Gelateria Gentile

$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
75 University Pl, New York
(917) 409-5979

About Gelateria Gentile

Gelateria Gentile is a cozy, faux rustic ice cream shop on University Pl, offering a variety of gelatos and sorbets made in Italy. They have 10 gelato flavors, along with pastries, brioche, cakes, and drinks. The gelatos are creamy and flavorful, with options like mandorla di toritto and stracciatella. The baked goods, including croissants and cornetto, are flown in daily from Bari and are well-loved. Friendly service and a few counter stools make it a great spot to enjoy ice cream and people watch in Washington Square Park.

Customers' Favorites

Gelateria Gentile Reviews

4.5
90 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
72%
4
14%
3
6%
2
5%
1
3%
Food
4.5
Atmosphere
4.6
Service
4.4

Share your opinion about Gelateria Gentile

Restaurantji Rating

Very good gelato. Definitely one of the best, if not the best, in NYC! Highly recommended and very well organized to serve while social distancing!

Not gonna lie, this was the saddest gelato experience. Lol. I got a cone and the counter server scraped an itty bit of gelato and it barely covered the top. When I brought attention to how skimpy the serving was (you could see through to the bottom of the cone), the obviously agitated server quickly asked me if I wanted to THROW IT AWAY OR TALK TO A MANAGER. Um...no? I payed the 8 dollars for the hollowed cone and slinked away. Neither the gelato nor the experience was worth it....read full review

Best ice cream I’ve had in Brooklyn

Read All Reviews(90)

Menu

Add a Menu
Gelateria Gentile Menu
Gelateria Gentile Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Gelateria Gentile
Gelateria Gentile
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 8AM - 12AM
Tuesday 8AM - 12AM
Wednesday 8AM - 12AM
Thursday 8AM - 12AM
Friday 8AM - 12AM
Saturday 9AM - 12AM
Sunday 9AM - 12AM
Updated on: