“Man, after a day hiking out east we were craving a slice. Luckily we were able to swing into the greatest little pizza place in Montauk. And it was a perfect pairing with some Montauk Brewing Company beers. The pepperoni square was absolutely delicious and we will be stopping here every time we are out at the end.“
“This was the last stop on my day trip to Montauk, and really capped the trip off perfectly.We started with the Bay scallop appetizer. Crispy greens, flavorful bruschetta, loads of bay scallops. Everything in the dish came together great.Now, most of the dishes are family style, but since we were here in the off-season, they had single size plates. We ended up splitting the short rib and the fish of the day dish. The short rib was extra tender and had great flavor. It came with a side of polenta and broccoli rabe. The broccoli rabe was really good, but the polenta was just okay. The fish dish was the winner here. The fish was crispy on the outside and super moist on the inside. It was seasoned lightly and cooked perfectly. The crispy Brussel sprouts it came with plated so well and tasted even better. The cheesy rizzoto was out of this world. It was so thick but had great flavor, and the cheese wasn't overpowering. I would come back for a bowl of that rizzoto itself.If you appreciate great food, with fantastic service, and a beautiful view, then this is the place to come.Parking: Small lot.“
“Pure perfection. Simple as that. Fun decorations for the holidays, a great staff, and the best pizza in the Hamptons! Worth driving to Montauk for. That margherita pizza is killer!!! Love it here!!!Hunter is the best there is and this pizza is better than any other pizza I’ve had in the world. Couldn’t recommend this place more!!!!!“
“Pizza Village is one of the places to go in Montauk. My husband has been coming here for the past 40 years while he goes fishing in Montauk. Whenever we come out, we stop by here for a quick lunch. For the winter months, it’s slow and currently under renovation, so we took out few slices.Spinach w mozzarella slice is awesome. Plain slice is ok. Over the years we tried many other dishes and they are consistently good.Pizza used to be bigger and seem to be smaller these days- that’s the only thing but overall they have best pizza in Montauk.“
“The place was packed when we were there but the pizzas were still served quickly. It's apparently not an old "dive bar" like you'd think but it's made to look and feel like one. Bring a Sharpie or two with you because they encourage you to leave your mark on the tables, walls or ceiling. Try the white pizza, which comes with a generous amount of ricotta and soft, caramelized onions.“
“We came here by accident last year. I really liked it! Now we went for a walk to the lighthouse and stopped here on purpose. Everything is very delicious! cozy atmosphere and pleasant music. From now on I will only recommend this place to everyone. ☺️“