15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Otego

“How some people can give Rubera's bad ratings is beyond me. I guess they just don't know what good Italian food is. Rosie and Franco are extremely nice people and the food is excellent. Prices are very reasonable. I grew up in a large downstate city with more family run, home cooking, Italian restaurants than you can shake a stick at and Rubera's ranks right up there with them. I've never been disappointed there.“

“We had a full meat pizza and it was delicious 😋 The guys are super sweet,very helpful, and the atmosphere is great. They're even open until 3am!!!We're saving their info for our next visit into New York 🍕“

“One of the better Pizza places in Oneonta. Large menu, a bit dated on the inside, but worth trying if you're near.“

“Dante's is one of the many pizzerias in Oneonta that have good pizza. We've had mixed opinions on the food and quality in the past, but they have since been resolved and more consistently deliver quality food. A while back we had mentioned that we hoped to see them make something unique to them, something to stand out. Since then, Dante's has made the Chicago Double Thick Pan Cheese Pizza, which at the time we said: "Dante’s Pizzeria's Chicago double thick pan cheese pizza isn't just one of their best pizzas we've tried, it's one of THE best pizzas we've tried in Oneonta." And we still stand by that today. It's still the go to pizza, and worth trying if you haven't. The only issue we've had or heard of, is sometimes the bottom crust holds some burnt seasonings, which can add an acrid taste. Aside from that, their food is great and this pizza is excellent.“

“one of the best pizzerias in Oneonta. the owner clearly cares about the quality of his food, and cares about his customers.“

“Good food, friendly service“

“I went in there to order take-out. The person at the register was busy, so I waited about 10 min. until she was done helping people. I asked a question, she looked at me, and she just walked away, and acted as if I was not there. She then talked to someone sitting at the bar about the guest before me. I then decided to go elsewhere.

Addendum: I decided to give it another try. Food was good and plentiful. The waiter was great.“

“Here for grandson’s baseball and decided to stay close to our marriott hotel for dinner. Sal’s pizza was a major surprise. Delightful and delicious from start to finish. My buffalo chicken salad was outrageous and my husband’s tuna sub could have fed three people. Because our order was a bit late coming out (due to the tremendous amount of take out orders) Bobby, the new owner, brought out cannolis which was quite thoughtful and smart. He’s a Brooklyn, NY guy who knows his recipes. A must not dine in.“

“Nina's, the new Nina's, the New New Nina's Restaurant and Pizzeria? Whichever Nina's it is now, they have great food. Pizza's are good, though a bit skimpy on the cheese. The rest of the current menu is also pretty good and has a good variety. The drive to keep this historic location open shows in their food and families charisma. While Oneonta has no shortage of pizza places, it's still made truly special by keeping this one around.“

“Went there on a whim tonight. I'm Italian and I have had mussels prepared in so many ways. Those were the best mussels I ever had. Everything was rich and buttery including the fresh pasta and shrimp. Really good meal with fresh ingredients. Bravo!“

“We ordered takeout from here last night. We haven't ordered anything from them for probably two years prior. It was honestly the "under new management" sign that prompted us to try it again as we weren't thrilled with things prior to that. Well, the new management only needs to keep doing what they did last night and they should be a great success! The pizza and wings were excellent. Pizza was authentically NY style and the wings would have fit in well in Western NY (we are originally from South of Buffalo). Keep up the great work!!“

“Was visiting colleges in Oneonta and this place was recommended by locals. Undercover Eggplant did not disappoint. The sandwiches were delicious, and generously sized. It came on home made bread (my wife loved the bread) that was baked right there. Creative sandwich menu with pizza and salads also available, I suggest you stop in and try it. (We left with a loaf of bread to go!)“

“Holy culinary flavors in their pulled pork Mac-n-cheese!!! Sun was hearty size too! 🤤“

“Delicious food & yummy desserts!“

“Fantastic Experience Fantastic Food“