28 Best Steakhouses near Garden City

“"An Exquisite Experience at PrimeHouse, Garden City" Recently, I had the pleasure of dining at PrimeHouse in Garden City, and it was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere captivated me with its beautiful decor - a perfect blend of elegance and comfort. The real stars of the evening, however, were our host and hostesses, Jaime and Nick. Their attentive service, warm smiles, and expert knowledge of the menu made our experience truly memorable. They went above and beyond to ensure our comfort, making us feel like VIPs throughout the night. Now, let’s talk about the food - it was divine! Every dish was a culinary masterpiece, bursting with flavors that tantalized my taste buds. The chefs at PrimeHouse clearly know their craft and take great pride in their creations. Another noteworthy aspect was the parking facility. It was conveniently located and spacious, making the start and end of our dining experience hassle-free. In conclusion, PrimeHouse in Garden City is a must-visit. Whether it’s for a special occasion or just a casual night out, it promises an exceptional dining experience with fabulous food, top-notch service, and a delightful ambiance. Hats off to Jaime and Nick for making our evening so special!“

“Everything was great from start to finish. Food was great. Service was amazing. They were all very kind from the hostess to the servers/bussers. They were all very attentive. Thank you for a great dining experience. Will definitely be back.“

“Excellent service by Mariano the server. Hands on manager-Jason. The food was excellent & fast. Manager & server were both very attentive & professional. Will definitely be making frequent visits. 5 stars ⭐️ for sure. Awesome work!“

“Unbelievable! Great food, great fun, and the best service! Can’t wait to go back!“

“I was there today for lunch .. What a wonderful Place !! The Food was Amazing and the staff could not be more attentive .. A truly refreshing break from the ordinary .. It’s Come a Very Long Way from the JBH I drank at in my teens 😊😊👍👍👏. Go .. You will Not be Disappointed ❤️“

“I placed a catering order and went to Island Park for pick up. I met, while there, Angie Chieffo. She and her staff were wonderful, helpful and in the Holiday spirit. Angie went above and beyond to assist me. I am a loyal customer and she is part of the reason why. Thanks again Angie!!!!“

“I had a wonderful experience here dining, celebrating 🥳 a special birthday.. From parking to paying the bill everyone was friendly, cordial, polite and helpful.. Shout-out to maître D Tory & Valerie.. Our waiters Jason & Freddy are definitely top notch with their service.. And Manager’s Cliff & Albert are extremely great hosts, they make you feel welcome and they were very attentive and genuine.. Thanks folks for your hospitality, great service and delicious food. I’d definitely recommend visiting this restaurant for lunch, dinner, and any special occasion! #williamajacobs“

“Very friendly staff and great service food was amazing and very nice cocktails“

“Have dinner with my wife here every so often. The service is always great. Our waitress this time around was Stephanie and she was great, very attentive, courteous, super nice and quick with our orders, she is the best around and nothing with take her down. If you go here ask for Stephanie for your waitress.“

“We went to Peter Luger’s in Brooklyn to celebrate my son’s and my birthdays. Incredibly, it was our first time there. We will be back. Beautiful, old world atmosphere. The food was beyond delicious. Our waiters, Adi and Justin were friendly and professional. I read so many reviews that the wait staff was rude and cold. Don’t believe it for one second. All the waiters were attentive and checked to see how everything was going. Don’t miss the apple strudel and schlag. I’d give Peter Luger’s ten stars if I could. Can’t wait to return.“

“Go here often with my kids during the week, my daughter loves the Mac n cheese with fries, my son the cheeseburger w Fruit bowl, I usually have sirloin & Alice springs chicken with Mash & rice. Everything always come out cooked to perfection and hot.
Service is always on point, the host Hailey is great, she is so welcoming and always recommends something to try, the servers especially Guiselle & Wesley(i think) always very attentive and welcoming“

“Great service along with amazing food!“

“Great food and atmosphere! Never rushed. Our favorite restaurant for over 35 years!“

“I wanted a classy night out and this place hit all the right marks. I am sensitive to ambience and found that the music and lighting were perfect - enough to create an ambience but not put stress on my senses - I could still perfectly hear my companion and see the food well.

