50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Monsey

“I went here yesterday with my son after his evaluation next door. The pizza is SO GOOD. Closest thing I ever had to NYC pizza…kosher ingredients definitely make a difference. I wish I lived close to this place because I want another pizza from there today. Absolutely delicious. Next time I’m in the area, I’m definitely stopping by. Also, staff was very nice and accommodating.“

“I stopped into Seasons Express in Monsey and really enjoyed it. It’s a great kosher specialty store with coffee, ice cream, pizza, meat products, and plenty of snacks. Everything felt fresh, convenient, and well stocked.

I will definitely recommend for a quick stop shopping experience.“

“Wow, wow wow this place was amazing. Everything was delicious from food to the drink drinks and great customer service.
The pizza was good and fluffy
Fries was crispy and salty
The pasta was out of this world
And don’t get started about those cauliflower bites every lick was heaven“

“Al Di La Pizzeria & Bistro is what happens when a pizza place decides it’s not just here to serve slices — it’s here to make a whole statement.

You walk in thinking, “Okay, pizza,” and then suddenly the menu starts talking to you like it went to culinary yeshiva. Personal pies, specialty options, salad pizzas — next thing you know you’re standing there like, “Nu… what exactly is my mahalach here?”

The pizza itself? Very solid. Nice crust, good balance, not drowning in sauce like it’s trying to prove a point. You can tell there’s some thought behind it — not your basic grab-and-run slice situation.

And then there’s the presentation. Things come out looking put together, like someone cared. Even the salad pizza somehow feels like it’s dressed better than most people at a weekday lunch.

The vibe is a bit more on the “sit down and enjoy” side. Not heavy or fancy, just a step up from your typical pizza shop. Good place to slow down for a few minutes instead of inhaling a slice while running to your next errand.

Also, be ready — you might walk in planning one pie and walk out having tried three different things because everything sounds interesting. It happens. No one is judging.

Bottom line:
A creative, well-executed pizza spot that brings a little cheshbon into your ordering decisions — in a good way. Come hungry, come curious, and don’t be surprised if you leave feeling like you made a whole dining experience out of “just pizza.”“

“Since discovering Wonder, I have never had a fair or bad food experience. My orders have been delicious and delivery was always on time or early. I will eventually try each menu item but until then I recommend the Sushi plates and Big Belly chicken menus. The Pizza was also 100 percent.“

“With all the competition Johnny's faces in Mahwah, Ramsey, Allendale, and Suffern they have clearly shown from opening day to the present why they are the top choice. Every aspect of a business a customer would want they excel (product, cleanliness, customer service, and menu options). Besides a superlative slice of pizza their Sicilian is larger than others without being burnt on top (commonly found elsewhere), and their version of the Deep Dish slice is tremendous. If you want to dine in, take out, or not leave the comfort of your home and have the food delivered, they are the Must Go To spot in the area.“

“Perfect crust. Perfect pie. Sauce just right!“

“Love Rocks Kitchen- good and healthy food! Smoothies are out of this world!!“

“Food was great, only thing I would mention is regarding delivery. We requested it be left at the door cause we were running late from daycare. We don’t think that note made it to the delivery driver. Food was great, delivered on time, maybe a little early.“

“Came in for Friday evening take out. Love watching a glimpse of the cooking in the back and appreciate the zeppoli treats. Not just pizza it is authentic Italian cuisine. Never a bad meal.“

“This place is like no other. Lovely owners and the most delicious authentic Italian food. Wow!“

“Delicious food“

“Got invited to a #yelp event. I said pizza. I’m in. This place is kind of hidden but well worth it. Many pizza slices available. Soon as you walked in and smell the greatness you are going to have. The had sandwiches as well. I decided to get the Popeye slice (spinach & ricotta) and a prosciutto slice. Oh my goodness was amazing!! They had about 10 flavors of gelato to pick from as well. I got a scoop of the pistachio & a scoop of fruity pebbles. I was told by the owners daughter who was at register (very polite & friendly) they make them in house. I had to drive little of 30 min to get there. If you’re in the area stop by or if you like me take a ride. You won’t be sorry. There’s a fountain outside where you or the kids can cool off. Very clean inside. Well maintained inside as well. Thank you again… decided to buy extra to bring home as well. @yelpnorthjersey #yelpnorthjersey SQ Pizza @yelpnewjersey @sq_pizza_co“

