50 Best American Restaurants near Lewiston

“We ended up at Silo after the restaurant we were going to was closed. Honestly, I had my expectations low and ordered the chicken souvlaki salad, and to my surprise it was absolutely amazing! It was packed with bright, crunchy vegetables and a generous portion of tender, perfectly seasoned chicken. The tzatziki sauce was cool, tangy, and full of fresh herb flavor, tying everything together beautifully. The portion size was excellent, making it a great value for the money. Fresh, vibrant, and satisfying. I would definitely order it again!“

“I was just there the food was really good I had the fish fry the Louisiana fish fry I believe Katie was my server good service.“

“Apple granny food is so good that you want to bring more food home for dinner“

“This place is a true gem. There is something for everyone in this amazingly diverse, freshly made, and uniquely crafted culinary experience. Tonight, I requested a menu item that had been tweaked, as they constantly evolve their offerings to keep new and exciting dishes at the forefront. When I asked for it, they didn’t hesitate or give the usual “not sure we can” response—which would have been understandable, especially since the place was packed. Instead, I was assured they would do their best, and if it couldn’t be made, it would be personally explained to me. Adrienne, who made this possible and is essentially the director of the restaurant, bars, and lounge—a demanding role, especially on a busy day—went above and beyond, and I am so thankful to her. The dish was fantastically prepared, and I deeply appreciate both the food and the service. Bradley and others also stopped by to say hello and see if there was anything else they could help with. Truly top-tier in every way. Eating here feels like choosing to stay at a five-star hotel in NYC—exceptional, thoughtful, and memorable. Thank you so much to Adrienne and her entire staff“

“Aug 20. Took my sons on a guys only fishing trip on Lake Ontario and had dinner and drinks at this very good tavern. The food was delicious, but the best part was Katie and Bryn were outstanding at seeing to our needs. We enjoyed the service and social engagement. The three of us will definitely return during our next visit to the area“

“Great food, Great atmosphere, wonderful staff!!! 5 stars“

“Things started out on a bad note as the location in Open Table is incorrect. We didn't discover this until after we had already parked and paid event parking rates only to discover we were over a mile from the actual destination. We moved the car to a different lot and had to pay a second event rate fee. We were originally seated at stools at a counter top directly under a speaker. I'm not sure what the purpose of a reservation is for if we weren't to be seated at a table. We requested to be moved and were seated at a table in the far corner - still better than the stool. From there everything went up- the service the food and the drinks were wonderful. I had the lobster roll, the portion was huge and delicious. The Turfboard was a meal on its own even split between two people. Our server was fast and checked on us regularly. Minus the sting of unnecessarily paying $45 for parking and the confusing seating - I really enjoyed the evening.“

“We chose Tin Pan for our mini reunion (12 people) and we were so glad we did. The patio was perfect and the food and drinks were great! Carla, our waitress was exceptional. She Continuously was checking on us to make sure all was good. We all ordered different entrees and everyone enjoyed their choices. Awesome restaurant!“

“Food is excellent and very reasonable. The waitstaff was on top of everything. Wonderful experience.“

“Came in today and was expecting a typical fast food/casual dining experience. The restaurant was surprisingly busy, but our server Charles, really impressed us. We expected a longer wait time but our drinks and food came out so quickly and everything was perfect. Thanks again Charles“

“We visited Turtle Jacks while on vacation. The food was excellent, but two servers that were in the place were not nice and did not want to serve us. Until Jen who was amazing. We sat there for 30 minutes and the two servers kept walking pass us like we didn't exist. At that point my husband and I were getting ready to walk out until Jen came over, she apologized for the delay and service. She gave us the BEST service ever. She went above and beyond ! Thank you JEN you made our experience at Turtle Jack GREAT!“

“I called the week before arriving to inquire about a large group seating, the hostess took my name, number and size of party. She asked me to call the day before to confirm, which I did. We arrived earlier than expected and had to wait a little bit so current diners could finish up and give the staff time to setup for the 38 of us. I was very pleased with how friendly and accommodating the staff was for the size of our group. A group of 38 adults and youth hockey players from is a lot to handle. Not one complaint from our large group. I would definitely recommend and will, happily, return when in the area again.“

