50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Old Bethpage

“Cheap ice cream 10$ for a quart. Milkshakes are huge and painful but tasty. Not only is it a place you can eat inside and it shouldn't be full. It's a place where you can pick up and go.

Vegetarian options: Ice cream is pretty vegitarian if I do say so myself.

Parking: WAY TOO MANY PARKING SPOTS

Kid-friendliness: What's more friendly than a fricking sugar field day store“

“was awesome, 1st time there“

“My daughter and I happened upon this place and we were so happy we did! Chris (not sure if he was the owner or not) was super helpful since we have food allergies. He made my daughter a cotton candy milkshake which she absolutely devoured. I had a flavored coffee which was delicious. From the black and white checkered floor to the murals on the walls, the vintage looking tables and chairs to the fun gelato display case (which was nice and low for little ones to be able to choose from) the decorated garage door which let in so much light to the retro cola display fridge, everything was so well thought out and just a lot of fun. Kudos to them for a really great place, definitely go visit!“

“Guys, I have to share my experience at Let's Roll because it was wonderful. I don't really like ice cream (i know, that's crazy right?), but my husband and my kids always go to this place so I decided to try it. It's a super friendly place that's owned by a wonderful couple (Craig & Giselle, I think? I don't really know if that's how she spells it), but I never wanted to try the ice cream. Except today. I tried the passion fruit flavor - and my God, there's nothing like it! You really have to taste it - it's so yummy. And besides, the place is super family-friendly, with super nice people, such positive energy. I will be back soon. 5 stars for Let's Roll in Merrick!“

“Great spot, total hidden gem. I come in here time to time and their gelato is fantastic. My two favorites are the pistachio and rainbow cookie gelato ?.. they also have a nice selection of pastries / cakes. If you have a sweet tooth the cannoli creme filled lobster tails were amazing as was the rainbow cookie cheese cake! Last but not least they have a wide range of offerings as far as coffee & espresso!“

“I had the best experience at Carvel today! My server-extraordinare Jessica gave me world-class service and kindly helped me pick out the perfect Fudgy the Whale cake! Def coming back! Her boss Amanda was stellar as well! Best Carvel in Nassau!“

“I figured I would try this place out as they are one of the few places where I can find any coconut flavors. I got a medium cup of ice cream for$6.50 (includes tax). You get 3 scoops. I got coconut, toasted coconut, and chocolate lovers. It was amazing and worth the price which I can't say for other places. I would recommend giving this a try, There is lots of seating and the workers were pleasant.“

“- "What a hidden gem! Michuacana exceeded my expectations with its rich flavors, generous portions, and warm service. I'll be back soon!

Kid-friendliness: Highly recommended for kids - "I've never seen such a diverse range of ice cream flavors! Michuacana's got it all, from fruity to nutty to decadent chocolate. The quality is top-notch, and I can't wait to try more!"“

“If you want a place to go eat with dirty hands this is the one! Bathroom is always closed but there’s an alley not too far away. You can tell management really cares about the customer experience when they keep the bathroom closed from customers. And they even have tables, that alone would be a health department violation(tables without a working bathroom) but who has time to call them anyway? I think the stuff here is delicious but it could also be the flavor from the last customer on the door handle so who knows?“

“Favorite place to visit for a ice cold treat :) Quick service, always got my fav flavor in stock.“

“fresh buns and delicious dogs!“

“Great Stuff! Wonderful Service!“

“Unique and fun experience! Delicious ice cream and friendly workers! Will definitely be back!! Coram location“

“I have visited this store unexpectedly, and I must admit, the staff’s were very friendly and helpful, the atmosphere was very pleasant and extremely welcoming. This store is very tidy and make anyone feel they’re being treated right and they have a great selection of products to choose from.
Jason- Queens- NYC
Attorney- In- Fact!“

“Homemade ice cream!!! Love it“

“Purchased this beautiful unicorn cake yesterday! It’s so freaking cute & was delicious! I tried the strawberry soft serve which was dairy free & made with oat milk. It was ok for what it was. Don’t think I’d purchase that one again. They did have about 4-5 options that were dairy free & cannot wait to try those next! Zhao helped us (as per the receipt) & she was so kind & gave phenomenal service. Very quick too. The store itself was so clean & they had a ton of options as far as cakes go and even the frozen ice cream section. Will definitely come back again & again ?

