New American Restaurants near Middletown, NY

MIX N MAC - Mac & Cheese New American • $
280 NY-211, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Fried Mac and Cheese Balls
Family Cheddar Mac Balls
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Mac
Chicken and Waffle
Shrimp Scampi Mac
Buffalo Chicken
Sriracha Honey
S'Mores Churros

“Amazing. A must try. I could spend the day eating and everything in the menu.“

4.4 Superb298 Reviews
Clemson Bros. Brewery American • $$
22 Cottage Street, Middletown

“We are camping at neversink RV resort and was looking for a local brewery. And found a nice spot that had a nice mix of brewery and commercial beers. Food was phenomenal. Ownership and general manager. Super nice. Easy to talk to. The place is dog friendly which was very helpful for us. Thank you! Had a great day.“

4.2 Good316 Reviews
Chianti Cow Restaurant New American • $$
1483 US-6, Port Jervis - 8.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Red Peper and Fresh Mozzarella Salad
Charlie Approved Chocolate Mousse
Braised Lamb Shank Wellington
Chianti Cow Bistro Burger
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Hot Appetizer Medley
Our Own Stuffed Pork
Pan Seared Salmon
Fresh Baked Bread
Pepperoni Pizza

“A long time family favorite of ours. Lovely, comfy environment and super delish unique dishes. They’re always changing up their menu to include something new and exciting, in addition to their fantastic menu main-stays.“

4.3 Superb102 Reviews
Christopher's Bistro Bistros • $$
69 Brookside Avenue, Chester - 9.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp and Sausage Andouille Sausage
Cajun Shrimp with Cheddar Grits
Bistro Burger and Yam Fries
Christopher's Chicken Dish
Beet Salad with Shrimp
Roasted Half Chicken
Truffle Parm Fries
Warm Spinach Salad
Sweet Potato Fries
Steak and Potatoes

“I attended a baby shower at Christopher’s this past weekend. The food was delicious. The room and service were perfect! Thanks for making the day special.“

4.7 Superb74 Reviews
Stagecoach Inn, Goshen NY New American • $$$
268 Main St, Goshen - 6.05 miles

“I had a wonderful 50th Bridgerton-themed birthday party, and The Atrium was the perfect venue for the occasion. The Atrium Room was absolutely lovely — filled with natural light, even on a cloudy day. The dinner was delicious, and the outdoor patio seating added a charming touch. The staff was friendly and accommodating, making the evening flow smoothly. I couldn’t have asked for a better setting locally to celebrate such a special milestone!“

4.4 Superb148 Reviews
Delancey's Seafood • $$
40 Park Place, Goshen - 6.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Arugula and Prosciutto Pizza Margherita
Chicken Tenders Onion Soup Wedge Salad
Chicken Wings with Thai Chilli Sauce
Nachos with Chili and Jalapeños
Chicken and Chorizo Fettuccine
Char-Crusted Sirloin Steak
Grilled Vegetable Panini
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Side Mashed Potatoes
Seafood Fra Diavolo

“Just had my best friend’s bachelorette weekend dinner here and it was phenomenal!! The food was great and the owner also covered our bill because of us celebrating her getting married which was so generous!! As “out of towners” from NJ we definitely had a great experience! Thank you so much & God Bless! 🙏🏻“

4.3 Superb132 Reviews
Dobbins' Tavern at the Stagecoach Inn in Goshen, NY American • $$$
268 Main St, Goshen - 6.17 miles

“I had a wonderful 50th Bridgerton-themed birthday party, and The Atrium was the perfect venue for the occasion. The Atrium Room was absolutely lovely — filled with natural light, even on a cloudy day. The dinner was delicious, and the outdoor patio seating added a charming touch. The staff was friendly and accommodating, making the evening flow smoothly. I couldn’t have asked for a better setting locally to celebrate such a special milestone!“

4.3 Superb91 Reviews
Kelley Jean's American • $$
145 North Church Street, Goshen - 5.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Charlie Guarding His Ravioli Parmesan
Honey Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Bacon Cheeseburger and Fries
Charlie Eyeing the Wings
Burger Sliders and Fries
Andrew's Beef on Weck
Cheesesteak Sandwich
Warm Pretzel Sticks
Fried Pickle Burger
Pitcher of Bud Light

“We came here after visiting Legoland because we didn’t want to eat at the hotel there. I found this place online and we wanted to give it a try. I’m SO glad we did. The food was delicious!!! We were happy with everything we got. Our waitress was so sweet and welcoming, she even recommended a local ice cream spot nearby for dessert! You can tell the staff there really cares about their patrons. Highly recommend this lovely restaurant if you are in Goshen!!“

4.3 Superb84 Reviews
Frogs End Tavern & Cortile Bar • $$$
634 Pine Hill Rd, Chester - 8.92 miles

“Such a beautiful relaxing experience with such amazing food. The staff from the minute we arrived for our reservation time to the end was exceptional kind and amazing service. Tre our waiter and the rest of the staff made us feel very welcome. We are looking forward to our next visit.“

4.9 Superb10 Reviews
Howell's Sunflower Café Cafe • $
18 West Main Street, Goshen - 5.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Roll French Toast
Burger
Salad
Wrap

“The food was fresh and simply flavorful. Chris was attentive and friendly. The prices were very reasonable. For 2 sandwiches, smoked salmon spinach salad, 2 ice teas and a smoothie came to less than 50 dollars, go to McDonald's and order 2 meals it will cost about 30 dollars and then food is highly processed. We would definitely go back.“

4 Good50 Reviews