The menu was nicely varied with some familiar and some more unique options (try the duck confit spring rolls.) The prices are above basic but reasonable compared with other upscale options in the area. I felt that we got what we paid for in terms of service, atmosphere, and food.

The staff was courteous and helpful. They were just the right amount of present, providing everything we wanted including menu suggestions without seeming overbearing and in your face at all. We did not have to wait too long for anything.

We went at a high traffic time and it was a little crowded. We had just enough personal space but not a whole lot. Definitely not what you'd call privacy, but we and everyone I saw seemed comfortable.

Overall I highly recommend this place, you will not be sorry.

Spent about $150 including tip for two people, full meal including dessert, no drinks.“

“From NC and my boi Terrell suggested here. Food and ambience was absolutely incredible!! Will definitely come back!“

“Absolutely love this place. So many things to choose from and everything is amazing“

“Great food, excellent drinks, great service“

“Awesome steaks and sides!!!“

“We dined at the Majors Restaurant in East Meadow. Dinner was delicious. I have no complaints about that. Here is my issue. Little, but it’s the principle. My husband ordered a cup of coffee after our $158 Dinner. The coffee came and when he put milk in it, I noticed it was really dark. I tasted it. WOW it was burnt, old & muddy. I called the waiter over and asked for a new brewed cup of coffee. He came back with a cup from the SAME pot. Normally I would of just moved on & left it. But when the bill came we were charged $3.50. For 1 cup of burnt coffee? Sorry it was the principle. If you are going to charge your clients $3.50 for a cup of coffee, invest in a Keurig where every cup is fresh. You make a great margin per cup?“

“I’ve been going to Hendricks for years and never did I have a bad experience there. My wife and I have gone together or we’ve been there for large gatherings as well and always a great time and amazing food. One of the most underrated restaurants on Long Island.“

“The food was very tasty! The service was outstanding. Likewise, the welcoming atmosphere was GREAT!!! Kudos to the Texas Roadhouse Restaurant!!!👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾“

“I’m just shy of 50 and this is my first time in LI while residing in NY my entire life. My gf and I came down from Saratoga last minute after our trip to Lauderdale was canceled. We thank Jimmy Hays, his awesome staff and friendly local regulars for their hospitality and overall friendliness. We sat at the bar, felt like I was home at my local favorite establishment. Hands down the best meal we had in town and time spent. I would come down for this experience again & again now that I know where to go! Joe Cox, Saratoga NY“

“Love this place and their tasty food, will defo be back for more, a great experience.“

“The appetizers - fries, creamed spinach, garlic mash were tasteful and the fried calamari crispy cooked to perfection. The 100-day aged tomahawk steak was succulent and cooked to perfection as well as the NY strip. The Old Fashioned drink was better than I expected and real smooth. Overall very satisfied with the quality of food and service.“

“Great place and nice food“

“What a wonderful comforting atmosphere to sit down in after the trials and tribulations of check in and security ... a massive massive thank you to the beautiful Riju who served me and went above and beyond, thank you for sharing conversations and your time with me.. I wish you all the best and hope to see you again soon in another place and another time sister <3“

“Most delicious ribeye, great atmosphere. They made a good dirty martini! Will definitely be going back!“

“the last time we ate at Thom Thom our service was terrible. My main complaint then seemed to be lack of staff relative to the amount of customers. tonight we had the SAME waiter as last time, and the service was very good. There was definitely more help in the dining room and even though the crowd was larger today service was very good. Helpful and you could always get someone to refill water, or if you had a question. Food quality and presentation has always been very good, so, given the better service, I was pleasantly pleased.“