33 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fishers Island

“The Pequot is a very special place and Ian is a great manager“

“I've been going to this place since I was a kid; roughly since I was 7. The Greek/Italian cuisine is and always was above par. Portions are healthy and robust. I had an appetizer of fried Smelts (Strictly a north East Coast Jam). Delicious, a bowl of 'Real' Clam Chowder: Smooth, creamy, savory - decadent (Tastes like home(New London). Had Broiled Haddock and baked potato as an entree. All that was needed afterwards was a coach.“

“Amazing people, wonderful food. They make you feel like family“

“Not only is the food fantastic but they’re so hospitable friendly but they don’t invade when you’re eating just kind hearted people their love shows in their food please visit I try something different every time“

“We had a great experience eating here last night! The food was excellent and the service was exceptional! Would highly recommend their pizza and garlic knots!!!“

“Great pizza, friendly service, 2 NY Slice Pizza Slices and a drink for 8 bucks, you can't beat that. Best Pizza Around!“

“We went here for the first time yesterday and it was amazing! Easily there best pizza crust I’ve ever had. The caramelized onion and mushroom pizza was absolutely delicious. You can tell all of the ingredients are super fresh and the flavor combos are well thought out. If you haven’t checked out this spot, you’re missing out!“

“Mystic Pizza has by far, some of the best pizza I've ever eaten. the staff was great and very friendly. Ask for Alex, she was wonderful.“

“Not being from the area I wasn't sure where to get a good pizza. I'm so happy I decided on supreme pizza! Everything about this place lives up to the name! SUPREME EVERYTHING! The pizza, the owner, the employees, the atmosphere and even the other customers! I will definitely go there next time I'm in the area! We really enjoyed our 1/2 and 1/2 pizza! Thanks to all of you! Karen“

“Everything I've had at Nanas has been excellent! my favs are the drinks, risotto balls, pizza and hot donuts! The staff is the best!“

“Best pizza I have had. The staff was amazing, pizza even better. Highly recommend The Rolling Tomato.“

“This is one of my favorite places! I love their cabbage grinders, so instead of shredded lettuce, I get shredded cabbage. It gives your grinder that extra crunch. Their grinder rolls are the best around here. They don't get soggy and they taste great!“

“Possibly the best pizza I've EVER eaten! 🍕“

“Ordered delivery on a taco pizza, pepperoni pizza, onion rings and a lb. of chicken tenders. Everything was made with fresh ingredients and tasted delicious. Delivery was fast. Highly recommend!“

“Amazing food, great people“

“Great lil hole in the wall spot place to get a bite w the family!“

“I made a discovery at The Recovery Room !!! A masterpiece !!!“

“The employees regularly greet the customers by name. The bagels, pizza and other delicious items on their menu are fantastic. I love the artwork and the music that plays on the stereo.“

“📅 09.16.25 WRITTEN REVIEW Big Al’s Reel Reviews - EP.163 🍕 Mango’s Wood-Fired Pizza Co. 💎 'Big Al's 💎 Gem Spot' Old Mystic Village, CT This afternoon I pulled up to the Village of Mystic straight from BMW of Warwick in my new BMW M850i Gran Coupe to see if Mango’s could raise the B.A.R.R... because I was hungry. And they absolutely did. In fact, this spot just became a Big Al’s 💎 Gem Spot. Here’s how it all went down: 1️⃣ Wood-Fired Wings (Buffalo) - $15.95 BOMB! 💣 Eight perfectly wood-fired wings- crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, with buffalo sauce that hits just right. The blue cheese dressing deserves its own shoutout 💣😎 2️⃣ Oma’s Real Meatball Sandwich- $17.50 BOMB! 💣 These wood-roasted, hand-rolled meatballs were full of flavor and smothered in rich pomodoro sauce, tucked inside toasted rustic bread with melted provolone and parmesan. It comes with potato chips and a fresh crunchy pickle. 3️⃣ Small Mango’s Mozzarella Pie- ½ Mozzarella/Funky Monkey- $19.95 💣 DOUBLE BOMB! The cheese half? The best cheese pizza I’ve had on this side of the Thames River, perfect crust, flawless sauce-to-cheese ratio. The Funky Monkey half? 💣💣 DOUBLE BOMB! The heat level was spot-on and the flavor combo was straight 🔥. Verdict: Mango’s brought the flavor, the service (big shoutout to my server Jessica, who was mad cool 😎 🙌🏾), and the vibes. This is officially a Big Al’s Gem Spot, and one I’ll be coming back to again. ☝🏾❤️ - Big Al Mayo “See you on the Rebound, Peace✌🏾out”“

“Great clam strips and onion rings.“

“Had the Solis Special tonight. Fantastic!“

“The cheese steak sub is great! I tried this place while visiting my husband who is currently working in town. The owner was super friendly. Gave us a free drink for it being our first time there. Someone else was getting a pizza while we were there that looked great too and I would have loved to try. Definitely recommend. Great local place!“

“love their subs. also always very friendly“

“We aren't from around here and needed a quick bite. We ordered a pizza and it took about 30 minutes, and honestly it was the best pizza I've ever had! It was a little awkward standing there waiting for it while one of the women cooking loudly complained about a customers order but it happens.“

“Ordered a couple pizzas and enjoyed a beer at the bar while waiting. Staff was great, and the pizza is the best. Will go back often!“

“The food was delicious and was made in a timely manner I ordered a BBQ chicken pizza and it was delicious“

“So good � the food is so good & it’s like home made healthy quality not like fast food quality �“

“The service was great, drinks were delicious and the pork chop….perfection!“

“Life long customers but we only would get pizza or grinders, which are phenomenal. Tonight we decided to order pasta dinners and burgers off the menu and we were blown away! The portions are quite generous, the meals were delicious, the soup was perfect, the side salad also generous and delicious. The containers were generously sized and microwavable which is awesome because there's too much to eat in one sitting. Everyone in my home cant stop talking about how good dinner is. The kids burger is a full size burger with a handful of fries, enough for feed 3 toddlers. No one left the table still hungry. Bye bye olive garden. This is our official new pasta spot. Prices were quite reasonable as well. Very pleased!!! We'll done Midway Pizza! 5 billion stars FO-SHO!!!“

“Passing through and checked out their ice cream and gelato! Enjoyed that, and appreciated the suggestion to go to Watch Hill. Thanks!“

“Osmino’s Grill is a gem of New London! The food is amazing, take out is always easy, the owners are the sweetest, and there is always something on the menu for everyone! Their pizza is awesome. I can’t say enough amazing things about this restaurant! 20/10 recommend!“

“The food is great and my family and I go at least once a week. All so the people that work there are great to. Love that place.“

“Easy location between New London and Waterford. Love ordering online and using pick up window. Never leave my car. Great for this busy mom. Food is always good. If not they make it fix it when I call. A+ service.“