21 Best Italian Restaurants near Mattituck

1

A Mano

A Mano Italian • $$
13550 Main Rd, Mattituck

Customers` Favorites

Linguine Shrimp Crabmeitat Chilies Emon armen27
Fig and Prosciutto Pizza
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Homemade Bread with Oil
Chicken Parmigiana
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Pasta Bolognese
Sunday's Gravy
Burrata Salad

“A Mano has been one of our go to spots for years. They're consistently great. The only problem is, I keep ordering the same things because I like them so much. The mushroom pizza is to die for, their pastas are always perfect, and the atmosphere is romantic, perfect for date night. The place just has charm, and the staff is always super friendly, welcoming and attentive.“

4.3 Superb58 Reviews
Michelangelo Pizzeria Pizza • $$
10095 Main Rd, Mattituck

Customers` Favorites

Broiled Seafood Platter
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Vegetable Pizza
Fritti Di Mare
Veal Milanese

“Lovely dinner with my family last night. Waitstaff could have came around to keep drinks full and make sure our needs were met. Food was delicious but someone needs to please clean that pizza oven. Burn bottom and crust was a bummer as everything else was very nice. Photo is my take home slices. All three pies were this way. Such a shame. My family came from MA.“

3.7 Good49 Reviews
Centro Trattoria & Bar Italian • $$$
3525 336 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 8.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Housemade Burrata Con Prosciutto
Antipasto Classico for Two
Burrata Appetizer Special
Mini Cannolis 3 Per Order
Pappardelle Bolognese
Spicy Shrimp Rigatoni
NY Strip Peppernatta
Cavatelli Carbonara
Organic Wild Salmon
Rigatoni Carbonara

“Restaurant Week menu was just as good as the regular menu and the portions were just as big. We had a really great waitress, Colleen, who was thoroughly attentive, cheerful, and polite. Thursday night is music night and we loved the duo...piano and singer. Their classic repertoire was really dining music and we thoroughly listening to them. All in all our evening at Centro was great!“

4.5 Superb210 Reviews
Maroni Southold Italian
54195 Main Rd, Southold - 7.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Toasted Marshmallows over Chocolate Mousse
Ribs with Gummi Bear Glaze
Chicken Parmigiana
Penne Ala Vodka
Sushi Tuesday

“Maroni's is such a gem in the middle of Southold. The Sushi Tuesdays are INCREDIBLE and the truffle grilled cheese is to absolutely DIE for. Kristen & Amber are 2 of the best on the North Fork and if you've not had their meatball pot yet I IMPLORE you to do so. And this is coming from someone who doesnt eat meatballs outside her Nonna's kitchen.

I can not express this enough but make reservations and enjoy the fact that the place deals in cash/check/zelle only and that the prices on the menu reflect tax & tip so you can know exactly what you're spending in advance.“

4.7 Superb58 Reviews
Villa Paul Italian • $$
162 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Eggplant Tower with Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Red Peppers
Homemade Bread Pudding Seasonal Flavors
Oysters Rockefeller and Oysters Casino
Roast Long Island Duckling
Chicken Parmigiana
Almond Joy Sundae
Veal Saltimbocca
Fried Calamari
Clams Casino
Baked Clams

“The food is wonderful here!“

4.7 Superb65 Reviews
Grana Trattoria Antica & Enoteca Italian • $$
1556 Main Rd, Jamesport - 3.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wood Roasted Eggplant Pizza
Grilled Artichoke Salad
Wild Mushroom Pizza
Eggplant Parmigiana
Margherita Pizza
White Clam Pizza
Grilled Octopus
Not Your Mom
Fig Pizza
Jamesport

“Excellent food ..cooked to perfection..Great wait staff..Cozy & Inviting…“

4.5 Superb95 Reviews
Touch of Venice Italian • $$$
28350 Main Rd, Cutchogue - 2.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Shrimp in Scampi Sauce
Linguine Con Vongole
Linguine with Clams
Rigatoni Bolognese
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Stuffed Artichoke
Grilled Swordfish
Veal Parmigiana
Beef Bolognese
Fluke Francese

