15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mayville

“We reserved Truffle Honey for our rehearsal dinner and welcome party the evening before our September 2025 wedding. We’ve really enjoyed this restaurant any time we’ve visited for dinner, and our event was beyond phenomenal!

Our rehearsal dinner was held inside the restaurant, where staff organized a few long tables to accomodate about 50 people. We had a family style dinner and the food was amazing - they never miss!

We had beautiful weather so our welcome party guests were able to enjoy both the restaurant and the beer garden - enjoting buffet style food and drinks from both bars! We could not have picked a better venue and would recommend Truffle Honey to anyone looking for a similar venue with great food!“

“The eggplant parmesan,lasagna,blueberry coco moijito,red sangria, and tiramisu Where all excellent. The servers,bartender where all very efficient and helped each other out.Highly recommend.“

“Beautiful little bar/restaurant inside of Chautauqua Suites hotel. Went for thursday wing night and happy hour. The place was busy but the servers were right on top of it. Sat at the bar and received great friendly service from all staff. Wings were killer. Recommend trying the rootbeer bbq and honey mustard. Happy hour specials were remarkably affordable and drinks were good. 40 dollars for 3 people to eat and drink is hard to find in 2024 especially for a sit down restaurant with a great atmosphere with great food. Everything else we saw come out to the other patrons tables looked great too. Will be back.“

“Best bbq chicken wing pizza around!! Stuffed crust too!!!“

“The nicest people you could meet, and some of the Best food for miles. I live nearby and have enjoyed the Bridgeview for years.“

“love everything we have had and love that they deliver to our area!!! always a pleasure to deal with!!!“

“Outstanding pizza and shaped like a buffalo!!! Excellent friendly service and atmosphere outside“

“I ordered a party pizza for my Rookie Wild Eagles cheerleaders. I thought there would be more than enough because this pizza is huge! Remind you these are 8-10yr old girls and some of them “don’t like pizza”. This pizza was devoured! Even the girls who said they don’t like pizza had several pieces. Thank you Mama’s pizza for an awesome dinner for my girls!“

“Avery has great customer service! Can't wait to order again“

“Stopped in for a Mother’s Day celebration for lunch a day early because everywhere is a mad house on Mother’s Day. Jen was our server and she was wonderful beyond words. The food came out quick and hot. It was delicious! Their menu was awesome- we will definitely be back because there’s so much more to try!“

“I recommend this uniquely artistic and creatively designed establishment. Tyler, our waiter, was very attentive, but truly an intellectual when sharing local historical information. The drink & food menu was diversely expansive featuring a delectable array of gourmet selections. Our group went with ordering an appetizer of artichoke cheese dip, which was dangerously delicious, followed by the main course featuring “white chicken & spinach pizza”, the to good to describe broiled Haddock, and savory chicken parmesan with homemade marinara sauce spaghetti.
The entire experience was rewarding and worth the drive. It’s definitely an establishment that we will look forward to returning to again, and I am looking forward to trying the other selections on the menu. I also noticed that this Restraurant caters to canine companions which is also a positive.“

“What a great place! Always so fun. The food is excellent and the servers are very attentive. Keep doing what you are doing!“

“Best pizza and wings in the area now !! If you haven’t tried it you’re missing out !!“

“come on down to Bridgeview for some amazing lunch made by yours truly❤“

“Great fast service, great food, it's a great experience . We keep going back!! Highly recommend!“