25 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mohegan Lake

“Apparently, we went in the wrong door and stood at the wrong side of the line, the two girls working ignored us, another couple walked in the "right" door and cut us on line. We waited for realistically 5 to 8 minutes scratching our heads as another girl came out of the back and while the one girl struggled in vein to scoop the ice cream the other two girls talked amongst themselves about love, work and managers being bossy, we quietly snuck out the "wrong door" and headed down the road to the next ice cream establishment. Too bad that people today people feel that just because they showed up thats good enough. I do not blame Haagen dazs because most places we go there are children being left unsupervised and refusing to do their jobs. If you can find the help its usually bad. Thanks we'll try again soon.“

“It’s an exciting and fun place.“

“I came here once in 2016 and still think about the ice cream I had. The shop is conveniently located right near the water, so my family and I ate our ice cream on a bench with a great view of the water and mountains. Some of the best ice cream I've ever had! If you ever find yourself in Cold Spring, definitely make a stop! I also love the name!!“

“I first visited the Blue Pig over the summer. I live in Orange County and my family and I wanted to try the ice cream here! I have to say, not only am I super impressed with the amazing products and flavors you have, but EXTREMELY impressed with the sustainabilities that’s been implemented at your business. This is the very thing I’m passionate about and have been trying to suggest with local businesses near me, especially some of the cream places; let’s eliminate single-use plastic utensils that end up in the trash and either get actual compostable utensils (and compost the utensils) or encourage reusing by offering metal ones you can return and wash after eating, just like at Blue Pig. In addition to the water refill! This effort means the world me and very happy to see Blue Pig adopt this. I’m happy to support small businesses who are sustainable. Thank for supporting local and caring for the environment! I’ll certainly be back for another visit:)“

“Such a nice local ice cream shop! Loved the variety on the menu and they even had a frozen dog treats. Flavors and quality of the ice cream are great. Today I had a coconut Kit Kat that was excellent but they also had some vegan/nondairy options that looked tasty. The outdoor area is nice to sit at and dog-friendly. Also appreciate that this is woman and LGBTQ+ owned.“

“Great service and ice cream!“

“Friendly staff. Made me the new rainbow cookie shake and it’s a 10/10.“

“We had pistachio and coconut from the large variety of selections available. This is handmade in the store stuff. Off the charts delicious.
Lovely propietor and assistant doing it old school. Hardest part is knowing which flavors to choose.
Thanks!“

“You may be thinking that all Carvel locations are alike, but they're not. I have visited many Carvel locations in many states, and this one (fortunately my "home" Carvel store) is the best. The soft ice cream is consistently dense and smooth, never runny, and they have a large selections of hard ice creams and sherbets, all of which are delicious. Portion sizes are generous. The staff is friendly and helpful. Never disappointed with anything from this place.“

“Wednesday is Sundae. BOGO“

“I visited this place about 6 times in three weeks. They have a variety of flavors and the staff always was welcoming. I would recommend the mango, raspberry and berry mix. The lines dont stay packed for too long. The staff is speedy yet efficient with cashing orders.“

“Delicious ice cream. Excellent menu choices. There’s no place like King Kone!“

“Lots of flavors to try, good ice cream and games to occupy the children. Nice quiet Main Street to sit outside.“

“Our favorite Carvel by far! The staff is wonderful, always helpful, patient and very accommodating to special requests! The service is great! The store is very clean and they serve quality ice cream and beautifully decorated cakes (they can make pretty much make any design/style you want). Another plus- convenient hours and location. The best ice cream shop around!“

“Love the milk shakes here. Just a quality fun place that makes you smile. Enjoy.“

“The unicorn ice is amazing!“

“After a grueling hike, a cold and refreshing treat is exactly what my friends and I needed! Bozerinos offer various treats: ice cream; soft serve; Italian ice; and milkshakes!

We tried the Lil Blue Panda, which seems to be a mix of cookies-and-cream with another flavor. It was very good and not too sweet.

If you are craving something sweet though, definitely try the Salted Caramel Brownie or the Deep Crunch Apple Pie (I may have spelt this flavor wrong, but if you go, you can probably figure out which Apple Pie flavor I am talking about). Both are guarantee to satisfy any sweet tooth that customers may have.

Of course, you can go for the classical flavors they have there: Birthday Cake; Chocolate Mint Chip; Rocky Road; and many more. Please note it is cash only!“

“After bike ride meal. Place is packed with bikers on good weather weekends though many just getting Powerade.“

“I literally can't recommend this place enough! we stayed in cold spring for 4 nights and got food here everyday haha! we tried pretty much everything and EVERYTHING was delicious! freshly cooked, with love! the staff are super friendly and welcoming too. absolutely 5 stars!“

“No better place to reward yourself after a vigorous bike ride on the North County Trail way. Where else can one get Cooke Monster flavored ice cream and the best smoothies in Westchester County? A super friendly staff adds to the fun.“

“This is absolutely the best Carvel. Dana & Sal are awesome proprietors.“

“Let's now discuss the pizza, which is the true star of the show. Tutto Pizza offers a variety of delectable alternatives, all of which are meticulously prepared. Each pizza is a true work of art, from the traditional Margherita, which displays the ideal mix of acidic tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and aromatic basil, to their creative gourmet combinations.A special note should be made of their crust, which is the prefect combination of chewy and crispy and provides as the excellent backdrop for the delectable toppings. Whether you like a fluffy, thick crust or one that is thin and crispy, Tutto Pizza has you covered.“

“The ice cream is good but the manager was rude. I went in with 5 people and I was paying on my own and when they ask whose next it was my turn . When I got to the counter she stated I was with the other woman. I explained I am paying my own so I would be next. She said I had to wait til they were done as I was part of that group . So needless to say by the time I received my order I had to take it to go as my friends were done with their ice cream . The young woman who helped me was very nice but the manager/owner needs lessons in customer service.“

“Was impressed with the quality of danishes, been here a couple weeks in a row, and they seem to be on top of things, so far its been very consistent.“

“Burger were great, the staff was courteous 👍“