Customers` Favorites
“As a musician who has played so many bars all over NY state I must say the environment at Tailgsters is so incredibly special. First, they treat the bands with love and respect. It should be the norm but sadly it’s not always the case. They go above and beyond. From the ownership to every single enologee that works there, it’s impossible not to absolutely love every person associated with this bar. The crowd is great and super friendly and safe and I genuinely look forward to playing there again. They treat their customers, staff; and performers like family. Really like family. I am so grateful that we’ve played there twice and I’m already looking to playing there again. Michelle behind the bar is a genuinely great person and makes awesome drinks, but every single person there is so approachable and engaging. I can recommend Tailgsters as a genuinely fun environment that treats everyone like family. I look forward to just visiting when I’m not playing. Impressed is a huge understatement. Thank you so much for treating our band the way you did. Truly an Awsome night and the staff and crowd at Tailgatets made our night extra special. Thank you for being genuine and amazing people. They’re doing it right!!! Beyond grateful for an awesome night!!! Thank you!!!!“
Customers` Favorites
“Delicious food and great drinks“
Customers` Favorites
“Dined with Scot as our server Tues eve. The food was excellent, as it always is, and Scot made sure everything went smoothly. The appetizer came out quickly, and good pace between the app and the main course, which had generous portion and, as noted above, tasted great! He checked with us, and delivered drink refills as needed as well. We had a great time, and will certainly be back.“
Customers` Favorites
“Great food and atmosphere.“
Customers` Favorites
“Great times and great menu friendly staff“
Customers` Favorites
“good specials friendly staff, but they DO NOT honor the website specials :(“
Customers` Favorites
“This place is truly a hidden gem in Sayville! Excellent food that is way beyond my expectations for a pub. Great fresh brisket, and arguably the best hand-cut fries on Long Island! Solid selection of draft beers, friendly bartenders, and local owners who take pride in their craft and care about their patrons. Please Support your local businesses and communities! ?“
Customers` Favorites
“Great atmosphere, and very nice people. Love it!!“
Customers` Favorites
“We hadn’t been here and years and decided to visit while in town. The menu is super unique and prices are what you pay for. I have become a fan all over again.“
Customers` Favorites
“Love this bar so much. My friends and I go there all the time after our gigs, and the server Joanne always takes such good care of us. The food is delicious, the vibes are cozy, and everything is super clean. A great place to have a drink or bring your loved ones!
Vegetarian options: Not a veg heavy menu, but I'm sure if you asked for options they would make something for you. It's just that kind of place.
Parking: Parking can be tough, especially on the weekends.
Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly“
Customers` Favorites
“First off I want to say I've been coming here for years and I just love coming here!! Everyone here is so nice and friendly which is why I always come back. The bartenders especially Kayla and Meagan truly are rockstars.
The food is always good and I really enjoy the atmosphere here and I will always be coming back
You have a really nice set of managers and the new general manager Jillian who took over the store is fantastic!!! She truly loves her staff and takes pride in her job and it shows!!!“
Customers` Favorites
“{{restaurant.reviews}}“
Loading...
“4.5 stars is about rightThis is my first time here never been here before I didn't even know it existed went into watch the Jets game really great place for TVs everywhere I mean they had everything on You know it's like watching the Jets they're terrible They lost terribly their season's terrible so they have a few other things on there's like a college game on and then there was like some MMA women's fighting It was just a lot of things to look at.Very pretty young bartender and Alexis and I didn't catch the other woman's name but they were both really niceHere's the exampleAnd the reason why I gets one star offI ordered a Miller lite It was flat so there's your one star off really flat I haven't had a Miller Lane foreverNow he's with a bunch of guys and they were drinking Miller lite out of a pitcher.When I went to leave I said Oh I just had the 1 Miller lights to no worries I'll put it on their bill You don't owe.anything.Now that's a great bartender bartender knows their patrons and when they're coming back when the by when the buyback all those of things something other places could really use and learn about is buybacks and courtesy.So I asked for some change just so I could tip her five bucksI'll definitely be back here especially to watch the Jets lose!Possibly for the super bowlHave the shrimp fajitas for sureFriends said they were good ?“