Polito Bakery

$ • Bakery, Custom Cakes, Cupcakes

Hours today·

About Polito Bakery

Polito Bakery is a long-standing establishment that has maintained its quality of bread and pastries over the years. The bakery offers a good selection of items at great prices, and the staff is welcoming, helpful, and professional. Favorites among regulars include saviardi cookies, apple pie, and cannoli. The bakery is noted for its tasty pastries, offering some suitable choices for those with dietary restrictions. While some may find the prices higher than expected, the service is generally fast, and the fresh-baked scents create an inviting atmosphere. The bakery also produces special celebration items, such as wedding cakes that are beautiful, moist, and delicious with amazing frosting and fresh strawberry filling. Other standout items include Sfogliatella, giant apple horns, brownies, black and white cookies, elephant ears, and biscotti. The cheese cake is often cited as the best. The intimate atmosphere makes it a pleasant experience for customers, and the bakery is easily considered the best pastries in the area. Ample parking is available in the front and rear of the store, although the small size of the bakery can make it crowded.

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Polito Bakery
Polito Bakery
View All Photos

Polito Bakery Reviews

3.8
96 ratings
5
64%
4
4%
3
8%
2
12%
1
12%
Food
4.1
Atmosphere
4.1
Service
4.6

Share your opinion about Polito Bakery

John at Polito’s Bakery in Williston Park made my daughter’s wedding cake, and it was absolutely beautiful and delicious! The cake was moist, the frosting was amazing, and the fresh strawberry filling was the perfect touch. Everyone loved it and couldn’t stop talking about how wonderful it tasted. John did an incredible job and helped make the celebration even more special. We highly recommend Polito’s Bakery!
I used to live in Kew Gardens and would drive to Polito's just for their nut cake. I still remember how delicious everything tasted, and really miss going there.
I wish they had mail order!
Such amazing pastry, breads and cakes. Great service and kind and welcoming staff.

Read All Reviews(91)

Hours

Monday 7AM - 4PM
Tuesday 7AM - 4PM
Wednesday 7AM - 4PM
Thursday 7AM - 6PM
Friday 7AM - 6PM
Saturday 7AM - 6PM
Sunday 7AM - 5PM
Updated on: