9 Best Caterers near Mattituck

“I don't know how to begin to express how incredible Chris and Joanne are. My original wedding caterer cancelled less than one month prior to my wedding for 150 people at a venue that required complete customization. Every chair, tray, fork, knife, etc. I was required to bring in and my wedding simply wouldn't have been possible without them. They truly go above and beyond to make your day incredible, and most importantly stress free. The attached photo shows Chris literally wiping the floor during a band break. Their staff set up all of my beautiful tablescapes, welcome stations, etc. Chris also set up my entire ceremony after an issue day of with the rental company. Aside from how above and beyond they went, the food was incredible. I married an Italian so my guests take food very seriously and the positive feedback was resounding. Chris and Joanne truly saved my day and blew every expectation out of the water. We are immensely grateful to have found them!“

“Our guests just can’t stop talking about the food created by By Hand Catering. Adam and Liz are phenomenal to work with, offering the opportunity to work with you to create a menu and event that fits your style. We had a backyard wedding with 150+ people that required an endless-cocktail style reception and the use of unique spaces for our bars. Adam adapted to all of it and we would not have had the event we had without the teamwork between him, his colleague Liz, and Rita from Rita Ellis Events. Most importantly, Adam and Liz worked with their chef to help recreate Chilean empanadas that are so important to my husband’s side of the family. Those empanadas were AMAZING and were the main hit amongst all of our guests. If you want excellent food and need excellent logistical support for a complex event, look no further than By Hand.“

“We ordered from Lighthouse Deli for my son’s graduation party and it was AMAZING! The heroes were packed and delicious, delicious meatballs, penne Ala vodka, and my favorite was the Broccoli Rabe with Sausage. Tony was a pleasure to work with and delivered the food and was so nice. The best experience with our first catering order from Lighthouse. Thank you so much Tony and all who made the delicious food!“

“The best authentic Guatemalian food, plus they have great birria tacos. La mejor comida auténtica de Guatemala, además de que tienen excelentes tacos de birria.“

“Would definitely recommend for a nice handmade pasta meal. They were able to accommodate dietary restrictions (vegan and vegetarian) and still had a wonderful tasting pasta. We also had half plates of zucchini fries which was huge, and a half plate of baked clams, which came with 6 clams.“

“They catered our wedding and it was done to absolute perfection. The cocktail hour food was everything we were hoping for. The cocktails were perfect all night! The dinner came out hot, incredibly delicious, and in record time for all guests (200+ person wedding) we can't say enough good things about grace & grit + staff! Amazing food. Amazing drinks. Amazing staff. They take it seriously and they know what they're doing!“

“East End Clambake catered my daughter’s and my mother’s joint birthday party in my backyard in July. I cannot describe how amazing and wonderful they were every step of the way. We ended up renting chairs and tables as well as went with the The East End Lobster Bake package, with fried chicken (the only catered who offered this as an addition to lobster!) Patricia coordinated everything and really made it so very easy. I can’t remember the two women who came to the event along with the chef but they really out themselves, our 60 guests were truly delighted and the food was incredible. No one left hungry, that is for sure!!!! They really know how to run a smooth operation and all of the staff were so lovely to work with. They are absolutely the best!!!!“

“Highly recommend Matt Kar and his team at Christopher Michael Catering! They were extremely professional and super easy to work with! Matt Kar is so understanding and accommodating which really helped to make our wedding less stressful! They definitely went above and beyond for our wedding and we couldn’t be happier with their service! Their food is phenomenal and so delicious!! Compared to other caterers in the area the pricing was great especially for how much they offer and do for you! We would not have been able to have a wedding on the East End if we didn’t have Christopher Michael Catering helping us! We’re so grateful for them and they truly made our wedding day even more special!“