Ice Cream Shops near New Paltz

“This place has an old-timey feel to it which I love. Prices are fair. Service is too. Selection for ice cream is pretty good. They will have at least one flavour that is non-dairy. I got a hot fudge sundae with cookie dough ice cream.
Seating is limited to a couple of seats towards the entrance.
They accept both cash and card.

Parking: There is parking on Plattekill Ave. Before 6 pm you have to pay. After it's free

Wheelchair accessibility: There is none. You have to use the stairs.“

“My wife and I were visiting the area and just assumed the Udder choice was a place to go get ice cream. Turns out they do have delicious ice cream, but a whole lot more. It is a full restaurant serving breakfast and lunch all day long and clearly a local favorite! We did enjoy their ice cream, but had we more time in the area, we would have certainly had a meal there.“

“I really enjoy the bubble tea here! The ice cream is good too, but I go for the bubble tea. There are plenty of options.This place just opened up so it is still being decorated, but give it a shot as the family that runs it is very kind and helpful.“

“They always have new and interesting flavors. I took my son. I have accepted that I can't have anything with dairy and these are rare treats for him. They had a few non-dairy sorbet options. I think I got pineapple, added some shredded coconut, and it was absolutely DELISH!“

“I was out today riding my motorcycle over the mountain and stopped in for a twist cone. Your chocolate and vanilla ice cream is so rich in flavor. I remember if correctly it was called Juergen's Place back in the 1960's.“

“This is far my best market place to go to. So many memories of coming here when my son was three years old; he’s now 35! Along with my sister and brother-in-law Linda and Doug!!!! And the pumpkin ice cream and apple cider donuts…the best! Thank you to the Tantillo family! ❤️“