Old Fashion Pizzeria
CLOSED$ •
About Old Fashion Pizzeria
Old Fashion Pizzeria Reviews
92 ratings
Jimmy - I just walked by and saw the windows all boarded up. I can’t believe you retired without telling me! Thank you for all of the delicious slices over the years, especially the Hawaiians with olives (even if I had to go buy the ham sometimes). You are truly a legend and one of my favorite parts of this city. I hope you have a great retirement my friend.
What an incredible neighborhood pizza spot. It’s truly humbling to catch the owner passionately serving up pies and great subs.
He’s such a nice guy too. Places like Old Fashion are what make New York City special. It’s not just about the food, and the food is great, but there’s a neighborly quality to the rare spots like these.
I got the grandma slice. So delicious.
I can’t wait to come back.
He’s such a nice guy too. Places like Old Fashion are what make New York City special. It’s not just about the food, and the food is great, but there’s a neighborly quality to the rare spots like these.
I got the grandma slice. So delicious.
I can’t wait to come back.
Was in NY for a trip, is the best pizza around better then the pizza in Pittsburgh also.
Parking: Not sure about parking if it is free or pay, I just park and took a chance
Parking: Not sure about parking if it is free or pay, I just park and took a chance
Old Fashion Pizzeria is a quaint, friendly neighborhood spot in NYC known for its delicious slices and loaded rolls. The owner is incredibly nice and funny, adding to the delightful experience. The buffalo chicken slice and margherita slice are highly recommended, along with the grandma slice, which is described as so delicious. The owner passionately serves up pies and great subs, contributing to the neighborly atmosphere that makes places like Old Fashion special. While parking can be tricky due to the bike lane, the service and food quality make it worth the visit. Call ahead for takeout to enjoy the great food and the super gregarious owner while picking up.