“Wow, this establishment is a far cry away from the pirate bar it used to be back five some odd years ago. We came here from Hamilton for a new years dinner. Had the place to ourselves, it was nice. A gentleman, by the name of Harmeet owns this establishment. Very friendly gentleman, very inviting, greeted us and told us about the food and displayed a passion for his food unlike any I've seen before. He makes most his food and all his sauces from scratch. Things like the fries and mozzarella sticks he gets in bulk, but he ensures a quality provider. The mozza sticks had that nice gooey stringy stretch to them. The fries were the first hint this meal was going to be good. Well seasoned and crunchy, done just right. My brother's girlfriend had them in a poutine and the serving was very generous, definitely fill you up to the max with one order. She was very happy with this dish. My brother had the parm chicken sandwich and I had the Nashville Chicken sandwich. The chicken patty was perfect, so juicy. The Nashville wasn't your traditional style sandwich (usually garnished with coleslaw, pickles, and tossed in Nashville sauce) it had the seasoning dry rubbed on, I think there was a sauce to it, but the chicken was so juicy it really didn't need much. It was topped with a slice cheddar, lettuce, onions, and I think there was tomato, but I'm not sure. It was so good it was gone before I had time to really analyze it lol. The key take away from this meal was my wifes chicken wings... Of anywhere we have ever had wings, these by far were the best we have ever had. The breading was thin and not overwhelming, good meat content too. Generous saucing (she got the honey hot), and they are also marinated to boot, absolutely phenomenal. Harneet has a skill for his homemade sauces, he let me try his dynamite sauce (which for most people I would say is at the top of their tolerance for hot sauce, he also has hotter), but the ballance of sweet to heat is perfect. I can not stay enough about how good this food was. The place doubles as a convenience store, so its very unassuming. This place is on the route for one of my favorite motorcycle routes, so I will be back 100%. Thank you for serving me, and the outstanding dining experience.“

“Being from Milwaukee, my standards for a Friday fish fry are pretty high. I can tell you all the locals who recommended Ray's Tavern to me, we're spot on. Excellent meal & service! Thank you's to Nick (the owner) & my server Christina!“

“Great food and wonderful staff.“

“Enjoyed an excellent dinner tonight at Savor. Food was delicious-there were four of us—two of us had the pork chop and the other two had the Swiss burger. Well prepared, juicy, tasty. Would have again. The $30 prix fixe dinner offers appetizer (we had the crab cake and the goat cheese and quinoa salad), main course and dessert (all excellent). Student/servers did a great job. Hats off to the chefs. Will return. Make sure to get a reservation.“

“Love this place! Great people, great food, and it’s right in Ransomtucky!“

“The Food was fantastic, and they have a great wine selection. On top of that staff was super friendly. This is definitely a great spot to spend time with family and friends, very top notch!“

“If you plan on getting a window table, your only chance is to make an advanced reservation. But a reservation will not guarantee a window table, it just improves your chances. Best chances are to reserve a table at 11:30 (when they open for lunch). The food was reasonably priced for such a fantastic location and it was delicious.“

“It's nice having the Marlboro open again. Great bar area. The dining room is spacious. The Food is fabulous and so reasonable with the rest of the world. One suggestion. The salmon. Prepare it differently. The stuff in the bowl. Yuck The salmon was delicious.“

“Amazing fish dinner! I wont eat a fish fry anywhere else. the staff is amazing and friendly 💜“

“The food was fantastic and we received excellent customer service! We were able to sample our drinks prior to selecting. The burgers were some of the best I’ve ever tasted.“

“The service was very good Sat in the bar area for TV sports, which several TV’s with different games on and easy viewing Meal was OVER the TOP Experienced the Crab Melt Awesome job Chef Relaxing fun time“

“Pizza an wings is really gd wish they GrubHub tho so I could order all the time“

“Had the roast beef.....it was fantastic!“

“CAN'T BEAT THE PRICE, MORE IMPORTANTLY CAN'T BEAT THE TASTE! YUMMY OR AS I SAY "YUBBY"!!!!“

“Absolutely fantastic service, atmosphere, view of Niagara Falls, and meal. Couldn't have asked for a better dinner and dessert to celebrate my Mom's birthday. Thank you, Mortons Grille! Thanks for the exceptional service, Leesa and crew!“

“amazing staff. handled our last minute group of 26 for our wedding. thank you. food was amazing rowe 2022 wedding sept 10“

“We had a fabulous time at this restaurant. The staff were amazing. The food was awesome. The whole vibe was just pretty darn cool. Highly, highly recommended.“

“Such a cute little hideaway that we stumbled upon out of the blue. Why didn't we know about this sooner?! The fish fry (lunch portion) was wonderful and plentiful. I would highly recommend this place...however, I'd never get a seat again if I did! Lol“

