8 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Hyde Park

“My wife and I have ordered from Previti for several years now thru Door Dash. the food has always been excellent. The other day I had a call from Previti. It was the owner, Joe. He told me that my mother had wandered in after having her car bumper come completely loose on Marcus Ave. She had no phone, and was shaken up by the whole ordeal. Joe called me for her, and gave her a cup of hot tea. I went over, picked her up and got her home. Later my wife and I returned to pick up her car. We decided to eat dinner there and take advantage of the pasta night specials. The lasagna and the rigatoni with meat sauce were both excellent. Thank you Joe and staff for taking good care of my mother, and providing us with an excellent meal! All the best!“

“THIS is the place to cater your next affair ! Don’t hesitate, book it now ! My wife and I recently experienced the joy of hosting my son and daughter-in-law’s wedding rehearsal dinner for seventy family members and out-of-town friends. We have been regular customers at Umberto’s Pizzeria for years, next door to the restaurant, getting our weekly Sunday or Monday night pizza pie. Nevertheless, we had never previously ventured into their restaurant next door. What a pleasant surprise ! What a smart decision to book the party here at the renowned Umberto’s of New Hyde Park. The second floor of the restaurant opens up into a spacious, light-filled, warm and welcoming room, big enough to feel like a proper celebration event space. There was plenty of room for our family and friends to mingle and even plenty of space for the several toddlers in attendance to sit and play, and run around. They enjoyed the party as much as anyone ! The catering menu provided a wide variety of choices from appetizers, salads, pastas and main courses from which our son and daughter-in-law selected from to satisfy the preferences of all of our guests. The food was delicious, as we’ve come to expect. Also, thank goodness each table received a Grandma’s Pizza. An affair at Umberto’s isn’t complete without a taste of the Grandma Pizza. The wait staff couldn’t have been any more attentive and solicitous. They were sensational. It’s obvious what a well managed team this is, kudos to Katy and Gaetano. Thank you Umberto’s for making this a most memorable affair. One minor note - The menu, to our surprise, doesn’t include dessert. What’s an Italian meal without a tiramasu, cannoli, or napoleon ? Thus, we brought our own which was fine but less satisfying than an Italian pastry to top off the night. - Bruce & Melanie Miller“

“AMAZING!! Could very well be the BEST tasting pizza in Long Island. The staff is great, place is clean and the pizza is TOP of the TOP!“

“I been going to Eddie's since I was a little boy... no joke! My parents use to own a shop nearby and it was great, don't let this place fool you, looks like some typical pizza joint - nah, this place has some amazing history and is a bar pie place and has some amazing food. The chicken dishes are amazing, you can get cherry peppers on your bar pie which make it very amazing. Every waiter and waitress here is super nice and kind. They have a jukebox, this place feels like a gangster hangout and it is amazing. Awesome old movie posters on the walls, this place is great! It is very nostalgic for me at 25 years old but this place also rubs my heart that this is what old NY was like, this place gives off that vibe of a NY very long gone... We can cheerish and enjoy it here.

The food is great, the vibe is great, everyone is great. I am unsure if the man with grey hair works here still but he was amazing also such a funny kind guy. TRY THIS PLACE! Have a coors and relax and feel like you're one of the gangsters who would import it illegally to the East Coast back in the day :)“

“Umbertos with a calmer vibe... some of my friends argue that the pizza is better at Angolletos . Personally, LOVE them both Equally. Specifically the Sicillian. Over all a GREAT pizzeria especially if you like a quieter more intimate eating experience... and GREAT pizza or plate of food. On a scale of 1-10 i give it a 10. If i was in the band Spinal Tap. Id give it an 11😎😁...... 🍕🍕🍕🤤👍🏽👍🏽“

“I dont normally do reviews but I felt the need to tell whoever is looking for pizza in the area look no further... the pizza is incredibly good very good sauce flavor... perfect crispness... 👌 ive ate at every great pizza spots In NYC these guys a a sleeper !!!“

“The best pizza and shrimp parmigiana anywhere! Outstanding!“

“Hands down The best Brick oven pizza I ever tasted!!! Ultra thin Crispy crust with fresh mozzarella and their very own amazing sauce with a hint of their secret ingredient.“