“The food is amazing and the staff is incredible. We had a blast there last evening. Can’t wait to go back!“

4.5 Superb76 Reviews
Edgewater Restaurant Italian • $$
295 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Filet Mignon and Shrimp and Mushroom
Shrimp Oreganata & Risotto
Roasted Duck Pizza
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Almond Cream Cake
Chicken Parmesan
Blueberry Waffle
Side of Risotto
Chicken Cutlet
Fried Calamari

“The staff was amazing to me. I enjoyed everything down to the last bite. I love your restaurant and it was in walking distance. I went from my hotel last night. This place has an amazing staff and beautiful views. I definitely recommend it“

4.4 Superb172 Reviews
Limoncello Ristorante Italian • $$
21 Hill St, Southampton - 10.44 miles

“They were kind enough to let me and a friend have a lovely dinner very close to their Monday closing time. I had limoncello chicken and my friend veal parmigiana. The food was absolutely superb, delicious and cooked so well. Plates were so beautifully presented was a shame to take a bite. I had a beautiful glass of Chianti. What else could you ask for . The ladies taking care of us were attentive, kind and well spoken. I have no complaints at all. It was spectacular. Thank you so much
Sarah Halsey“

4.3 Superb20 Reviews
Il Giardino Restaurant by John Gambino Italian • $$$
739 Main Rd, Aquebogue - 5.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bolognese Pappardelle
House Made Fresh Mozz Salad
Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato
Pasta with Scallops
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
North Fork Paccheri
Halibut Puttanesca
Chicken Parmigiana
White Clam Sauce
Gorgonzola Salad

“Chef John Gambino and his team are welcoming. The service was excellent and he came around and visited the patrons at the tables and bar. His Sicilian cooking reminded me of my Sunday dinners at home. The filet of sole, vegetarian lasagna, caponata and eggplant parmigiana were delicious. Thank you for a great experience. Maria Pia“

3.9 Good122 Reviews
Michelangelo Southold Italian • $$
53345 Main Rd, Southold - 7.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Slice Pizza
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Piccata
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Fried Calamari
Eggplant Pizza
Grandma Pizza
Garlic Knots

“The food is excellent and the pizza is even better. There once a week. You will be pleased.“

3.8 Good84 Reviews
Barrila's Pastaria Restaurant & Bar + Catering Services & Event Venue Italian • $$
300 E Main St, Riverhead - 8.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Assorted Meatballs in Sauce
Spinach and Cheese Ravioli
La Pastaria Risotto Fungi
Vitello Milanese Panini
Bucatini Amatriciana
Caprese Salad Small
Shrimp Francaise
Spinach Ravioli
Appetizers
Meatballls

“Really Italian food! Homemade pasta! U should go ❤️“

3.8 Good117 Reviews
Lenny's Pizza & Bistro (AKA Lenny's of Jamesport) Pizza • $
1451 Main Rd, Jamesport - 4.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Square Pie
Chicken Francaise
Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken
Slice of Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Caprese Salad
Veal Cardinale
Chicken Bacon
Chicken Wings

“I am a Shipt shopper and travel to Riverhead once or twice a week. After a long day, I always look for something fast, delicious, and satisfying. Since I love Italian food, I googled an Italian restaurant nearby and came across Lenny Pizza & Bistro.

My first visit was on September 22, 2025, when I ordered the baked ziti, sautéed spinach, and garlic knots. This was actually my first time ever having freshly baked garlic knots—and they were incredible! That entire meal was so delicious, I knew I’d be back.

On September 29, 2025, I returned and tried the meat lasagna with the sautéed spinach and garlic knots—it was absolutely perfect. Yesterday, I found myself craving that lasagna again and just had to go back. Once more, I ordered the meat lasagna, spinach, and garlic knots, and it was every bit as amazing as the last time.

The food here is consistently fresh, flavorful, and comforting—exactly what I need after a long workday. I can honestly say Lenny Pizza & Bistro has quickly become my go-to spot in Riverhead. Highly recommend!

