Gelatoville Gelateria

$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
163 1st Ave. unit 1, New York
(201) 913-9393

Customers' Favorites

Gelatoville Gelateria Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.7 (152)
Restaurantji Rating

Not only is the Gelato the BEST I’ve had in NYC, the Staff is SO sweet! Mujo and Shoshanna interacted with all of the customers with so much compassion! They both were incredibly thoughtful. I could tell they wanted each one of their guests to leave satisfied and happy! Will be returning MANY times- can’t wait to get the Cookie Crumble in my next cup!

Restaurantji Rating

I was just passing by minding my own business ? when I saw Gelato staring at me! Im pretty sure it was calling me as well..I had no choice but to respond. When I came on the staff was really helpful and patient cause it was really hard to choose a flavor... eventually I did the cheesecake amazing ?? and you can combine flavors ?.. I will definitely be back and if you like to taste things you will too!!

Restaurantji Rating

Lovely gelato! Owner notes in the reviews that everything is imported from Italy and there's a sister store in Florence. Loved the outdoor seating and kind staff. The white chocolate pistachio was sweet creamy and flavorful! I did sample the signature one with the orange and biscuit and would come back for it! Also gelato is typically healthier than ice cream (because ice cream may have higher fat content from egg yolk and cream). We need more gelato spots!! Would also love a...read full review

More Reviews(152)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 8AM - 11PM
Tuesday 8AM - 11PM
Wednesday 8AM - 11PM
Thursday 8AM - 11:30PM
Friday 8AM - 11:30PM
Saturday 8AM - 11:30PM
Sunday 9AM - 11PM
Updated on: