Made In New York Pizza
CLOSED$ •
About Made In New York Pizza
Made In New York Pizza Reviews
53 ratings
I ordered a regular slice and a pepperoni slice. The crust was soggy and the the sauce was horrible. Nothing positive to say about this spot. Too many better options around to waste your time here.
A NO GUILT TRIP
The sausage, pepperoni pizza was a bit of a disappointment. It had such a pale color and appeared raw. On a more positive note, the peppers and mushroom was a hit with my partner, and the crust was absolutely delicious! Coming back for another evening bite! Hot without taking the roof of the mouth, off!
The sausage, pepperoni pizza was a bit of a disappointment. It had such a pale color and appeared raw. On a more positive note, the peppers and mushroom was a hit with my partner, and the crust was absolutely delicious! Coming back for another evening bite! Hot without taking the roof of the mouth, off!
Update April 2026:
⬆ consistency. Bigger slices. Great chew & crust.
⬇ no wings. No beef Patties. Seating. Service is indifferent.
📝 2nd best spot in the neighborhood
✅ it’s on the remix
March 2025:
Within 6 months, the pizza scene from 92 to 106 on Broadway has hit an all time high of quality options. If you’ve lived within this border long enough, you know how average to poor it used to be.
All...read full review
⬆ consistency. Bigger slices. Great chew & crust.
⬇ no wings. No beef Patties. Seating. Service is indifferent.
📝 2nd best spot in the neighborhood
✅ it’s on the remix
March 2025:
Within 6 months, the pizza scene from 92 to 106 on Broadway has hit an all time high of quality options. If you’ve lived within this border long enough, you know how average to poor it used to be.
All...read full review
Made In New York Pizza is a clean, late-open spot with a variety of options. The pizza has light, delicious sauce and offers slices starting at $5. Many customers find the pizza to be top-quality, with some noting the crust can be made crunchier upon request. However, prices for some slices, like the $7 slice with barely any pepperoni, can be disappointing. Overall, it's a popular, affordable choice for a quick, tasty meal.