Restaurants in Montauk

“Loved this restaurant! Everything we had was delicious, you can't go wrong. the service was great. Wish we lived closer! Must visit if you're in the area”

“On a yacht delivery from Ft Lauderdale to P'Town. Stopped in for the night (late June 2023) and needed a good dinner. Saw this cute/unique restaurant on way to the typical fried seafood place down the road. Didn't care for the "attitude" and decided to come back to Rooted - so glad we did. Great food, smoked Old Fashion was beyond delicious, and our server Masha and bartender Sarah went above and beyond to make our dinner experience great. Small, only a few tables, which allows for the chef to cook the food to perfection. Highly recommended and will come back on next trip.”

“Fried chicken was amazing, legit some of the best I’ve ever had.It was quite packed/seemed a bit disorganized when we were there, so here’s a tip: go to the back to order the fried chicken / sides. Once they hand it to you, go check out at the front. You don’t need to wait in line to pay at the deli counter.”

“Great lobster rolls !!! - Good service!”

“We ordered Dani roll and Dragon roll. Both were yummy. Wish it was less expansive so we can get more varieties. Not crowded. We were there around 2pm on Saturday. Would recommend giving this place a try. Also tea are complimentary.”

“Great service by all.Food was amazing and the bartender offered exceptional service.”

“The fries were amazing, they only had one working bathroom while we’re were here and it is a tight squeeze. There was a line and the sink was not draining well. The lobster roll was delish but the kids chicken quesadilla was amazing! I stole quite a few bites. My husband had the fish sandwich also good! The drinks were cold and delicious. We got sat right away but the food took a bit long to come out.”

“BEST pizza ever, made with the finest ingredients. Delightful staff in a charming setting. Don't miss out!”

“The sushi was so fresh. Presentation was beautiful. The place is standing room, bar like with seating outside. Nice when it's warm. Tucked away from the marinas but not too far. Loved it.”

“Great porterhouse and considerate and friendly employees”

“Bartender was very friendly told us about the drink Bingo that was happening that night. Great drinks! We ordered two frose’, delicious ! Cheers to Bounce !”

“Acaí done right. The acaí is blended the proper way and remains thick, not soupy. The fruit is always fresh, the granola is always crisp.”

“Soup dumplings are my daughter’s favorite! Love this place!”

“I got my husbands 40th bday catered by Quinchos and it was such a big hit!!! Everyone including the kids loved their food. All the food was excellent! We are already thinking about the next time we come to town and order again!”

“Great vibe casual dining great smoothie and breakfast burrito 🌯 nice staff”

“Great specials, very busy but attentive staff! All food has been very good...we've been several times, always have seafood/ fish. Peanut butter pie is to die for!! YUM!!”

“Food was great,service is fast! Just wished that there’s more smoothie on the Acai bowl, they put very little and too much on the peanut butter. Would recommend coming in around 2ish, which is easier to get seat and more quiet”

“The Beach Club is a fantastic way to spend your afternoon. Our server Luna, went above and beyond to ensure we had a great time. I've been coming to Gurneys for many years and service has been mixed but today was great and I'm looking forward to visiting again next season. Happy Labor Day!”

“Food is fresh and delicious. If you’re looking for a warm, home cooked type meal, this is the best spot. Have been here several times and am never disappointed. Friendly staff, extremely clean, and reasonably priced.”

“Quaint spot! Food was delicious!”

“Our family of 10 walked in and had the best pizza � for a great price. We were super pleased and plan to make a trip back for sure!”

“It was amazing to be part of this silent protest in opposition to a project that doesn't belong at Ditch. Thanks to everyone who organized it and for all who attended. Now sign the petitions.”

“Food is delicious and affordable. This place is great! Different meats prepared daily, serving breakfast and lunch. My boyfriend and I stop here anytime we’re stumped on what to eat. Staff are so nice and efficient! This place doesn’t experience the crowds that other places do in Montauk during the summer, which I selfishly love!”

“Great food amazing lasagna great service. Mario made our night so special. We will see you next year. A hidden gem for sure.”

“Best Lobster Roll in Montauk”

“Great coffee!! And great service!”

“First time trying this place....very simple menu...american food...my husband and I ordered the potato skinny for appetizers ( very basic potato skins)Entree ihad a turkey burger..made very well. My husband at the shrimp tacos,which he enjoyed alot. If you are looking very simple laid back place then I would highly recommend this restaurant. If you are looking for more of an elaborate menu with a nice view,this may not be your place. Restaurant was clean,staff very nice.”

“This is our go to whe. We are out in Montauk. We usually do lunch but this time we did dinner and wow were we blown away.

We had a salmon dinner with creative and ample sides and also a penne with fennel which the pink vodka sauce was in my opinion best I ever had .. also had the portobello burger with this pesto and fig sauce that blew me away .

