5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hillsdale

Hillsdale House American • $$
2634 NY-23, Hillsdale

Customers` Favorites

Trio Tapenade Platter
Mac and Cheese
Pulled Pork
Side Salad
Brisket
Pizza

“Great little spot. I would have given five stars however, over the years, they have had Chef retention struggles, so the food has always been a bit inconsistent. It seems like it has gotten much more consistent over the last year, which is great to see. Very friendly staff“

3.7 Good24 Reviews
Four Brothers Pizza Inn Pizza • $$
2828 NY-23, Hillsdale

Customers` Favorites

Small Pizza Pepperoni and Sausage
Greek Salad with Chicken
Housemade Marinara Sauce
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Grilled Chicken
Philly Steak
Baked Ziti
Alla Vodka

“Wow!!! What a great place to eat after a full day of skiing! The Greek salad is a must! A large will feed 4! A small would easily feed 2! The split pea soup was amazing! The pizza and the pizza dough was so amazing! The waitress was so friendly and had a great attitude! We absolutely had a delightful time! Great food in a great atmosphere! Very clean!“

3.5 Good39 Reviews
Tommy B's Slice Shop Pizza Takeaway • $
1817 NY-23, Craryville - 2.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza and Special Pies
Whole Pie Toppings
The Holy Cannoli
Salad of the Day
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Whole Pie
Slice of Pizza
Veggie Lover's
Vodka Taconic
Sicilian Pie

“Such a cute small spot my 4 yr old loved the place N the pizza he said 2 thumbs up and loved the 8 ball such a retro feel my husband couldn't get over the size of the slice he got such good prices worth a driveKid-friendliness: The guys working joked with my four yr old“

4.8 Superb58 Reviews
Church Street Deli & Pizza Pizza • $
1677 County Rte 7A, Copake - 5.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ham and Cheese Sandwich with Coffee
Cheeseburger with Fries
Chicken Caesar Salad
Pizza Slices
Cheese Pizza
Roast Beef
Wrap

“Pretty good pizza especially the white Pesto Melanzane pizza. We went on a Tuesday and they had a special for $10 large cheese pizza which the kids ate. The girls who work there were super friendly and even put our pizzas on a side table so we had room to eat. The one funny thing was they only had two paper menus for the whole place and one had separated into two pieces. Im all for conservation but im sure there's a xerox machine somewhere in town. Please be aware they close one day a week.“

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
High Falls Pizzeria & Taphouse Pizza • $
94 Main St, Philmont - 8.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brew House Burger
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza My Heart
Greek Salad
Hamburger

“Weary traveler looking for some good pizza. This pizza restaurant was A+. I dined in and service was great. I ordered 2 slices, pepperoni and sausage. Quality of the ingredients was definitely on the plus side. I struggled to finish the rwo incredibly topped slices. It was hard to stop eating but it was so good. Nice crispy and tasty crust with more than adequate toppings. Would highly recommend.“

3.6 Good26 Reviews