Bagels Restaurants near Montauk, NY

“As a team of 30 working on-site in Montauk, coordinating meals for a large group can be a challenge, but Theresa made breakfast one of the easiest parts of our week. She was wonderful to work with, easy to communicate with, and incredibly accommodating throughout the ordering process.

We ordered 30 Sunshine Start bagels, and they were a huge hit with our crew. Everything was fresh, delicious, and a great way to start the day before long hours on-site. We especially appreciated Theresa's attention to detail and willingness to accommodate team members with dietary restrictions, including gluten-free and dairy-free options.

The food was excellent, the service was seamless, and the entire experience was stress-free. We would highly recommend this spot to anyone looking for a reliable and delicious breakfast option in Montauk.“

“Goldberg loves bacon! Not kosher or halal. Good everything bagel. Toasted to a crispy bite. Bacon cooked well. Eggs were fluffy fried. Cheese well melted. BEC porportions were just right. A bit too much ketcup. Service could have b3en friendlier. Topped off the meal with a large ice coffee. Came out to over 16. Not sure how but ok. I still may come back.

Stopped by again last weekend of summer 2025.
Was staying at hither hills campground and going fishing at 8am that day. Wanted to start the morning off early with a fresh bagel and ice coffee. They open at 6am and we got there around 620. They didn’t have bagels yet. The guy behind the counter couldn’t say when they would get their bagel delivery, “ could be in 10 minutes, could be twenty,” he exclaimed.
:( Bae was disappointed and I was a little too. I settled with a bacon egg and cheese or …. A roll. Ate it on the boat.“