29 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Paltz

“I love this restaurant, it’s definitely one of my all time favorites. It has amazing flatbread pizza with all the gourmet toppings you can think AND they have a few dinner specials that are absolutely delicious. Lastly, everything is fresh, tasty and not overly priced. If you haven’t been here you are missing out.“

“I go to Rino's for the amazing customer service - I go back to Rino's for the delicious food. While you're waitingon the0tk0p, check out the little Italian grocery section full of imported oils and vinegar and traditional ils school pasta shapes like orecchiette.“

“Beautiful grounds, food and wine were amazing. Highly recommend, best of all, the staff were all super nice. Can’t wait to go back.“

“I have celiacs disease so I asked if they had a gf pizza, they were so helpful and the pizza was AMAZING!!!

Kid-friendliness: super nice and friendly towards everyone

Dietary restrictions: They were very careful about not cross contaminating my gluten free pizza!“

“I absolutely love it here!! The food is so good it’s almost impossible to find something you don’t like. There is a very kind lady that works at the counter and is always fun to talk to. I will definitely be going here more often. 100% will be recommending this place to all my friends and family.“

“If I could rate food 10 stars I would. The soups, service, and especially the grilled salmon with vegetables were all 🤩. The atmosphere was average, this isn't a super fancy restaurant so it was expected. The menu was massive with pasta, pizza, veal, steak, seafood, heroes, salads, soups, an assortment of appetizers, an impressive kids menu, and all the other stuff a fancy Italian place would have. I also thought the price was decent for your average meal but the food was so good they could have changed more and still got me to come back.

Vegetarian options: There were plenty of vegetarian dishes but half the menu was neat based.

Kid-friendliness: Faint kids menu, pizza pasta and they can get you vegetables on the side.

Wheelchair accessibility: Everything was wheelchair accessible.“

“Maria and her team are fantastic - amazing - wonderful. She is a consummate professional, easy to communicate with, and provides the most delicious, satisfying food and impeccable service. She helped pull together a custom dinner for 80+ starving rock climbers without skipping a beat. She predicted our hungry behavior better than I could!! Everyone raved about the food (pasta, salad, main dishes, gluten free pasta, cookies = delish!), and we can't wait to come back to New Paltz and work with her again in the future. THANK YOU AGAIN, MARIA! YOU ARE A ROCKSTAR!“

“Great place to spend an afternoon with friends and pups! We thought the pizza was delicious and loved having the flights of cider. There’s a nice shaded pavilion where the dogs can hang too. Also a beautiful pond where we saw geese and a turtle! Would definitely recommend this place!“

“Nice staff, good prices, solid Pizza. Next time I’ll have to try some kitchen food! Pizza is excellent. Almost went back for seconds lol“

“We are from California and got in late and hungry. Ordered a marghertti pizza, Hawaiian regular and gluten free. Everything was delicious. They kept doors open after they closed to fix a pizza order for us. Great customer service.
Everything was so good we ate there again the last night of our vacation.“

“What a great local spot. This is a solid pie with some pretty delicious crust. They consistently deliver quality pizza with quality ingredients and sauce. It’s a family-owned business and you can tell there’s a lot of kindness there, between the proprietors and the staff. Super reliable, super delicious.“

“Expensive but good food….“

“This place makes me feel like it's nineteen seventy

It's a very basic old-fashioned pizzeria. Nothing fancy good pizza nice people

I got a slice of spinach pizza, a slice of mushroom

Prices are great“

“Regular at Pizza Mia, my favorite slot for a slice on a lunch break in Newburgh. Location is convenient and near places to shop. The creative slices are filling, tasty, and the people here care about their end product. Their service is always above and beyond. 100% recommend stopping in and trying a unique slice that catches your eye. You won’t be disappointed!“

“the food is great there i tried some of the baked ziti and the wings and my family ordered from there half a tray of seafood too of everything it was to die for even thou i cant eat shrimp and lobster“

“Hands down best pizza in area, I’ve move out of area in 2022. Come back to visit family in Newburgh still go to my favorite pizza place in town. Pizza and wings were amazing yesterday thank you ❤️🍕.“

“We had the buffalo chicken pizza, ham and pepperoni roll, and the ravioli dinner (yum, with mozzarella cheese and sauce on top). All were excellent. We did a pick-up order, and noticed when we got home that the salad was missing that went with the ravioli dinner. We called, and what seemed like only moments after I put down the phone, the doorbell rang with the salad and bread and apologies delivered -- great service!“

“from the I r dinners to pizza ALWAYS VERY GOOD FOOD!!!!! PORTIOB SIZE,SERVICE & FOOD VERY GOOD!!!“

“The best pizza and garlic knots I've ever had! Huge slices, tons of toppings, the perfect crust and spectacular flavor! I live in another state and make sure to stop into Benny's every time I visit home again. I recommend this place to everyone, it's the absolute top of the list when it comes to real NY pizza. 10/10 must try!“

“We had never heard of Paesanos until we moved to Modena. We were happy to find out that the pizza is great, garlic knots are the best, extra crispy wings are amazing and the subs are delicious. Also prices are very reasonable. Only complaint is that they only deliver for cash.“

“First time for Father’s Day… won’t be our last! Everything was delicious! 😋 The Filet & braised short ribs cut like butter and our server, Sierra was friendly and incredibly attentive. We are looking forward to our next visit!“

“Perfectly good pizza. My local pizza place. They sometimes send out mailers with coupons to make it more affordable. I am a little spooked that Google just asked me for this review because they noticed I call this place one week ago! I guess I will store the number and dial rather than hit the number provided in a Google search, now that I know they are capturing that particular bit of info. Hello big brother!!!“

“Wonderful“

“Everything is exceptional but the brisket might be the best i've had anywhere in the US with the gravy. Plus the people are geniune and friendly.“

“They have GIANT pizzas every night which are awesome and large pizza every Tuesday only $10.99, you can’t cook for much less and in the summer no one wants to they always say 20 minutes but they have it ready in less than half the time Definitely going through the summer every week, after we go back to giant pizzas but they are so big we ask them to double cut“

“I grew up in NYC and during my teenage years in the 60's discovered middle eastern cuisine. It was the choice for "fast & delicious meals" Now my discovery in Rosendale has presented me the delicious opportunity to learn the exceptional cuisine offered at The Garden House. everything I've eaten is mouth watering wonderful. The community of welcomeness is abundant each time you visit. Enjoy a 5 star meal.“

“Ordered a large tray of Chicken Francese and it was AMAZING. Flavorful and tender even after reheating. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“