“best pizza and wings in mystic“

“great food great customer service“

“The food was delicious and was made in a timely manner I ordered a BBQ chicken pizza and it was delicious“

“Great food and prices fresh food.😃“

“So good � the food is so good & it’s like home made healthy quality not like fast food quality �“

“Everything I've had at Nanas has been excellent! my favs are the drinks, risotto balls, pizza and hot donuts! The staff is the best!“

“Hands down some of the best food around, the pizza is perfect. Our new favorite place! We will be back!“

“Best pizza in the area no question.“

“01.03.25 Can you find Healing at The Recovery Room in the ❤️City of New London, CT❤️ This place earned two 💣💣!! My Hunger was healed and tamed at The Recovery Room Restaurant located at: 445 Ocean Ave. New London, CT ❤️ 'Big Al's Reel Reviews' Keeping it Real to Reel! ☝🏾❤️ -Big Al Mayo“

“I can really only give this a four out of five cause while I do like Papa John’s, there are some things that need to be pointed out. First time I ordered them was the day after 4th of July last year and I had no problems, but I recently ordered from them on DoorDash yesterday since they were nearby my girl’s place.

I ordered a garlic stuffed crust pizza and some wings for me, and a regular stuffed crust pizza with some breadsticks for my girlfriend. She had no problems with her food, but when I took the first three slices of my garlic stuffed crust, I don’t know if it was something with the pizza or not but my stomach felt a little weird. Every time I take slices of the garlic one, I always can’t help but wash my hands afterwards, which I could give a shit less about.

I later decided to eat my wings, and while they are decently enjoyable, they need to be tossed in more sauce. I had to grab BBQ sauce from my girl’s fridge and apply it to my wings, could give a shit less about that too, and it was a bit better. But these guys gotta toss their wings in more sauce. No one wants a dry wing.

On another note, when I ordered from them at the beginning of the year, I got the Chicken Parm Bites, which were ok, and the pizza sauce that came with them had a slight sweet tang, like lemon or something, which I honestly wasn’t fond of. And I don’t know if that’s the same sauce they also give with the breadsticks or not, but come on. We don’t want a sweet sauce with the breadsticks.

Will it be my last time ordering from them again? I don’t know, but for now, this gets a 4/5. (Subscribe to Doughtoli and DoughJoe)“

“Ordered a couple pizzas and enjoyed a beer at the bar while waiting. Staff was great, and the pizza is the best. Will go back often!“

“Rachel was very rude and unwilling to fulfill the needs of the customer. I used to work for Dominos and always gave the best service possible to fulfill all customers needs, worst service ever.“

“Easy location between New London and Waterford. Love ordering online and using pick up window. Never leave my car. Great for this busy mom. Food is always good. If not they make it fix it when I call. A+ service.“

“My husband and I live in Chesterfield VA (Rich)
Every year we come up to CT and have to come to our favorite Pizza place. I get spaghetti w extra meatballs and cheese. My husband always a grinder. The best is the rice pudding. Omgoodness the very best. We love the owner. He always has a big hug and the whole staff is wonderful. We always have a cooler full from Midway Pizza.
Bob & Tammy“

“I am simply obsessed with The Bridge. We came in last month for the first time, and have been back at least weekly since!! What a hidden gem- not only is the food delicious (the bagel and coffee rolls….. unbelievable) but the service is fantastic and staff are the absolute kindest. They truly care and go above and beyond for their customers. I can’t wait to keep coming back, and I’m so grateful we have such an awesome, family friendly food spot so close to our home!“

“Great service. Love the app.“

“The service was great, drinks were delicious and the pork chop….perfection!“

“cool comfortable. and the music is usually pretty good“

“Very nice place! Very friendly and helpful staff. The menu is interesting, lots of unique sundaes and flavors! Highly recommended 👌“

“The food is great and my family and I go at least once a week. All so the people that work there are great to. Love that place.“

“Osmino’s Grill is a gem of New London! The food is amazing, take out is always easy, the owners are the sweetest, and there is always something on the menu for everyone! Their pizza is awesome. I can’t say enough amazing things about this restaurant! 20/10 recommend!“

“We ordered for delivery while staying in a nearby hotel. The delivery man was very friendly and polite and the extras were delivered in a large reusable bag--helpful when traveling. The pizza was amazing--some of the best I've had with a unique flavor to the crust. Well done Gus's. Thanks for making our fun night in the hotel memorable and delicious.“