50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mount Ivy

“I've ordered twice under the new ownership so far. It's not terrible. I think there's room for improvement. my first order was a chicken parm hero which was delivered. I would recommend the bread to be toasted and crispy as opposed to just warmed. I will also recommend not wrapping it up while it's piping hot in foil because when it arrived and was opened, every bit of the cheese stuck to the foil and it was unsalvageable. definitely could use some bit more sauce, and chicken for the price. and tonight we ordered a pizza and garlic knots. it was just okay. not terrible but nothing to write home about. we specifically asked for it well done and it wasn't even close. the crust is chewy and almost stale tasting. which also made the garlic knots chewy. Mr Crispy, with all due respect, perhaps try to live up to the name by making your breads and dough actually crispy or somewhat crispy?“

“I Sent my friend a Johnny's pizza for his 70th birthday last week. Unbeknownst to me, my friend was in the hospital during that time. I called Johnny's and advised them of this and they very graciously Sent a free pizza, celebrating my friends healthy return home. My old friend just finished the pizza, and shared it was delicious. Not only are Johnny's Pizzas Large, their kind Hearts are even Bigger! Bravo and God Bless, Mike C from North Carolina“

“Love Rocks Kitchen- good and healthy food! Smoothies are out of this world!!“

“Came in for Friday evening take out. Love watching a glimpse of the cooking in the back and appreciate the zeppoli treats. Not just pizza it is authentic Italian cuisine. Never a bad meal.“

“Friendly staff, great food! Cool location but should be more centrally located. Too good to be kept a secret :)“

“Besides that the food is delicious and gets prepped very fast!!
the workers are soo kind! My baby made a huge mess and before I got a chance to clean it up they reassured me that they’ll clean it up and I shouldn’t worry about it! 🥹🥹“

“We stopped here while traveling from RI to PA and WOW are we glad we did. We needed a place to accommodate our small pup so we stopped to ask if they had outdoor seating. They didn’t but they created it by carrying a table and chairs outside for us - talk about customer service! Nick was such a fantastic host - setting us up, providing exceptional service and great conversation! I also can’t forget to mention how incredible the pizza and chicken roll were! This place is a 10/10 and we will definitely find a reason to stop back again!“

“Amazing food and excellent service! Everything is always delicious!! Pizzetiello is now one of our family dinner go-to spots when dining out.“

“Goddamn the pizza is so good here. I don’t know why we even waste time with any of the other places around here.“

“Excellent! Food was so fresh and fabulous and so was the service. Pizza crust was delicious and light. Everyone was so very nice and accommodating. Great atmosphere and concept of Pizza by the foot. So good that weekends are packed, so make a reservation or try a weeknight. You will not be disappointed!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Best pizza in town! Yummy Pizza in Monsey serves amazing, fresh pizza, and their homemade jalapeño calzone is absolutely delicious. Friendly staff, great service, and a cozy atmosphere make it a perfect spot for a bite. Highly recommend!“

“Martio's is my go-to pizza spot. Whenever we have family visiting, it’s a must-stop so they can experience some truly fantastic pizza. The dough is perfect, with just the right amount of crust. The sauce hits all the right notes, and the pizza is loaded with cheesy goodness. If I had to choose between Martio's and any other pizza in the world, I’d choose Martio's without hesitation.

Beyond the pizza, the Italian combo sandwich is delicious, and the pasta fagioli soup, garlic bread, antipasto, and gelato are all standout dishes. 10/10, will always recommend.“

“The best food and family in the world 🌎“

“Yesterday 1st time had the ribs to die for .loved it all except the mac and cheese was a little to dry and wasnt a fan of the shell macaroni.but i did see a pizza pie go by and man it looks real good.im coming back my family and turn them on.“

“We just got dinners from Gerard’s for the first time. Definitely will be going back! The food was excellent, large portions and reasonably priced. Very, very good!“

“Pizza was excellent, great crust and flavorful sauce 👍🏻“

“Amazing pizza, clean establishment and friendly staff. 5 ⭐“

“Took my toddler here on the way home from his 3rd birthday at Legoland. He’s very picky, so I wanted food I knew he would eat. Pepperoni pizza and buttered penne is always a win for him!

Very nice service. Did not treat me weird for bringing a small child to eat in their otherwise quiet establishment.

The food was nice and hot, and the chicken Caesar wrap was awesome. Would go back if in the area again.“

“Wonderful food and staff. Our favorite restaurant by far!!“

“excellent pizza and food always fresh. service is great staff is very friendly Marco the owner and kylee who takes the orders are great people“

“Rocco’s has terrific food and a great atmosphere. To top it all off, service is wonderful and they do so much to help the community. I highly recommend this family run, delicious restaurant!“

“incredible food, incredible staff. my best friend brought me here 9 years ago when I went home to visit. I came back to visit this week, ate here twice and brought rice balls home from vacation. awesome awesome awesome place!!! ♥️“

“Great food!!!! Big portions! Great atmosphere! You won’t be disappointed! 🍕“

“We ordered from Chef Tom & Napoli's for my 50th Birthday Party & the food was Absolutely Amazing! Everybody loved everything that there was barely any food left to take home. Chef Tom & his crew are professionals at their craft. When I have a party this is the only place I order from.“

“As soon as I walked in, the overwhelming aroma made me feel like I picked a good place to stop and get a slice. The hot honey pepperoni was actually amazing. Def try it. Owners are super nice and, even though they said it’s hard, are actually able to have 3 conversations at one time!“

“Stella Luna is the best it’s ever been. I’ve been going for 15 years to this Pizzaria. It has been renovated. It looks beautiful. The food is fantastic. New menu will delight. It is less expensive than almost all of the pizzerias in Rockland County …five stars.“

“Lugar seguro tranquilo, entretención para niños y adultos. Lo pasamos muy bien!!“

“Hands down one of the best pizzas you’ll find in the Rockland/Bergen County area. Always spot-on with flavor and consistency, with that perfectly crisp, golden undercarriage every slice lover dreams of. The quality easily competes with, if not surpasses, top-tier Manhattan joints—yet somehow at a way better price, even with the convenience of credit card payments. Tucked away in the Suffern/Mahwah area, this place is a true hidden gem. The prices are super fair, and every dollar feels well spent. Let’s be real—if someone’s dropping a one-star review here, it’s probably just jealousy talking.“

“The best pizza in town, as well as a friendly staff who always go out of their way for the customers“

“GREAT PIZZA, CAME BACK IN TOWN AND SAME OWNER STILL THERE, CUSTOMER SERVICE WAS GREAT AND EVERYONE STILL REMEBERED ME,“

“I've been coming here for about 20 years and came back here recently for a visit.
I think the crust of the pizza used to be better. With toppings, the pizza becomes soggy very easily and the crust is less crispy than I remember.
It's best if you order plain cheese or white pizza, so the base doesn't become soggy and the crust remains crispy.“

“Had a fabulous dining experience. The music was very quiet .. the food was outstanding.. the dessert n drinks topped it off! Extremely nice waiter! Very generous n kind. The ambience is so relaxing! Definitely a place we will come back to.“

“I will admit I have been slacking on my reviews since I went back-to-back on vacation three times. This local pizza place is a hidden gem that was introduced to us by my Aunt Deborah (Debbie) Langer, who always orders pizza here for my cousins. They have been ordering from here for well over five years. I figured I should give this place a chance since my aunt spoke highly of it. Surely enough, this pizza place did not disappoint. In fact, we have made it our favorite pizza place to enjoy as well. The owners and staff are remarkably generous! They seem to also get along so well with their regular customers that it is like their recurring customers become a part of their family. It is amazing to see this hospitality and kindness in a restaurant setting. I personally love the creativity of this restaurant and how every time I come there is a new type of pizza pie or new menu item. It is truly unique that they take ambition to be brave, creative, and test out new food items. Keep up the awesome work and looking forward to the next time I eat in or order out!“

“Best pizza and excellent customer service!!! Loved it! Margerhita’s pizza top of the line.“

“I recently stopped into Nicky’s Pizza & Deli in Montebello, NY, and wow—what a memorable visit from start to finish. The moment I walked in, the guys behind the counter greeted me like an old friend, practically welcoming me in with open arms.

I ordered their Parmesan pie and a BBQ chicken slice, while my friend went for a piping-hot Sicilian and a chicken-bacon slice. Every bite was fantastic—hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. The Parmesan pie had that perfect cheesy crisp, the BBQ chicken slice was savory and satisfying, the Sicilian arrived steaming and soft, and the chicken bacon slice was a hearty, flavorful one-two punch.

What truly stood out was their service—they made me feel like family, not just a customer. And props where they’re due: even the bathroom was clean and well-maintained, which is huge for a casual spot like this.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Montebello with fast, friendly service and a feel-good atmosphere, this place nails it. You really can’t ask for more. Highly recommended!“

“My daughter and son in-laws “go to” gem for gatherings and pizza nights is now one of my favorites too. We decided to skip the barbecue at my home and ordered assorted sandwiches, pizza cut into appetizer squares for the “little ones”, outrageous pasta and broccoli, garlic knots with sauce and a delicious salad. Delivery was prompt and everyone loved the entire meal. I will be back again.“

“BEST pizza & Italian dishes in Rockland, hands down! I have going there for over 25 years and NEVER had a disappointing meal. EVERYTHING is GREAT. Soups, pizza, appetizers and main dishes all prepared fresh. The sauce is the best I have tasted ANYWHERE. I have taken many friends there and never had a complaint! Laidback staff let you eat im peace but if you need anything they are right at your table.“

“this has gone up to my number one Pizzeria in Rockland County Nanuet.“

“Got invited to a #yelp event. I said pizza. I’m in. This place is kind of hidden but well worth it. Many pizza slices available. Soon as you walked in and smell the greatness you are going to have. The had sandwiches as well. I decided to get the Popeye slice (spinach & ricotta) and a prosciutto slice. Oh my goodness was amazing!! They had about 10 flavors of gelato to pick from as well. I got a scoop of the pistachio & a scoop of fruity pebbles. I was told by the owners daughter who was at register (very polite & friendly) they make them in house. I had to drive little of 30 min to get there. If you’re in the area stop by or if you like me take a ride. You won’t be sorry. There’s a fountain outside where you or the kids can cool off. Very clean inside. Well maintained inside as well. Thank you again… decided to buy extra to bring home as well. @yelpnorthjersey #yelpnorthjersey SQ Pizza @yelpnewjersey @sq_pizza_co“

“so far everything we have ordered has been fantastic! can't wait to try more!“

“Great place to eat after long day of Uni. And get 10%off if you are a RCC student. Highly recommend“

“I like the pizza, and I would probably choose it over most of the pizza in this area cuz it's closest to New York style slice. They consistently undercook the garlic on their garlic knots, so their garlic knots have this unfortunate, intense acidic taste of raw garlic to them“

“*Edit to the below review - the owner reached out to us after we left our review, and apologized for our experience. We did decide to give them another try, and we did get a good pizza this time. We appreciate the time he took to speak with us.

As a family of native New Yorkers, we'd like to think we all know good pizza here at our house. We've been all over for good pizza, but this place has always been our at home go-to place to order from. Our grandparents ordered here for years before we moved locally and started ordering ourselves about three years ago - at least 6 or 7 years of happy customers between both families. The last 4 or 5 times we've ordered here we've been pretty disappointed - but today we received the order that officially has gotten us to the point where we will no longer be ordering or picking up food here anymore. Tonight's dinner was officially a waste of money. The peppers and onions were raw on a 1/2 sausage peppers and onions 1/2 extra cheese pie. We asked for it to be cooked well done, which we have plenty of times before, and the pizza had to be cooked in our oven so that the dough could finish cooking. The whole thing was a big, sloppy mess when we opened the cover. This place used to be great quality food - every single time. I get that times are tough and things are expensive, and things can't always be perfect. There's been a serious decline going on though, and tonight was kinda the last straw for our family.“

“We have ordered from here many times and love the pizza. But this week, we needed to order a Gluten Free pie, which was not only delicious but came with its own pizza cutter, so there was no cross contamination! Well done, Peal River Pizzeria!! Thank you for that!
+“

“I’ve finally tried their white pie and I have to say it’s the The Best white pie I have EVER had. Finally a white pie that’s got the perfect amount of garlic! Worth Every Penny! And don’t forget to grab a Sweet&Salty’s cookie too!“

““Nicky’s 2 makes the best subs I’ve ever had, hands down. The bread was fresh, the ingredients were high quality, and everything was packed with flavor. The portions are generous, the service is friendly, and you can really taste the difference compared to other sub shops. Absolutely unbeatable!”“

“From the folks at lites plus, we love you guys and this place! Consistently good pizza and always cooked the way we like it. It’s one of the best pizza places in Rockland county. Aside from their pizza all of their food is good here. They are also the most affordable.“

“delicious pizza and sandwiches!! Excellent staff !!“

“We had a terrible experience at aspire brewing this evening and cosimos accepted our family of five right at closing and took care of us in a way that put everything that had been wrong, right. They were welcoming and understanding even though we felt terrible to walk in 40 mins before closing with so many of us. They were maxing. The food was amazing. The service and atmosphere were exactly what we needed after the terrible previous experience! Thank you!“

“Best pizza and the tortellini is so good too and the garlic bread with cheese! If you’re in the area go there! Never had any problems with them!! And fast quick delivery!“