13 Best American Restaurants near Olcott

“Great food and fantastic service“

“Homemade chili, soups and hand cut curly fries! The owner also makes his own hot sauce which is delicious. We've been going just about every weekend to enjoy lunch with the family. Great place for breakfast and lunch with that little hometown feel.“

“We have visited several times when we are in Olcott salmon fishing. Excellent clam chowder, cold beer and the service is very good!“

“Dined here for Mother’s Day. Let’s see what to have? I choose the sumptuous buffet. It started with shrimp salad with ice underneath. Then on to pancakes, bacon and sausage. I skipped cheese potatoes and frittata. Watermelon bowl of fruit so fresh-amazing. Next ham & ?? Forgot lol. Then beef, homemade - not salty , tater tots . Next my favorite turkey, homemade gravy , squash, Oh little croissant crab sandwiches, deviled eggs. Sure glad I looked it all over ahead of time as one could hardly sample everything here! Thought I was done, turned around to see cookies, mini muffins, Strudels in various flavors then mini cupcakes, and regular cookies in many kinds, oatmeal raisin, peanut, chocolate chip. Plus all the things I forgot. I was stuffed when I left. Only $30 bet I ate a whole turkey dinner putting breakfast and lunch aside as well as dessert. So worth it!! But wait when I first came in we were asked menu or buffet. We looked over buffet and then found there was prime rib king or queen, cut and then the chicken and biscuits and gravy!!! Now what??? I decided buffet Then because I love good food I asked for chicken & biscuit with gray To Go!! Sat down to enjoy all my choices.,0h my enough food for a family. My daughter was in same boat - way to much. We tried a lot but I have to say everything was delicious!!! Sunday was out of this world , I can only guess chicken and biscuits will be too. Well we have eaten here before. They have spaghetti- so good, seafood of all kinds, salads- you name it, they may have it. So nice eating outside when it’s a little warmer. So be sure to try this nice restaurant across from the park. You’ll be happy you did!! Open Fri, Sat, and Sunday. Call to see about Thursday. They told us ;but now not sure. Olcutt is a great place to visit, enjoy the park. Little shops, ice cream beautiful Lake Ontario and what a sunset. Weekends are best. I had a wonderful Mother’s Day!!❤️💐Thanks to my beautiful daughter who surprised me!!“

“My husband and I went here for the first time today and we had a wonderful experience! We were greeted with smiles when we came in and the owner came and talked with us! It was very welcoming. The food came out in a timely manner and was delicious!!! I ordered the pork tacos and I definitely want to come back! Great staff! Great food! Perfect atmosphere!“

“Hilltop catered our wedding this past Saturday for over 200 people and it was absolutely incredible!!! We knew from our tasting that Hilltop was our winner! Everything was amazing; the display, the service, the ease and speed of the buffet and most importantly the food!!! We had people coming up to us all night raving about how this was the best food they have ever had at a wedding and people called and sent texts the next day still raving! Crystal is amazing and went above and beyond to ensure that we had a perfect celebration! We cannot thank Hilltop enough for helping us have the wedding of our dreams!“

“Highly recommend the fish tacos! They are a game changer! It’s 90 degrees out tonight and the dining room was so nice and cool! Great staff, great food and fantastic atmosphere! 10/10“

“Best Fish Fry I’ve had in a long time !! New England Chowder was the Best Ever! Service was Outstanding !!! Can’t wait to go Back 😎😎“

“Amazing food, nice view, good bands, we are regulars and the barmaid Courtney is fantastic we had a good time last night, thank you sunset grill“

“Our 1st visit. Pros; great server who worked for every penny she made tonight. She ran the bar and the waited the tables. Cozy atmosphere, minus the bar noise. Food was good. Ordered a beef taco, sampler and a slice. We waited a bit longer than it should have taken for such a simple order but we were not in a hurry. Cons; Had we been in a time crunch.. I would have been very disappointed. The pizza sauce was way too sweet on the slice, and the slice was coldish and tasted old, the cheese was hard. Also the side sauces for the sampler platter are served in plastic cups and they are all cold. My son loves to dip his pizza logs and Mozzarella sticks in warm sauce.. I’m looking forward to returning to try something new. We live about 15 min away so it’s close enough. Side note: we met a man named Matt here tonight and he took our bill and paid it. Chatted with my son and I for a few minutes and was a genuinely nice guy! We tried to return the favor, but we will just pay it forward ❤️ Kindness is Contagious.. pass it on! Matt made our night.“

“1st timer trying Matty's. Called in for a large pep, fresh mushroom, and garlic pie. We'll be back again soon. The pizza was absolutely amazing. From the dough and crust to the perfect cook time and perfect amount of toppings. Their sauce (We ordered their regular sauce) was really good. Next time I'm ordering extra sauce because it was so pleasing. Keep up the good work Matty's! I HIGHLY recommend giving this establishment a try.“

“The food was good. Pizza types are unique and delicious. The only downside was our server, Stefanie, insisted that there was an upcharge for cheese on a bean burger that was listed on the menu as "includes your choice of cheese..." When I tried to point out to her that the menu doesn't say that and it is included, she became rude and refused to do anything about it. Would have given 5 stars since the food was good. But Stefanie's service lost them a star from my review.“

“Our 1st visit. Pros; great server who worked for every penny she made tonight. She ran the bar and the waited the tables. Cozy atmosphere, minus the bar noise. Food was good. Ordered a beef taco, sampler and a slice. We waited a bit longer than it should have taken for such a simple order but we were not in a hurry. Cons; Had we been in a time crunch.. I would have been very disappointed. The pizza sauce was way too sweet on the slice, and the slice was coldish and tasted old, the cheese was hard. Also the side sauces for the sampler platter are served in plastic cups and they are all cold. My son loves to dip his pizza logs and Mozzarella sticks in warm sauce.. I’m looking forward to returning to try something new. We live about 15 min away so it’s close enough. Side note: we met a man named Matt here tonight and he took our bill and paid it. Chatted with my son and I for a few minutes and was a genuinely nice guy! We tried to return the favor, but we will just pay it forward ❤️ Kindness is Contagious.. pass it on! Matt made our night.“