22 Best American Restaurants near Painted Post

“my boyfriend and I were in town from buffalo and wanted to find a nice small private business for dinner. we found frans on Google..omgosh it was absolutely spectacular!!! the decor is so neat to look around and up at. it was a busy sat night. we didn't wait long for a table. everyone was so friendly and efficient. our server Chelsea was phenomenal. never needed to ask for anything. the food was beyond anything we could have hoped for and far exceeded our expectations. highly recommend the prime rib, the scallop special was excellent also. ABSOLUTELY get the chocolate cake for dessert you'd swear it Just came out of the oven. if I lived in the area I'd be here only. it was so nice seeing the ppl who lived there say hi to several groups each time they came in. we didn't feel like visitors at all but like family. thank you! job well done!! many blessings for contiined success“

“My sister and I were in the area for my nephews wedding and came across Jelly Beans. A very cute comfortable place to eat. The wait staff and hostess were very friendly and service was fast. Food was delicious and reasonably priced. Would highly recommend“

“I was looking for a bite to eat and they place popped up. I read the reviews and took a chance and ordered online. I got there and i greeted with a smile from the staff and the customers. This place felt like the show Cheers except they had live music:) I couldn't stay for the music but I really enjoyed myself for 30mins.

The food was sooooooooo good!!! Whomever the cook was that day needs a pat on their back.

If you looking for a quick amazing meal with some good company this place is it, Yep Sit and Bull Pub is AMAZING:)



Parking: Small parking area“

“I had the pleasure of dining at Applebee’s while traveling through New York State, and I couldn't be more impressed! Not only was the food delicious, but the service was top-notch. The wait staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure we felt right at home.

The real standout, however, was when I accidentally lost my wallet at the restaurant. To my relief, someone turned it in, and the manager went above and beyond by mailing it back to me in Ohio. It’s rare to find such genuine care and kindness in a restaurant, and I truly appreciate their exceptional hospitality.

This Applebee’s team made my day, and I will certainly be back next time I'm in town! Thank you for your honesty, professionalism, and outstanding service!“

“I have been a huge fan of Tossed for a while now. Their vegan wrap has been my go-to but it has just been replaced by their harvest cobb salad. It. Is. Amazing. It's the perfect combo of sweet, salty, tangy and crunch. I practically licked my bowl clean! I will have to stop myself from ordering this weekly! An added bonus is they always have friendly staff and great decor. highly recommend!“

“Searched for a local Steeler bar and this one was recommended! I’m so happy we spent our evening there! The food was good, the staff was friendly and welcoming, it was warm and comfortable and the Steelers won!!!! I highly recommend this place!“

“There is something to be said about food cooked with genuine love and care. That is what you will get here. It is no frills on the outside but it feels like a homecoming when your parents or grandparents would cook your favorite meal while you sit in the kitchen and chat... it's exactly that. Changing menu and fantastic food from the heart. Cash only

Vegetarian options: Small menu but still had delicious vegetarian options!!“

“family owned and operated with great food!“

“Nice, friendly wait staff“

“Absolutely outstanding on all aspects of our visit. The atmosphere, the food was superb, reasonably priced for what you got, but more impressive was Brynn our server everything was supersanfantastic!“

“Always an enjoyable place to go with the family for a quiet dinner. There is always a solid special and some great appetizers. The bartenders are awesome and come up with some great cocktails. Ever tried a sour old fashioned? It had egg whites and Soko so I was not sure at first to say the least. 8/10 would try again.“

“I am dairy free and it’s nice to be able to go to a local shop that offers options to meet my allergy restriction. The BEST vegan peanut butter ice cream I’ve had! Highly recommend you try it out!“

“A great spot for a romantic evening out with your significant other.“

“good times good service and the old phone booth“

“awesome place. awesome service.“

“Food and hospitality were great! Can't beat the prices! We will be back tomorrow!“

“Wonderful dinner. Rack of lamb was delicious. Great wedge salad. Warm bread with olive oil and granny apple dessert with ice cream and coffee. Mattie was a delightful and knowledgeable server! Five stars!“

“This could very well be THE BEST hotel I ever stayed at. They were thoughtful enough to decorate the entire fourier with stuffed animals with bandaids for our wildlife Rehabilitation conference since we take care of injured wildlife! The ENTIRE staff, from check in, to the kitchen and dining staff, to the house keeping were all so very sweet, fun, engaging, polite and helpful. Completely mind blown to see this level of an ENTIRE staff that accommodating. Especially this day and time. So refreshing to know this is even possible to achieve.“

“Tammy is the most amazing & generous host. Such great communication for our event. Thank you so much!“

“Meatballs Appetizer, wiped it clean, soups (creamy chicken and minestrone) yum, main dishes the trio and lasagna (home made pasta) clean the plate with my bread. With every thing so good had to try dessert, carrot cake, excellent, tirasamu, creamy and light. Staff all accommodating and pleasant. Prices, very fair.“

“The best barbecue ever! Went to a workshop and stopped in for lunch. Great atmosphere with great food!“

“Love this place the food is outstanding and the owners are top notch!“