{{ group }}
-
{{ item.name }}
- {{ item.properties.formatted }}
Customers` Favorites
Customers` Favorites
“Always great pizza and friendly service. 10/10!“
Customers` Favorites
“I ordered the Eggplant Parmesan dinner as a take out. My goodness, it was so delicious, filling and even had it the next day for lunch because the portion was large.“
Customers` Favorites
“Best antipasto bread in all of Central New York! 😊“
Customers` Favorites
“Tonys is always number one at our house for pizza“
Customers` Favorites
“The food is amazing and so are the owners they are always amazing too me and the food is delicious and out of this world 10/10“
Customers` Favorites
“Just the best. Made with love. Best food in the valley.“
Customers` Favorites
“Pizza and Chicken tenders were delicious. Great sauce on the pizza and the tenders were cooked perfect! (Not overcooked and not greasy) We will definitely be back!“
“We had fabulous pizza today for lunch! I highly recommend the onion and garlic! Everyone was so nice too!
Parking: Easy parking right in front
Kid-friendliness: All are welcome, very simple restaurant.
Wheelchair accessibility: Easy flat entrance.“
“Came here Thursday January 8th 2026 at 3pm for a pacific veggie pizza. Who ever raised the young lady working by herself raised her right. Great pizza great attitude and working hard. She deserved way more than the max for tip on the machine. Been coming here on and off since I’ve moved up here 2 years ago. First pleasurable experience I’ve had since.“
Recommended
Customers` Favorites
“{{restaurant.reviews}}“
Loading...
“Every once in a while you stumble across an absolute gem. This is one of those places. On a recent trip to Cooperstown we looked up local pizza places and Nonna’s, understandably, had great reviews. I’m happy to add mine to the list. This is a fantastic experience from start to finish. Wonderful staff and incredible pizza. We had the Antipasto Salad, the Quattro Formaggi and a Margherita with some extra toppings. Everything was to perfection. I cannot recommend this place enough. Worth the trip.
#pizza #woodfire #cooperstown“