“This is not a fine dining restaurant, but it is a very nice family-friendly spot where you can enjoy a great meal after a full day of activities. It feels a bit more elevated and relaxed compared to the other dining options in the resort, which we really appreciated.
They offer a solid kids’ menu,my daughters had the chicken parmigiana and loved it. For the adults, we tried the seared ahi tuna and the braised beef ravioli, and both were excellent for a restaurant at this level.
The wine list was also a pleasant surprise, with a good variety of VQA wines along with a few international options.
Service was excellent! friendly, attentive, and very accommodating with kids, which always makes a big difference when dining as a family.
We had a really great experience overall. Having traveled extensively with our kids and dined at all types of restaurants, I can confidently recommend this place to families looking for a quieter, sit-down option that elevates the dining experience within the resort without needing to leave.“

“We went for a late lunch yesterday. Everything was amazing. Our server JoAnn went above and beyond to make our meal and experience perfect. We have been there many times but I would say yesterday was our best meal and service. Hope we get to sit in JoAnn's section when we return again next month.“

“This is a Top Knotch Local Place to eat at with Food that is Out of This World!!!! It has had the same Owners for 30 years and most of their Staff has been there for 15 years or longer! Tammi was our Waitress and she was Phenomenal❣️
We're headed back to Nashville Tennessee in the morning but if and when we came back to Niagra We WIll go back!!!“

“Traveled here from Maryland and had Taylor’s saved as a place to visit based on reviews. We were not disappointed! Our server was great and very accommodating, especially with our furbaby Ziggy along. We all agreed the French onion soup was the best we have ever had!“

“you need to put sweet relish in your macaroni and potatoes salads no taste to it“

“luv the brisket ! took some time to get all that smoke in there.“

“Great place to take the kids for icecream 🍦“

“The food was great and the service was spectacular! Bill is very attentive and provided us with many activities to do even though it’s not tourist season right now. The locals that were there were also very nice and helpful. They even gave us sleds to take with us so that we could go sledding! The atmosphere is one that makes you want to stay for a long time. The daily special was delicious. Highly recommend.“

“large portion, friendly, lot more expensive than U.S.“

“I believe they have the best chicken wings in Niagara County..always have great service and great bartenders!!
Highly recommend this place!!
Also have pool +darts((have leagues in both) and many times have fantastic live music!!!“

“Been meaning to come here since they opened ... a few years ago? Finally got the chance. The menu seemed okay but we just ordered beers. I got a Southern Tier Irish Coffee Cream Ale. It was absolutely delightful. I'll definitely check the spot out again. Seems like it'd be a good place to watch a game.“

“We stopped for a late lunch on Saturday. Had about a 35 min wait for a party of 7. My food was great! I had a chicken sandwich and fries. Two of the kids had pizza and said it wasn't good. They said the cheese was weird. Everything else was great. Our server was great, friendly and engaged frequently. Wonderful atmosphere. Reasonably priced and variety of menu options.“

“1st time trying the food at the dog house today! Omg I was extremely happy with the entire experience. I ordered fish and chips, onion rings and ate my husband's chicken tenders. I was full from eating my food but I honestly didn't want to stop eating cause it was so good. I highly recommend this place. Can't wait to go back. I fully intend on going there and trying every thing on the menu.

Kid-friendliness: Definitely kid friendly. They have a wide variety of kid friendly food.“

“I’ve lived in Niagara for 20 years and the Eager Beaver is our to go place now. Hands down the best chicken wings and pizza around. Our waitress Robin did an amazing job servicing my crew Saturday night. You definitely have to go and check it out. You won’t be disappointed! Thank you“

“Had lunch there with my family and the staff was amazing. The cocktails were excellent and the food delicious especially their poutine. 10 out of 10 recommend.“

“My husband and my family come here all the time. It is always spot on and the service is always amazing! Was just there for breakfast today and it was so good and the waitress was so nice. Keep up the great work, you’re always busy for good reasons!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“The breakfast was delicious. you have to try a grilled muffin. The service was fantastic. Definitely stop by if you are looking for a great breakfast.“

“friendly staff and hours aren't bad. I haven't tried delivery yet. I will try in the near future.“

“Such a great place. Food was delicious and fresh. Service was impeccable and atmosphere relaxing. I’d be surprised if it didn’t have a Michelin star or 2 ⭐️ ⭐️“