“Although the restaurant was busy today we were seated, waited on, and served in a reasonably amount of time. The food was good and the wait staff was friendly and accommodating, especially since we wanted a window table that had not been bussed yet.“
“If you’ve seen the movie “The Menu” this is the Seneca Lake equivalent however without the tragic ending. Watch the movie then go to this place because the food is phenomenal, maybe you’ll see the connection. In all seriousness great place to eat, recommend reservations in advance, if you love German cuisine this is a must while in the Lake Seneca region. Indoor and outdoor seating, it’s just a fantastic place and would tell anyone to go and give it a rip for the experience and food.“
“My husband and I were out working in the area far from home. This area doesn't have much, then when we found Rylee's Place! Went in, were immediately greeted and helped. The food is great, came out in speedy time, AND Rylee makes the muffins!! How cute . Definitely coming back when I'm in the area again. Very friendly staff as well!“
“Little restaurant on the Seneca wine trail. Great food, good portions and our server was very attentive. Breaded mushrooms and mozzarella sticks were tasty. It was prime rib night and wow! It was huge! Cooked to medium rare as ordered and was very good. The au jus that came with it added the perfect amount of saltiness. My husband loved his chicken parm - 1/2 inch thick breaded chicken breast with yummy melted mozzarella on top served over spaghetti. He was full about 3/4 through his meal but liked it so much he finished it! Meals came with a salad and a side. We'd definitely visit again! Of note is that they don't take reservations.“
“I have lived around the way from Toni's diner my whole life it has been a true privilege's to have such a great diner so close to home! Service is 2nd to none atmosphere is Comfortable and Friendly and you will find no sweeter woman in the world than Toni!Parking: Its right behind the Gas station on 414 its tucked away from the highway which is really nice, makes it feel quiet and private!Kid-friendliness: Great parking and child friendly!“
“Called in a big Togo order around 9:00am Saturday, 20 minutes was not a long wait. Everything was perfect and correct, good food fast. The ham is an actual ham steak not lunch meat. Can't wait to try lunch sometime soon.Pictured is The Big One. French toast, over easy eggs, hashbrowns and sausage links.“
“Wonderful and friendly staff combined with tasty wine, cocktails and mocktails. What a wonderful surprise for a first time visitor to this lovely area of the finger lakes region. Please stop by and have a bite to eat if you're in the area. I'm so glad me and my dear friends did. ❤️“
“There's no strangers here. This small town diner was full of regulars pre-covid but took quite a hit during quarantine. The owners have worked 6-7 days a week to keep it open and are making a comeback. Food is better than might be expected, service is stellar.“
“First time here. Heard good things so we planned to meet up with my oldest and his wife. Was not disappointed. I had two eggs, scrambled with sausage links, home fries and English muffin. My girlfriend had French toast. I don't remember what the kids had, but they were happy. Our drinks came in cans, which was cool, but not sure if you get free refills. Still, good homestyle cooking with friendly service.“
“Had the burger plate special. Huge burger and generous side of fries. 5 stars is not enough!!! A definite 10!!! Delicious!! Will be a regular stop on my way back from the Windmill Owner/cook was super nice, friendly, accommodating. Can't say enough great things about this wonderful establishment“
“Don't let the outside fool you! It's one of the most immaculate, neat, homey, cozy, and charming restaurants I've ever been to in my life. Seriously. I'm glad I let my husband convince me to try it. Tastefully decorated, TV's playing Youtube scenery videos with nice music, a pool table room, a fireplace going. Even a glimpse at the immaculate kitchen shocked me. The food was great. I had a fish fry. Most places give bland fries: theirs was seasoned and so addicting. The burger my husband got tasted quality. For all those people who complained they couldn't get seated because they bring a bunch of people...look around. It's small. It's cozy. It's a small business in an even smaller town, not a big chain that can handle unexpected groups. It's obvious that the couple who own this place care about all the little details that frankly, most restaurants skimp on, so we're giving them more than 5 stars. We're coming back, without a doubt.“
“Stayed here the night of Aug 21. Stay included a 5 wine sampling and a complimentary bottle of wine in the room. The room is just ok, but the views on the patio of the room are amazing. All the employees were very nice as well. Stopped by here while traveling to Niagara falls from Maryland, and the wife already wants to come back next year.“
“Absolutely amazing dining experience.... Amazing burgers with fresh ingredients. Amazing staff. The one girl even tried to help me find old wine from their reserve.. this was our first time visiting and WILL NOT be our last... great food and service..“
“The food is phenomenal! Fish fry is to die for, from the fresh haddock to the creamy tartar sauce and the amazing coleslaw, everything is delicious!! Their chicken fajitas are so amazing, they serve their fajitas with an amazing lime crema and a flavorful chipotle barbecue sauce, and it's all a flavor rush and on point!! Definitely recommend Johnny's kitchen for a true flavor experience !!“