—Victoria“

4.6 Superb59 Reviews
Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant Pizza • $$
1271 Noyack Rd, Southampton - 7.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Seared Local Calamari
Meatball Sliders
Eggplant Sliders
Arugula
Pizza

“Restaurant was packed as is usual at this time of the year.However the food,and service was not compromised. Fried artichokes were excellent,as was the arugula pizza,and egg plant pizza as well!
However for me as a gluten free Celiac customer, i needed gluten free pasta.Well they not only had it but it was the best I had ever had!!! It was the shrimp fra diavalo over ziti.Perfect heat to a firm pasta cooked perfectly in a separate pot as not to cross contaminate,now that's customer service !
If you want a terrific meal without stupid Hampton prices, come to this terrific local restaurant ,you won't be disappointed!“

4.6 Superb50 Reviews
Slice of the Hamptons Pizza • $
20 County Rd 39, Southampton - 9.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Peter's Drunken Grandma
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Meatballs or Sausage
Roast Beef Supreme
Bruschetta Pizza
Grilled Chicken
Peter's Grandma
Chicken Wings
Fresh Cannoli

“We ordered Eggplant Rollatini, meatballs with spaghetti, salad and garlic bread with cheese....OMG it was so good. We will definitely go back!!“

4.5 Superb82 Reviews
Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour - The Hamptons Institution Since 1968 Pizza • $
42 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kid's Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce
Brooklyn Garlic Parmesan Knots
Fully Loaded Meat Pizza
Kid's Penne Alla Vodka
Meatball Parm Platter
Spicy Buffalo Pizza
Italian Cheesecake
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parm Hero
Pizza Margherita

“Fantastic food - Uncle Joe is a local legend. I've been eating his food since the 80s. Uncle Joe's Veal and Stuffed Artichokes are the Best! Mushroom & Garlic Calzone with or without Ham..Garbage Pie Pizza... getting hungry! Try the Prixe Fixe in the dinning room, full bar, great food and plenty of it, great prices. Awesome Desserts..“

4.2 Good152 Reviews
Cucina 25 Pizza • $
2802, 12 W Main St, Riverhead - 8.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Penne Bolognese Pasta
Classic Cheese Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Parm Hero
Penne Florentine
Grilled Chicken
Lobster Ravioli
Choice of Pasta
Fried Calamari
12 Garlic Knots

“The food is sooooooo good! Great casual atmosphere, too! Great staff, yummy pizza, and adult beverages. ❤️❤️❤️“

4.2 Good115 Reviews
Roma Pizzeria Pizza • $
31455 Main Rd, Cutchogue - 3.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Pie
Marinara Sauce
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Salad

“Born in New York and grew up in Huntington. This is my First time at Romas and visiting mom from Virginia, my son has never been to any authentic New York pizza joints. So when we tried Roma’s, he had the Sicilian and he told the owner “it’s the best pizza he ever ate”. Coincidentally the owner knows Tony from our local pizza place in Virginia. Real glad we got up for some real New York pizza before leaving to go home in little ol’ Virginia.“

4 Good47 Reviews
Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza Pizza • $
801 County Rd 39 #2, Southampton - 8.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza

“Working in the area for several days and found this little gem nearby. We liked it so much this became our lunch spot for the week.

The first day I was craving lentils and they had lentil soup available. I had that with a side of sausages. I also had the fried chicken and vegetables from the hot food bar and then the fried rice. I liked it all. Apparently their pizza is pretty good as well.“

3.9 Good56 Reviews
Scotto's Pork Store Deli • $$
25 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Hero
Tiramisu

“The best in Hampton Bays. They have a sandwich there that I call “el abogado” chicken franchese on garlic bread with cold fresh mozzarella“

3.9 Good64 Reviews
Sergio's Pizza Pizza • $
739 Old Country Rd, Riverhead - 7.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom and Pepperoni
Chicken Parmesan
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Special
Veggie Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Everything
Sicilian

“Pizza was great! I will be back“

3.8 Good74 Reviews

Mattituck’s related cuisines

You May Also Like