Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West, New York

Name: Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West, New York
Address: 200 W 60th St, New York, New York, 10023, US
Telephone: (929) 989-3669
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.1

$$ • Pizza, Burgers

Hours:
200 W 60th St, New York
(929) 989-3669

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West, New York

Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West is a popular neighborhood spot known for its exceptional Detroit-style pizzas, including the Colony, Margherita, and Vodka varieties. The garlic bread is a must-try, and the staff is friendly and accommodating, ensuring a great experience. While the restaurant has a beautiful dark minimalist interior, some guests have noted that the acoustics can be quite loud, especially during busy times. The restaurant is a great option for events and big groups, with helpful staff and timely delivery. Despite some concerns about the knowledge of the menu among servers, the food, particularly the pizza, has received high praise. With clean restrooms and moderately priced drinks, Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West is a highly recommended spot for a delicious meal, especially for those looking for a great lunchtime experience.

The service at this location was great, with the server Kelly providing excellent attention. The Detroit-style pizza was good, with the MVP pizza featuring a combination of vodka sauce, red sauce, and pesto. While the Le Big Matt burger was not as impressive, with the patties lacking flavor and being a bit dry, the overall dining experience was positive, with the staff being lovely and the sprout salad receiving high praise. Customers who have visited the Birmingham, AL location have also raved about the Margherita pizza, calling it fantastic and a new favorite.