16 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mayville

Truffle Honey Eatery Bar & Grill • $$
3943 NY-394 suite 2, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Creamy Mushroom Chicken Pasta
Kataifi Crusted Crab Cakes
Seasonal Vegetable
Charcuterie Board
Warm Asiago Bread
Wood Fired Salmon
Wood Fired Burger
Margherita Pizza
Brussels Sprouts
Wood Fired Wings

“Absolutely outstanding food. Everything was fresh and came out rather quickly. We ordered the warm asiago bread, salmon and steak. We sat at the bar, and although the bartender was rather busy she was still really attentive and friendly to us. The atmosphere was very cute. The one thing I would say is to make a reservation because seating is limited!“

4.6 Superb145 Reviews
Andriaccio's Restaurant Italian • $$
4837 W Lake Rd, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Linguine with Clam Sauce
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Parmigiana
Cheesesteak Hoagie
Prime Rib Special
Seafood Carbonara
Shrimp Portofino
Homemade Lasagne
Seared Scallops
Deep Dish Pizza

“Family-owned authentic Italian food, extensive wine and craft cocktail menu, family and staff that truly care about the dining experience. Can’t recommend enough.“

4.4 Superb97 Reviews
Bellini Lounge Burgers • $
215 W Lake Rd, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings

“Beautiful little bar/restaurant inside of Chautauqua Suites hotel. Went for thursday wing night and happy hour. The place was busy but the servers were right on top of it. Sat at the bar and received great friendly service from all staff. Wings were killer. Recommend trying the rootbeer bbq and honey mustard. Happy hour specials were remarkably affordable and drinks were good. 40 dollars for 3 people to eat and drink is hard to find in 2024 especially for a sit down restaurant with a great atmosphere with great food. Everything else we saw come out to the other patrons tables looked great too. Will be back.“

3.6 Good14 Reviews
CJ's Pizza & Subs Pizza • $
77 E Main St #1305, Westfield - 6.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Party 1-Topping Pizza & Bucket of Boneless Wings Combo
Dill Pickle Pizza with Mozzarella & Signature Sauce
Fried Mixed Veggies with Ranch or Blue Cheese
Onion Chips with Ranch or Blue Cheese
Mozzarella Sticks with Marinara Sauce
Glazed Cinnamon Knots
Pizza Combos and Subs
Loaded Cheesy Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
Fried Picke Spears

“Best bbq chicken wing pizza around!! Stuffed crust too!!!“

4.6 Superb43 Reviews
Bridgeview One Stop Deli Pizzeria C-Store Pizza Takeaway • $
4910 Main St, Bemus Point - 9.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Famous Boli and Bronco Burgers
Garden Pizza with Pepperoni
Sheet Pizza
Doughnut

“The nicest people you could meet, and some of the Best food for miles. I live nearby and have enjoyed the Bridgeview for years.“

4.6 Superb27 Reviews
Feelin' Saucy Pizzeria Pizza • $
111 W Main St, Sherman - 8.02 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Wings

“love everything we have had and love that they deliver to our area!!! always a pleasure to deal with!!!“

4.4 Superb8 Reviews
Mama's Main Street Pizza Pizza • $
111 W Main St, Sherman - 8.02 miles

“I ordered a party pizza for my Rookie Wild Eagles cheerleaders. I thought there would be more than enough because this pizza is huge! Remind you these are 8-10yr old girls and some of them “don’t like pizza”. This pizza was devoured! Even the girls who said they don’t like pizza had several pieces. Thank you Mama’s pizza for an awesome dinner for my girls!“

4.3 Superb11 Reviews
Lena's Pizza, Subs and Wings Westfield NY Pizza • $
45 E Main St, Westfield - 6.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Chicken Wings
Chicken Finger
Veggie Pizza
Turkey Sub
Quesadilla
Chef Salad
Pizza Logs
Antipasto
Steak Sub

“Great food and service. Highly recommend“

4.2 Good44 Reviews
Coppola's Pizzaria Pizza • $
20 Main St, Bemus Point - 8.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Chicago Style Pizza
Chicken Wing Pizza
Godfather Pizza
Chicken Wings
Greek Pizza
Med Pizza
Sauce

“Outstanding pizza and shaped like a buffalo!!! Excellent friendly service and atmosphere outside“

4 Good48 Reviews
Guppy's Restaurant & Tavern Seafood • $$
4663 NY-430, Bemus Point - 6.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger with Steak Fries
Beer Battered Haddock Fish Fry
Steak Salad with French Fries
Meatball Sub with Fries
The Buffalo Chicken
Mussels Appetizer
Chicken Pot Pie
Lime Margherita
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken Wings

“Guppy’s is our “go-to restaurant.” When someone visits from out of town, we take them to Guppy’s. When I want a Friday fish fry, Guppy’s has the best. Look out for weekday specials! Steamed mussels in butter and garlic for two with a side of fries is awesome. My wife always finds delicious gluten free selections and the chefs are always accommodating. Did I mention the great drinks and beer selection? Gondola seating is fun (a couple of times) and there is patio seating as well as indoors for when the snowmobiles are in use - lol. Highly recommended!

Dietary restrictions: Good choices for celiacs and accommodating chefs.

Parking: Large parking area behind the restaurant. Even that can get full during tourist season but you can park along side road.“

4.5 Superb114 Reviews
Pizza Guru's Barbeque • $
16 E Main St, Brocton - 9.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

- Jumbo Chicken Wings
10 Chicken Fingers
Cauliflower Pizza
Everything Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Assorted Sub
Pizza Sub
8 Ham Sub
Salami
Taco

“Best pizza and wings in the area now !! If you haven’t tried it you’re missing out !!“

4.6 Superb30 Reviews
The Green Door Tavern Bar • $
4739 NY-430, Bemus Point - 6.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Buffalo Wings - Single 10
Jumbo Buffalo Wings - Double 20
Turkey Bacon Cheddar Wrap
Half Order Chicken Wings
Complimentary Popcorn
Medium Chicken Wings
Mac Salad - Large
Peanut Butter Pie
Hot Ham & Cheese
Combo Platter

“What a great place! Always so fun. The food is excellent and the servers are very attentive. Keep doing what you are doing!“

4.5 Superb48 Reviews
Green Arch Restaurant Diner • $
41 W Main St, Brocton - 9.79 miles

“If you are looking for some good home cooking and a sassy fun staff. This is the place. I go every time I am in the area. Sitting at the bar they make you feel like family. They make amazing pies and desserts too!

Just visited again this week and still love the food. Friday I had the fish fry grilled with lemon pepper.....so good. The fish was flavorful, a great flaky white fish. If you are in the area you should drop in.“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Lenas-TaQo Westfield Chicken Wings • $
45 E Main St, Westfield - 6.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brisket

“Great food and service. Highly recommend“

4.1 Good14 Reviews
Bridgeview One Stop Wine & Liquor Pizza • $
4910 Main St, Bemus Point - 9.33 miles

“come on down to Bridgeview for some amazing lunch made by yours truly❤“

3.4 Good5 Reviews
Grace and Abe's Brewpubs • $
14 N Portage St, Westfield - 6.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Farmer's Market Pizza
Mediterranean Pizza
Wood Fired Wings
Pizza and Wings
Pub Pretzels
Creme Brulee
Pizza Spezial
Mac & Cheese
Pulled Pork
Cheesecake

“Great fast service, great food, it's a great experience . We keep going back!! Highly recommend!“

4 Good68 Reviews

You May Also Like