Honestly for all the new and choices joints in Montauk for the Price point, serving size and QUALITY ..maybe skip the usual tourist traps by the water and try this local town gem. We ha e consistently eaten there for 15 years and never ever disappoints.

Keep doing what ya doing NG see you in 2026”

“We LOVE it here!!! The food is AMAZING and fresh, the staff are welcoming, and so polite! Tables are spread out and you feel 100% safe. Service is top notch and the owners are the NICEST people. We come out here every Summer and you bet we are here atleast once or twice on vacation. It’s that good! My daughter loves the shrimp and lobster. 🍤🦞”

“Best pizza ever! The Sicilian pizza was fluffy, spongy with the perfect about of crunch to the bread base topped with a delicious slightly sweet tomatoes sauce and perfect amount of cheese. Pepe's Pizza has nothing on these guys.”

“Excellent quality of food, excellent attentive, service, and a beautiful beach setting. The shrimp taco, sword fish, scallops and caramel cheesecake were all correct.”

“excellent service.. excellent food../ amazing fluke sashimi!! and that burger!!! yum”

“Went for dinner and drinks and had a great experience. Service was super attentive and the lobster pasta was to die for. I will go back just for that dish! Then drinks in the patio by the water was so nice. Though $30 per cocktail is criminal!”

“We have been going to see Tom at Star Island Grill for quite some time....whether we have fish or not....
He and his crew have treated us to an amazing meal and friendship, each time...
Tonight, he had time to prepare something a little different.... the night before, we were talking about things we like.... and tonight, he prepared 3 dishes with all we talked about... absolutely over the top flavor and quality!
All dishes were Fluke....
1) Fish in Sambuca sauce with zucchini over asparagus.
2) Panco Crusted with tomatoes, onion and peppers in wine sauce over vegetables
3) Shrimp Stuffed filet over risotto
And the most delicious brownie, custard, ice cream as dessert...”

“Stop here every time I’m here. Great food and good coffee.”

“The atmosphere is seaside casual. An open floor plan exists with a nice bar on one side. It’s airy inside with high ceilings. The food and service is always great. The specials are always a delight. Prices are moderate and fair. Portions are generous.”

“Great local brewery now at QuickChek!”

“This place is amazing! Very clean, great food and wonderful service! We go for breakfast anytime we are visiting Montauk. The coffee is freshly brewed, they have a variety of breakfast options from healthy to indulgent, something for everyone.”

“Yummmmmmmmmy! Best milkshakes in the universe!”

“Foods great ! Nice people like you’d expect to find in The Hamptons !”

“Goldberg's Famous Bagels in Montauk serves up authentic New York-style bagels with a crispy exterior and soft, chewy interior, with their everything flagel earning high praise as a standout. The bustling spot offers a wide variety of creative cream cheeses and hearty breakfast sandwiches, though lines can be long during peak season. Despite occasional service hiccups, the fresh, flavorful bagels and casual vibe make it a go-to for locals and visitors.”

“great grab and go sandwiches with excellent home made condiments to customize, mom liked her coffee, crumb cake was also nice. I got grilled chicken wrap with herb mayo, honestly had low expectations, was VERY pleased, and glad.”

“I ordered a lobster fried rice and added beef, and it was a thing of beauty. The fried rice was done to perfection with the beef and lobster, the rice had wok-hei and very balanced with each rice coated with eggs. The lobster goes very well with the brocolli. Generous portion of lobster and food. 5 stars!”

“Really good place to get a good, quick, and cheap meal. The tacos are amazing and made fresh in front of you. The staff is also so nice and very efficient. The tortillas are what makes these the best tacos in Montauk. The food is always fresh and really good. It's the perfect place to go to grab a quick bite before, after, or during a stroll downtown.”

“My favorite place in Montauk . Sunset 🌅 is the best there”

“I am from Manhattan. After walking around downtown Montauk, I lanes in this simple eatery. I ordered Fish & Chips. The fries(chips) are crunchy and the fried fish is crispy and fresh. Highly recommended.”

“food= awesome! the best burger sliders ever!”

“It was my first time at Ruschmeyer’s in Montauk, and from the moment I arrived, I felt right at home. The front desk team was warm, welcoming, and went above and beyond—helping with my bags and giving me a great lay of the land.

The rooms were beautifully designed, spacious, and comfortable. But the real magic was in the shared spaces—the expansive lawn, cozy fire pits (complete with a s’mores kit!), shady trees perfect for relaxing, and a stylish bar and lounge area inside.

The location couldn’t be better—just about 0.7 miles to downtown and the beach, making for an easy walk or bike ride. We made the most of our time here and are leaving tan, full, and completely satisfied. Couldn’t ask for more—already looking forward to my next visit!”

“great place, great owners! it a must to go here and try the food and drinks! 5 STARS!”