Lexington Candy Shop

$ • Diners, American, Burgers

Menu Order Online

About Lexington Candy Shop

The Lexington Candy Shop is a historic restaurant known for its old-fashioned and handcrafted sodas. The menu features classic New York breakfast options, although some may find the prices quite high. The service is generally fair, and the atmosphere offers a sense of stepping back in time, often described as a "time capsule." The handmade sodas and egg creams are a highlight, with many customers praising their nostalgic and delicious flavors. The establishment uses historical equipment to make all the soda fountain classics, adding to its charm. The neighborhood setting is less busy than midtown, making it a nice spot for a relaxed visit. Visitors have enjoyed the fun atmosphere and the chance to experience a place that has been a part of New York’s tradition since the 1920s. While some find the food and drinks a bit underwhelming and the service not particularly good, the experience of visiting this iconic spot remains special. The pancakes, in particular, are considered the best part of the meal, though they can be found elsewhere. The original charm of the diner, with its vintage look, continues to attract those looking for an authentic and nostalgic dining experience.