Dietary restrictions: They have sugar free frozen options & dairy free options for soft serve & regular scoop ice cream.“

“This place is so much fun for kids! Mine love watching the “smoke” cloud pour out, and the ice cream is always fantastic.

Kid-friendliness: The staff is always very sweet with my kids, and they love watching the ice cream be made.“

“lovee!!!!“

“I love everything about this place. The cookies. The atmosphere, the wall with the huge cookie. The people there are extremely nice and I just love watching everyone bake their cookies, and they are very sanitary too!! Cookies are absolutely the best I come here very often. I threw up eating the large Reeces Peanut butter though. It was absolutely bomb but I just can’t take sugar like that.“

“A four for the ice cream which is always great But today I came in and no single Vanilla flying saucers. Loads of six packs. Refused to break up just one pack to six singles. I’m sure others would want a single after me. I’ll adjust this after owner sees and comments

Back again 2 weeks later. No single flying saucers. Time to knock of a star to 4 stars and not go back for a month. Going to Merrick Marvel now“

“My family and I finally had a chance to try La Carraia Gelateria tonight, and the entire experience was fantastic! The space is bright and clean, the owners were SO warm and welcoming, even taking the time to talk through the history of the store and the process/ingredients. The best part though was the gelato! Every flavor was incredible! There is such a noticeable difference in quality and taste! It is so refreshing to have a business run by genuinely warm and welcoming people (that just so happen to provide a delicious product!) like La Carraia Gelateria in the neighborhood! When you have a chance, support this new local business! You will not regret it!!! ❤“

“I went there and there customer service was great such a cute spot even the bathroom was extremely cute definitely took some pictures the food was so good I made my own bubble waffle there prices were good and I’d definitely come back again if you are looking for a late night spot to get a treat you should definitely come here 10/10 recommend“

“An absolute must try! Not your standard scoop of ice cream but a delightful mix that’s sort of part ice cream, part Italian ice, and part gelato with a huge array of homemade flavors. The prices are very good (especially for Long Island) and the product is phenomenal. Worth a trip out of your way to come here!

Parking: Linked number of spots in front of store, particularly on a busy day, but there is more parking in the side lot.“

“I was actually trying to go to the hamburger spot next door and saw this spot when looking for parking. There was a long line for the hamburger spot so I figured I'd get a small thing of ice cream to eat while we waited. I came here on a Saturday evening around 6pm and parking was hard to find. However, there was always someone leaving the lot.

There was no line for ice cream and staff was friendly. Credit cards are accepted. I decided on a small cup of soft serve chocolate ice cream (~$4) which was a good amount for one person. Full of flavor and very creamy. I would definitely return to try other menu items!“

“I come every Tuesday for the buy one get one free Twisters and first off not only are the ices and ice cream fresh and delicious!! But the staff there is amazing....the owners cousin always helps me and she is fantastic!! Thank you Ralph's of Farmingdale!!“

“The ice cream is just as amazing as the place looks inside! Honestly better than any Ralph’s Ive ever had. The pricing is so fair and the portions are huge!I got the Cookie Monster & double chocolate chip, and my boyfriend got vanilla chip & orange. We both LOVED them - I’m 100000% coming back here and wish I had visited sooner!

Parking: There’s spots in the front and a whole back parking lot behind the shopping center.

Kid-friendliness: Any kid would love the inside of this place!“

“Was very good. My grandson enjoyed his sundee. Nice and clean and very friendly“

“I’m amazed-really great service. Friendly staff. Even though the place was hopping, these servers really did a fantastic job and kept smiles on their faces. Bravo Friendlys!!“

“Carvel ice cream cakes bring out the childhood nostalgia in me!I did not spend much time in store but the older gentleman who attended to me was super helpful. He made suggestions for best results before serving and offered to decorate the cake further for us.The cake was as I remembered and I was transported back to my childhood and savoured each mouthful.Carvel has my heart!“

“It was a Dream for my daughter come true, waiting 1 Hour to have to Cookies.

Dietary restrictions: A lot of Sugar in it of corse.

Kid-friendliness: Only children Inside

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“Fantastic from beginning to end! Walked in on a busy night, and was quickly greeted with a smile and positivity. The owner (i believe) was there helping her staff tend to the crowd.
I asked about private catering and she was super helpful and provided me with information during the rush as well. Couldn’t recommend it more, love Ben and Jerry’s and this location!“

“Love the atmosphere- they have fresh ices and ice cream- possibly too many choices - line moves fast . Staff is friendly and efficient. Store is clean . The sell cute merch too

Dietary restrictions: They have non cream ices which my boyfriend loves“

“Awesome place and such a friendly staff. This place has been around since 1985 ❤️“

“I drive 40 Minutes to huntington from my home for their delicious waffle cone and dulce de leche ice cream. This location is my most preffered we have here in the Island. It is very clean and the young ladies and gentlemen that work here are so kind and patient. It is and will always be a pleasure to come to Kilwins. You come once and will never stop coming !!!“

“Love this place. We always try to stop in when we visit family on the island. Would have given it 5 stars, but they didn't have the flavor that I painstakingly waited 6 months for. You let me down Ralph. My puppy enjoyed his treat though. We'll def be back.“

“They are 3 Sisters and A Lovely Brother who I believe all work full time 9-5 elsewhere. The ice cream Is good but they Charge me way way more the The Udall rd west islip or The Howells rd one and they are so stingy it's Kind of sad because I try to support omw there now but quantity needs to change. Clean STORE Is a plus.“

“Always great ice cream and ices, the girls are friendly and welcoming. Best there is.“

“***** (Five Star) Review - The hubby and I love the Hicksville Sweet Shop! It is such a warm and welcoming restaurant/ice cream shop – were everyone knows your name! We reserved a table for Valentines Day and had a wonderful meal consisting of crab cakes, fried shrimp, French fries, vegetables and, for dessert, fresh homemade strawberry shortcake – reservations are rarely needed! Homemade ice cream and chocolates are also delicious! I can honestly say I never had a bad meal at the Hicksville Sweet Shop! Thank you Eva, Phil, Harry, Walter, Alma, Jeannie & Clair❤️e!“

“It’s not just Wednesday is Sundae at Carvel .. any day is great for a Sundae ! Was given a sample cup of the Strawberry Soft Serve because I said I had never had it before .. it was amazing. Had my favorite on this night though .. Chocolate ice cream with Strawberry topping and whipped cream on top. Great service here !“

“This is long islands guilty pleasure. Love stoping by in a hot summer night for any flavor you are craving for“

“Everyone who grows up on Long Island knows that Ralph's Ices is a staple. All of the locations are excellent, but this one right here takes it to the next level. Recently renovated, super clean and very efficient.

The staff goes above and beyond offering a seemingly endless array of tastings and flavors (Kudos to Maddy for being the best). The drive-thru is so convenient, they offer ice cream & soft serve as well, and they even have a candy bar! Cannot recommend enough.“

“Great icecream and yogurt“

“Wow! Blown away by service and the tasty gelato- I’ve been on the hunt for over ten years for a gelato even close to what you can get in Europe and this is the best I’ve found!
Dana was so kind especially with my sons. Thanks for a great experience we’ll definitely be back!“

“Ralphs Italian Ices are always great. It was on the visit bucket list since my kids have never had them. As always the food was great. The staff, not so much. They seemed bothered by us being there, and both seemed to be having a miserable day. In the end, we got what we went for, spent some time as a family, and enjoyed our snack after a very tough day saying goodbye my mother-in-law.“

“it's Carvel, nuff said 🙂🍦🍦🍦🙂“

“Amazing. So incredibly fresh. We will be back.“

“the german chocolate cake ice cream was out of this world! would totally recommend=)“

“Fast service“

“We went today for smoothies. The girl behind the counter Belair (not sure if I spelled it correctly) was amazing. She was by herself and today was very hot. There were a lot of customers coming in and she handled every person with a smile and excellent customer service.“

“Me and my colleagues stopped at carvel and man oh man was that ice cream absolutely scrumptious this location in particular is amazing! The girl w the bun is the nicest girl you'll ever meet plain and simple and sweet like the treats also how does she get her bun like that crazy!!! Very nice people who own this and great staff“