14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Hicksville

“The Pizza here is some of the best on LongIsland“

“Smaller establishment. Cheesy bread was nit hit both visits. I really go there cause its smaller so its usually less chaos. Location is tucked so not the easiest to find. Parking is also scarce as its shared with a shopping complex. Not the best location but doable.“

“Great pizza“

“hands down the best pizza slices i've ever had. worth every penny. I don't even like cheese and i still devoured it. 10/10. fast service. ADDICTING FLAVOR. boom slice??!? amazing. rigatoni pasta slice??? !!! yes!!! white slice?? mmmm yesss i'm going here again tomorrow“

“The new owners have done a magnificent job in re-opening this classic pizza joint! The new menu is awesome and I love the pizza they are making. I 100% recommend this establishment.“

“Pizza Twist was my first pizza experience in the US, and it has remained my favorite ever since, even after a year of frequent visits. They offer a consistent yet diverse range of flavors, and their vegetable combinations are simply top notch, I can’t even begin to describe how delicious they are. I highly recommend that everyone tries their pizza they have the best service and are the top choice in town.“

“I have had many items from this place and they have all been amazing. The spinach roll, chicken parm roll, pizza, etc. Their vodka sauce is fantastic and I was hooked on it for a while. Then I tried their bolognese sauce. I have eaten spaghetti bolognese in Italy, London, and probably 20 different places in New York and NJ. The bolognese at Alex’s is top 2 or 3 and I can get it without having to go to Italy. Huge portion and so delicious. Super friendly staff as well.“

“Mama Venezia Pizza – A Local Favorite!
Mama Venezia Pizza never disappoints. The Grandma pie is perfectly crisp with a great balance of sauce and cheese, and the Sicilian is light, airy, and full of flavor. The garlic knots are addictive and always fresh.

The three brothers who own the place are wonderful — friendly, welcoming, and clearly passionate about their food. Whether you’re dining in, picking up, or getting delivery, the portions are generous, the service is quick, and the food is consistently delicious. A true neighborhood gem that makes you feel like family every time.“

“Tony, Tony, Tony... Our party of 24 will forever be grateful to you for saving a night out with our family. When I called asking if you could accommodate a large party after plans to go into the city fell apart, you made it happen within a 1/2 hour even though you were super busy with other parties and on a Saturday night before Mother's Day. You welcomed us with open arms and treated us like royalty. You, Sal & your staff made sure we were happy, and we were. The staff is amazing. Patrizia's, as busy as it is all the time, never fails to provide the most delicious and fresh food and in abundance of it. The staff is very attentive and all work well together. The atmosphere is also a lot of fun. You have definitely gained 24 lifetime customers. God Bless!“

“We ordered 2 large pizzas and we expected a 14” large pizza but we received a 8” large pizza.The pizza was super tasty delicious and they put a nice amount of toppings on it.I would appreciate if the size was bigger as 1 8” pizza for 21 bucks is insane.“

“Great pizza place to go. Friendly staff.“

“The food is outstanding! The service, from the front counter to the hostess and wait staff, are all friendly, courteous and professional! The atmosphere is warm and cozy and the cleanliness is impeccable! Anyone who wants good, authentic Italian food with ample size portions should eat at Pasta-eria!“