7 Best Bakeries near Mattituck

“Every time I order from Ali Katz Kitchen I am not disappointed. This recent order of mac & cheese was excellent. Although it was frozen solid when I picked it up, it cooked up perfectly. This simple dish is just one example of the consistent quality of every thing made at Ali Katz.“

“Enjoyable find of a Colombian bakery that has been here 8 months already. Would have stopped in sooner if had noticed sooner.People come for their beef empanadas made here.They also make Choladas so so - way to tough a customer spoiled up island in Hicksville - not in the same league but tried it and enjoyed it. The owners family manufactures Macarons in Pachogue and has them here in many flavors. Not a fan of sugary sweet macarons but the hosts always convince me to try and I can never eat them LOL sooo sweet. But the Nutella and another she recommended were ok. The Nutella slightly easier. Yes stop in and get a slice of cake here - tres leches, caramel cheesecake slices etc.“

“I stepped into the Treatery for first time as I was waiting in queue to have brunch at the Main Street Biscuit Company across the street. It was a great decision! The cheerful owner and employees gave me a great impression. The cookies were out of this world! While I was bummed that they were out of their chocolate chip and walnut, the triple chocolate was amazing and so was the oatmeal raisin. I love to support women in business with a positive outlook and quality product. I highly recommend you step in as the summer season is approaching and beyond! A wonderful retreat on the way to wherever you’re heading east or even if you’re a resident! So glad I came in:)Kid-friendliness: They were cute kids in there enjoying their cupcakes! I also noticed a few custom orders being picked up for cupcakes, which was assumably a birthday party or special occasion!“

“This is my favorite ice cream shop. I’ve been coming here since I was a young child and I still do because their service has always remained the same! The people are so sweet and kind, plus their servings are REASONABLY GREAT portions unlike other places.“

“The cakes are very good and delicious, but the only thing I didn't like was the service of the people who attended me many grumpy faces ago, they do everything reluctantly and they always make money by throwing away, and many times they do the same to me. me and my family.“

“To begin this is a teaching kitchen, students are lead by instructors and taught how to run a business. That being said the food they put out has been given all the effort and attention it requires.The specials they have are unbeatable for the quality and amount of food that you get.I recommend going and giving it a try.“

“This local wast end bakery with a few spots has frown on me. At first I resisted but once they closed Riverhead it dawned on me we need more reliable bakeries out east. So when at the remaining locations O know I can get a variety of baked breads, the best Rugelagh and some albeit tooo neat .. some pies. So mot close to breirmere but respectable enough to grab for comp ay and please.“