“We recently discovered this amazing pizza and baked goods spot while dining at its sister restaurant, Al Dente Pasta Co., next door. Luciano's is now my favorite pizza spot in the area! Their dough is amazing and it really stands out in the white pizza with sausage and their simply amazing garlic knots (served with lots of fresh garlic and high quality olive oil). We are hooked! The staff go above and beyond (they treated us to a fabulous homemade chocolate chip cookie on a recent order). Their catering menu looks wonderful. You can tell a lot of thought and care has been put into this business! Check them out and Al Dente too!!“

“Absolute gassssssssss Keep killing it“

“Besides that the food is delicious and gets prepped very fast!!
the workers are soo kind! My baby made a huge mess and before I got a chance to clean it up they reassured me that they’ll clean it up and I shouldn’t worry about it! 🥹🥹“

“Great pizza, great service loved dinner !!“

“***** The best Caesar salad.“

“Friendly staff, great food! Cool location but should be more centrally located. Too good to be kept a secret :)“

“Love their chicken wings Always order two trays for family gatherings Everyone loves them and says they are the BEST Peggy“

“We love Spinachio! We came here before Dave portnoy reviewed them and I thought I rated them but I forgot! Anyways I always eat the food before and today finally snapped a pic! We love their food and not just pizza! Their soups are amazing and super flavorful. I’ve had the chicken noodle and straticella. The pizzas are always amazing. Fresh ingredients and delicious full of flavor. I haven’t tried a slice that I didn’t like. Today we got the vodka rigitini and omh it was so different but amazing. Creamy and cheesy. The regular pie we got well done so a bit more crispy. The fries were cajón and super good a bit soggy but very good. The time of the fries wasn’t cut out like the rest of the tins. They do that so it doesn’t get soggy. I love how they do that. The mozzy sticks are so good too cheesy and crispy! Owners are super friendly and recognize me and my husbands family. We probably come here maybe every 2 weeks when we are in the area. Highly recommend!!! And will always come back!“

“Great food, great service, very welcoming!“

“Excellent! Food was so fresh and fabulous and so was the service. Pizza crust was delicious and light. Everyone was so very nice and accommodating. Great atmosphere and concept of Pizza by the foot. So good that weekends are packed, so make a reservation or try a weeknight. You will not be disappointed!“

“Great food & excellent service.“

“Pizza was excellent, great crust and flavorful sauce 👍🏻“

“Great food!!!! Big portions! Great atmosphere! You won’t be disappointed! 🍕“

“Martio's is my go-to pizza spot. Whenever we have family visiting, it’s a must-stop so they can experience some truly fantastic pizza. The dough is perfect, with just the right amount of crust. The sauce hits all the right notes, and the pizza is loaded with cheesy goodness. If I had to choose between Martio's and any other pizza in the world, I’d choose Martio's without hesitation.

Beyond the pizza, the Italian combo sandwich is delicious, and the pasta fagioli soup, garlic bread, antipasto, and gelato are all standout dishes. 10/10, will always recommend.“

“This place really does an outstanding job with both the food and customer service. We ordered catering twice from here and both times, everything was amazing. The place is very clean, plenty of helpful staff, and the menu has a good number of things to choose from. I used to work in NYC so it takes a lot for me to like a deli (I was so spoiled with the options) and this place meets that level. Cozy Italian diner vibes that bring back memories. Try this place out! You won't be disappointed!“

“Lugar seguro tranquilo, entretención para niños y adultos. Lo pasamos muy bien!!“

“excellent pizza and food always fresh. service is great staff is very friendly Marco the owner and kylee who takes the orders are great people“

“My absolute favorite. Pizza is the best in the area. Staff is super friendly. Everything you want from a small business! Definitely my go to.“

“Absolutely loved the pizza here. Everything tasted incredibly fresh from the dough to the cheese and sauce. The crust was perfectly baked, light and airy on the inside with just the right crisp on the outside. The sauce had a great balance of flavor, not too heavy, and the cheese melted beautifully without feeling greasy.

You can really tell they use quality ingredients and take pride in what they make. Every bite felt fresh and well put together. The staff did an amazing job, and the overall experience was smooth and enjoyable.

