23 Best Italian Restaurants near Mattituck

“If you’re in Mattituck, NY, and craving an authentic Italian dining experience, A Mano Italian Restaurant should be at the top of your list. From the moment you step in, the warm, welcoming atmosphere makes you feel right at home.

Start your meal with their mussels appetizer, which is absolutely delicious—each mussel is perfectly cooked and served in a rich, flavorful sauce that sets the tone for the rest of your meal. The Sunday Special is always a treat, showcasing the chef’s creativity and dedication to fresh, seasonal ingredients. I highly recommend the pan-seared cod, which was a standout dish with its perfectly crisp exterior and tender, flaky interior, complemented by a beautifully balanced sauce.

No meal is complete without dessert, and A Mano’s cannolis are not to be missed. They are filled with a creamy, sweet ricotta filling that is both indulgent and satisfying.

Overall, A Mano offers an exceptional dining experience with its authentic flavors and inviting ambiance. It’s a place where every detail, from the food to the atmosphere, reflects a true appreciation for Italian cuisine. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, A Mano is a gem that promises to delight.“

“Great local place with excellent food and wine in a comfortable friendly atmosphere.“

“Lovely dinner with my family last night. Waitstaff could have came around to keep drinks full and make sure our needs were met. Food was delicious but someone needs to please clean that pizza oven. Burn bottom and crust was a bummer as everything else was very nice. Photo is my take home slices. All three pies were this way. Such a shame. My family came from MA.“

“Centro 336...Every moment from start to finish was perfect. The owners are attentive and ensure that everyone is happy with their dining experience. They truly care about their clientele. The service was wonderful and I can't say enough about the food. Large portions of beautifully prepared , delicious food. We ate more than we should have but it was too good to resist. The menu offers a variety of options to accommodate everyone's taste. Some of the items we had were the watermelon salad, the baked clams, the wild mushroom pappardelle, the roasted chicken and the crispy parmesan potatoes. For dessert we indulged in tiramisu, mini cannolis and cheesecake. There wasn't a single item that disappointed. It was well worth the drive east to Hampton Bays! We look forward to returning there again soon!!“

“The food is wonderful here!“

“The staff was amazing to me. I enjoyed everything down to the last bite. I love your restaurant and it was in walking distance. I went from my hotel last night. This place has an amazing staff and beautiful views. I definitely recommend it“

“My wife and I LOVE Maroni's Restaurant. It is our very favorite place. Their cuisine is fabulous! We love the entire menu. Recently, we tried their 'Sushi night' on tuesdays. So delicious. The drinks from their bar are phenomenal. Lastly, the owner and staff are so warm, welcoming and genuine. We cannot say enough about this wonderful place. --Rob & Leesa Engel“

“Excellent food ..cooked to perfection..Great wait staff..Cozy & Inviting…“

“The food is amazing and the staff is incredible. We had a blast there last evening. Can’t wait to go back!“

“Really Italian food! Homemade pasta! U should go ❤️“

“Absolutely phenomenal lunch at Limoncello Ristorante! We showed up straight from the beach in flip-flops and swimsuits, and felt completely at ease in the relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. Despite the casual vibe, the food was anything but — every dish we ordered was outstanding. Fresh ingredients, perfect seasoning, and generous portions made it one of the best meals we've had in a long time. If you're anywhere near South Hampton, make this your lunch spot. We’ll definitely be back!“

“The food is excellent and the pizza is even better. There once a week. You will be pleased.“

“We've lived in this area for almost 10 years and had never been. Probably because our kids are now finally old enough to sit properly for a nice meal at a nice restaurant :-) The food was truly amazing. It was a pretty crowded Sat night and parking was hard to find...had to park across the street... despite a fairly long wait for meal...the food was well worth the wait and we got out before any meltdowns:)“

“Good food, friendly spot, big fan. Been coming here for years. Here's my 1 suggestion: for the takeout ...why not offer online ordering? I have to call for take-out, which usually results in the line being busy (in the summer). If I can't get through I have to go elsewhere, which stinks because I live close by. Then, if I do get through, have to provide my credit card info, which is very 2006. Maybe ownership simply doesn't need the takeout biz and prefers it this way, and that's fine, but remains frustrating nonetheless. Just my .02 cents.“

“Had a wonderful Easter dinner and can’t wait to go back.“

“Wish we discovered Lenny’s sooner. Immediately took me back to the days I lived in Brooklyn and LI. Lenny’s exceeded my expectations. Fresh ingredients — all bursting with flavor. Perfect sauces, real cheeses (not plastic-like as so many seem to be), generous whole ingredients. We will be going back and loading up to bring home extras to Vermont. Friendly service too. Thank you Lenny’s! ?“

“Fantastic food - Uncle Joe is a local legend. I've been eating his food since the 80s. Uncle Joe's Veal and Stuffed Artichokes are the Best! Mushroom & Garlic Calzone with or without Ham..Garbage Pie Pizza... getting hungry! Try the Prixe Fixe in the dinning room, full bar, great food and plenty of it, great prices. Awesome Desserts..“

“The food is sooooooo good! Great casual atmosphere, too! Great staff, yummy pizza, and adult beverages. ❤️❤️❤️“

“We ordered Eggplant Rollatini, meatballs with spaghetti, salad and garlic bread with cheese....OMG it was so good. We will definitely go back!!“

“Pizza was great! I will be back“

“Working in the area for several days and found this little gem nearby. We liked it so much this became our lunch spot for the week.

The first day I was craving lentils and they had lentil soup available. I had that with a side of sausages. I also had the fried chicken and vegetables from the hot food bar and then the fried rice. I liked it all. Apparently their pizza is pretty good as well.“

“Born in New York and grew up in Huntington. This is my First time at Romas and visiting mom from Virginia, my son has never been to any authentic New York pizza joints. So when we tried Roma’s, he had the Sicilian and he told the owner “it’s the best pizza he ever ate”. Coincidentally the owner knows Tony from our local pizza place in Virginia. Real glad we got up for some real New York pizza before leaving to go home in little ol’ Virginia.“

“The best in Hampton Bays. They have a sandwich there that I call “el abogado” chicken franchese on garlic bread with cold fresh mozzarella“