Gelotti NYC - PERMANENTLY CLOSED

2486 Broadway, New York

Ratings

Reviews for Gelotti NYC

I don't know where to begin... We wanted to treat our son for some gelato ice cream. While the girl that was working the front was sweet and helpful, the ice cream was a disaster. The first cup we got was a strawberry flavor and my son wanted chocolate sprinkles on it, but once we got it we saw a LONG HAIR on the top of the cup where the sprinkles were (prob the hair came from the chocolate sprinkles, which looked like they have been sitting in that container for a long time),...read full review

Great addition to the neighborhood. Cute place with nice staff and amazing ice cream. My favorite is the Coffee Monster. The coffee ice cream base was outstanding and then they mix in choc chips and Oreos- so good. Uws folks please check this place out. It is worth it and we need to help businesses along Broadway have success. Still love this place. Java Chip Is amazing.

We traveled from California to New York this past summer, and stopped by this place to satisfy my daughters' craving for ice cream. We were pleasantly surprised by the warm welcome received from the staff. In addition, the service was excellent and the ice cream was just delicious, very generous in flavor and quality ingredients. I would definitely recommend this place !

More Reviews(34)

Gelotti NYC - PERMANENTLY CLOSED

2486 Broadway, New York, NY 10025
Suggest an Edit