Definitely one of the better pizzas I’ve had in a while. I’ll 100% be coming back and recommending this place to others.“

“All a great experience, awesome service, and the food…FUHGEDDABOUTDIT!!“

“Yesterday 1st time had the ribs to die for .loved it all except the mac and cheese was a little to dry and wasnt a fan of the shell macaroni.but i did see a pizza pie go by and man it looks real good.im coming back my family and turn them on.“

“The best“

“incredible food, incredible staff. my best friend brought me here 9 years ago when I went home to visit. I came back to visit this week, ate here twice and brought rice balls home from vacation. awesome awesome awesome place!!! ♥️“

“My niece took me, along with her daughter (my grand niece) and her son (my grand nephew) , to The Mountain House this evening. While they had been there before, it was my first time eating there. The kids had their favorite, a white pizza pie, my niece had the Greek Salad with grilled chicken and I had the Chicken Bolognese and 2 glasses of Chardonnay. The Bolognese was DELICIOUS AND more than enough for one person! The Chardonnay was pretty good as well!“

“The square pizza is the best, i'm in there 2-3 times a week for 1 and if they run out before i get there then i get a whole square pie, we love the pasta Abruzzese and just had a pie of eggplant with fresh muzz. also great, i'm org. from Brooklyn were every corner has great pizza, i will put Mangia square pizza up against any i'v had in Brooklyn, and the owners are tops.“

“The best food and family in the world 🌎“

“I come to Stella Luna Pizza at least three times a week, and there’s a reason for that. The vibe here is unmatched. The owner and his old man together are the perfect combination—real people, real hospitality, and it feels like home every time you walk in.

This is exactly why I’ll never choose a franchise over a place like this. You can feel the care, the consistency, and the pride they put into what they do. For the locals, this is the spot. If you want good pizza, good energy, and people who actually remember you, this is the place to be.

Wouldn’t change it for anything.“

“Amazing pizza, clean establishment and friendly staff. 5 ⭐“

“I recently stopped into Nicky’s Pizza & Deli in Montebello, NY, and wow—what a memorable visit from start to finish. The moment I walked in, the guys behind the counter greeted me like an old friend, practically welcoming me in with open arms.

I ordered their Parmesan pie and a BBQ chicken slice, while my friend went for a piping-hot Sicilian and a chicken-bacon slice. Every bite was fantastic—hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. The Parmesan pie had that perfect cheesy crisp, the BBQ chicken slice was savory and satisfying, the Sicilian arrived steaming and soft, and the chicken bacon slice was a hearty, flavorful one-two punch.

What truly stood out was their service—they made me feel like family, not just a customer. And props where they’re due: even the bathroom was clean and well-maintained, which is huge for a casual spot like this.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Montebello with fast, friendly service and a feel-good atmosphere, this place nails it. You really can’t ask for more. Highly recommended!“

“Hands down one of the best pizzas you’ll find in the Rockland/Bergen County area. Always spot-on with flavor and consistency, with that perfectly crisp, golden undercarriage every slice lover dreams of. The quality easily competes with, if not surpasses, top-tier Manhattan joints—yet somehow at a way better price, even with the convenience of credit card payments. Tucked away in the Suffern/Mahwah area, this place is a true hidden gem. The prices are super fair, and every dollar feels well spent. Let’s be real—if someone’s dropping a one-star review here, it’s probably just jealousy talking.“

“Marvin goes out of his way to make his customers happy. recently ordered a veggie pie (no mushrooms) with half dairy cheese and half vegan cheese. It even came with a little crust demarcation down the middle. Perfect!“

“Absolutely the best neighborhood pizza spot around! Every time I come in, I’m welcomed like family by Nick, Christina, Leo, and Tina—they truly make the experience special. The pizza is always fresh, perfectly cooked, and packed with flavor. You can tell they take pride in what they do. The atmosphere is warm, friendly, and inviting, making it the kind of place you want to keep coming back to. Whether it’s a quick slice or a full meal, they never disappoint. Highly recommend to anyone looking for amazing pizza and outstanding service!“

“Tried this pizza for the first time yesterday via pickup with my family, and it was so delicious that we went back to the shop to eat in again today. I’m actually not a big fan of pizza, but this place is incredible. Hands down the best pizza I've ever had! The staff are friendly and the atmosphere is great. My favorite was the Margherita. If you’re looking for a pizza that’s perfectly seasoned (not too salty) with high-quality, gourmet dough, you must visit this place.

Pro tip here: If you have leftovers (It tastes even better if you’ve kept it in the fridge or freezer beforehand), put them in a pan over low heat with the lid on. Heat it until the cheese feels warm and soft to the touch. I'm eating it right now, and it's shockingly delicious. The crispy texture is insane.“

“The best pizza in town, as well as a friendly staff who always go out of their way for the customers“

“Held a celebration of life for my father here last night. The staff and management were so accommodating and helpful both last night and in the planning. Had about 50 people in attendances and the service was everything we could have asked, not to mention amazing food!“

“Everything was amazing !“

“Great waitstaff and management! We’ve driven past here so many times and Stern & Bow is always packed! Food is 6+ stars!“