“Wonderful place for a night out, always our favorite pizza joint to eat in at because of the incredible aroma and comforting atmosphere. Pizza is piping hot and features a thin crust with a perfect balance of crunch and chew. Decent wine and beer selection to pair, doesn't need a huge menu like others as they know what they do best and they always deliver on that! It's a true staple of the Italian roots in Jamestown.“
“Elmo’s is the best in Town! I’m a born and raised Jersey girl. This is the best I can get to Jersey pizza in the area. Elmo and his crew is always very nice and the shop is always in tip top shape. You can tell he takes pride in his work and in his customers. If you want NY/Jersey pizza there’s no place but Elmo’s!! The rest are fake wanna be’s. “
“Vegetarian options: I like the white pizza which has no meatDietary restrictions: I like cheese chicken arms and bread so it meets my requirementsKid-friendliness: Kids who feel welcome here are quickly shown the doorWheelchair accessibility: Not really wheelchair accessible“
“Firstly- our server was amazing. I didn’t catch his name but he was young and very personable. The food was excellent as always. We had eggplant Parmigiana, seafood combo with angel hair, Nonna’s stuffed eggplant and garlic knots. As always- delicious tiramisu and cheesecake to bring home. Portions are very generous for the price so we always have lunch for the next day too.“
“Love this place such a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. never had a bad meal here nor bad service. If you are unhappy they go out of the way to make it better. recomend this place and defintley will be back. food is amazing i had wings and pizza and they were out of this world, saucy and good.“
“Hello, we were passing through Jamestown.., looking for a quick meal, saw the place, Googled and stopped in...we are all Italian, btw, eggplant parm and chicken marsala... were great!!! Sunday Sauce was smooth..atmosphere very casual and welcoming.... waitress (Ashley) was very accomodating..“
“Good is always good here. Service is always met with polite smiles and quick response. Atmosphere at the lunch hour is busy.Parking: Parking is limited as space is shared with another store. The empty lot beside them is available for parking at this time.Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly atmosphere and space. Lights aren't over powering but aren't too dim either. Space is good. Buffet is each to reach and utensils are clean.Wheelchair accessibility: To get in is a little tight but once in there is space to move to tables. Getting to the buffet can be tricky but not impossible. Bathroom is not easily accessible.“
“10/10 for the patience.I call the store to order a pizza, there’s chaos going on in the background, phones ringing, timers going off, I hear a man yelling.Come to find out, that man accidentally got cut with the knife. The man I’m on the phone with, it’s only him and the other guy at work who cut himself. I have to count cash to make sure I have enough to pay for my friend’s pizza’s, I feel awful the whole time. This guy staying on the phone with me while working, keeping his calm and professionalism. I know it’s their job but it should not be this rough, get this man a promotion and management do better for your employees please. Every time I get food from this area, they do exceptional.“
“I love this place except for a couple of changes they have made. When dinning in they used to cut your pizza in triangle slices and serve your first piece to you at your table. They don't anymore. They cut the pizza in squares so your always left with those little pieces with no goodies on them that nobody wants and they don't serve your first piece to you anymore. They got lazy I guess.“
“No frills place but with good food. We were passing by the town and spur of the moment decided to stop here. We got a chicken parm sub and raist beef sub. The roast beef sub was extra good and we could tell the beef was really good quality. We'll probably stop by again when we pass back through.“
“Definitely a nice place to stop for food pizza and wings. Super busy on a Saturday with walk-ins and call-ins but theybwere busting it out! We waited about 15 minutes for dine in.Kid-friendliness: It's pizza!Dietary restrictions: They have a gluten free pizza“