16 Best Bakeries near Mattituck

Ali Katz Kitchen Bakery •
55 County Rd 48, Mattituck

“Some places you seek out. Others seem to find you.

Stumbling upon Ali Katz Kitchen in Mattituck last weekend felt a little like that.

After nine years of calling Sag Harbor home, we’ve been spending our first real season getting to know the North Fork—and discovering the places that give this side of the East End its own sense of character.

And then there’s the food.

There is something to be said for really good comfort food. Food that doesn’t need to be overly complicated to be memorable. Food that simply hits the spot.

Today, we found it.

Fried chicken. Green beans. Potato salad.

Simple, familiar, and so incredibly good.

As a tastemaker and someone who has spent years representing chefs and telling the stories behind food, I’m naturally curious about the people behind what lands on the table. I loved discovering that Ali & Fitz are both chefs and reading the story behind what they’ve created together.

Because when there is passion behind the food, you can taste it.

And that may be what I loved most about Ali Katz Kitchen. It feels like two chefs doing what they love creating delicious food and sharing it with their community.

What a beautiful little discovery in Mattituck.

We’ll be back. 🤍“

4.8 Superb26 Reviews
Familia Bakery Colombian • $
252-9 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays - 8.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fondant Cakes

“I'm a regular at Familia Bakery's Farmingville location, so I was excited to stop into the Hampton Bays shop, and it lived up to everything I love about this bakery. It had the same quality, the same care, and the same friendly service I've come to expect.

Familia is who I trust with every custom birthday cake for my students, and they always go above and beyond on the design and the details. Their chocolate cake is a favorite in my house, especially with my girlfriend. It's great to know there's another location out east with the same standards.

If you're in the Hampton Bays area and need a cake for a celebration, or you just want something fresh and sweet, stop in. You won't be disappointed.“

4.8 Superb53 Reviews
The Treatery Long Island Bakery • $
1564 Main Road, Jamesport - 3.81 miles

“A thousand thumbs up for everything here! Thoughtful and delicious scratch made treats, YES PLEASE!��������“

4.7 Superb65 Reviews
Rustik Cake Studio Bakery • $$
53 Hill Street Ste 72, Southampton - 10.39 miles

“I took the Lambeth boot camp and everything was great. Thank you Rocío. Tomé el boot camp de Lambeth y todo estuvo super bien. Gracias por todo Rocío!“

4.7 Superb19 Reviews
Celeste Bakery Bakery • $
857-863 Old Country Road, Riverhead - 8.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“I ordered a birthday cake for A friend they did a beautiful job and executed it perfectly and she absolutely loved it. Wull definitely go back. 10/10“

4.5 Superb53 Reviews
Krieg's Bakery Bakery • $
39 West Montauk Highway Suite 7, Hampton Bays - 7.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cannoli

“I recommend trying everything made at Krieg's! All Delicious... especially the danish, jelly donuts, croissants, pies, cakes, etc.“

4.5 Superb52 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Grilled Cheese
Caramel Cheesecake
Apple Crumb Pie

“The Baker's Workshop at Suffolk County Community College Culinary Arts Center is a wonderful place for breakfast or lunch.
The students work so hard to prepare and serve delicious food.
Give it a try. You won't be sorry.“

4.6 Superb17 Reviews
Blue Duck Bakery Cafe Southold Bakery • $
56275 NY-25, Southold - 7.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Croissant

“highly do not recommend. keith kouris harasses people on the internet ! I ALSO GOT FOOD POISONING !! avoid avoid avoid!!!“

4.4 Superb41 Reviews
Hallock's Cider Mill Bakery • $$
1960 Main Rd, Laurel - 2.92 miles

“So I was on a mission to buy apple cider donuts. Two places I visited beforehand didn't have any so I found this gem. There is an array of pies, cakes, cookies and preserves to satisfy your sweet tooth. I was pleasantly surprised by the bevy of items that were offered. The cashier (sorry I don't recall his name) was pleasant and helpful. Most importantly I bought 3 apple cider donuts and a Bavarian donut. Next time I am out this way I'll be sure to pick up bread, preserves and soup.“

4.3 Superb66 Reviews
Briermere Farms Bakery • $$
4414 Sound Avenue, Riverhead - 6.76 miles

“Avocado picked up a Peach and Cream Pie today! The cream filling is my favorite part!“

4.6 Superb432 Reviews
Dari-Land LLC Ice Cream Shop • $
51 Main Road, Riverhead - 6.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Vanilla Ice Cream
Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Black Cherry Ice Cream
Banana Split

“I recommend Dari-land ice cream to everyone! The owner is such an amazing person who goes out of his way for customers! He went out of his way for me and I wish I could for him! Not only is his ice cream great but I want everyone to go to his store! Thank you Dari-land ice cream owner!“

4.6 Superb164 Reviews
Antojitos bakery Bakery • $
40 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays - 7.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Arepa Con Carne
Pan De Bono
Empanadas

“Honestly the best empanadas that I've ever had! We were met with a warm and friendly greeting from the woman behind the counter. I will come back again and again.

We had the beef, ham/pineapple/cheese, and the guava/cheese empanadas 🤌🏻“

4 Good106 Reviews
Hampton Coffee Company Coffee Shops • $
272 Main Rd, Aquebogue - 6.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sour Cream Walnut Coffee Cake
Coffee and a Cranberry Muffin
A Cup of Coffee and a Scone
Coconut Almond Macaroon
Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Hazelnut Iced Coffee
Marshmallow Square
Chocolate Croissant
Pecan Raisin Scone
Mocha Freeze

“Hampton Coffee has the most delicious iced matcha lattes! They also have amazing iced coffee, refreshers, and a wide variety of fresh treats!“

4.4 Superb179 Reviews
Stone Street Cafe Cafe • $
54180 Main Road, Southold - 7.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich Display
Quiche

“The first time I tried the pretzel croissant I became addicted! All of their croissants are amazing... Their coffee is awesome too! So glad it opened in Southold. Lately, they've been making the pretzel croissants into egg sandwich which I'm sure is delicious too, but I prefer to ask for it alone :) Whoever is making these croissants, thank you Chef!!!!“

4.4 Superb102 Reviews
Junda's Pastry Crust & Crumbs Bakery • $$
1612 Main Road, Jamesport - 3.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Apple Strudel
Pies

“Been going here for nearly 15 years; love it!“

3.5 Good40 Reviews
Tate's Bake Shop Bakery • $
43 North Sea Road, Southampton - 10.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Shortbread Cupcakes & Pride Cupcakes
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
Assorted Grab & Go Treats
Fresh Strawberry Cake
Banana Choc Chip Cake
Cookie Dough Cupcake
Lemon Cookies
Brownies
Bakery
Fudge

“dont know how i got em but glad I did.“

3.6 Good158 Reviews