18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Phelps

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

We grabbed a half pepperoni, half cheese pie here recently and honestly it was excellent. Hand-tossed, New York style — you can tell everything’s fresh. No shortcuts.

What made it even better was getting to meet the owner Mary. Super welcoming, great with our little ones — that stuff matters when you’ve got young kids with you. She let the kids pick out a couple of the cookies and offered them some stickers and tattoos, which I thought was a nice touch.

The staff was on top of it the whole time without being overbearing. And after the pizza, they brought out hand-baked cookies made with simple, fresh ingredients — a nice touch we weren’t expecting. The kids loved those just as much.

Speaking of the kids — on the way home they said it was the best pizza they’d ever had. That’s not something they say lightly.

Worth the visit. We’ll be back.

— Josh“

“It’s been a long time since I’ve had a favorite pizza place and I’m pretty sure Otis and Lisa’s is now my new favorite pizza place! Their food is so good! The pizza topping portions are perfect and their wings are fantastic! That home sauce is amazing! 🤩. I won’t be getting pizza or wings from anywhere else!“

“finally got to try this last weekend after moving to newark a year ago was delicious and upset I've been missing out all this time. will for sure be ordering from here more often.“

“Pizza and wings are both very good. Wings are crispy with extra sauce in the container. Cheapest bestest value around.“

“Today my wife and I grabbed slices for lunch, and I must say it was pretty delicious, cooked to perfection, with zero flop. I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza and would happily eat there again and will be. Bravo Guys!“

“Wings are really good and a good price.“

“very expensive and horrible service…the waiter had to be told what we needed instead of asking us first,food was COLD not warm but COLD…we were sat down without plates or napkins when given our appetizer and when asked it took almost 15 minutes to recieve them the waiter also never asked how the food was or anything else…FIRST AND LAST TIME GOING HERE!!!!“

“I come from ithaca. Home of the worst dominoes. This one gave me my dominoes back. Love the wings 2times. ALSO THE STAFF the staff is awesome. Some of the best customer service around and I look forward to every time I stop in! Good vibes seriously the customers service there is on point. COME TO DOMINOES!!!“

“Always bright and cheerful! Their vegetables and meat are the best around. I am pleased that Wegmans stays informed about health trends and the general public’s desire and offers a variety of products. Also Wegmans is community oriented and frequently involved in ways to help out💜“

“I have, as of Christmas, not been there, but have perused a menu. As it's a new venue, hear long wait times from people who've ordered/gone there. After the New Year, , I will definately go see for myself. .
Pics to follow!!“

“Really nice people! Told me about the offers they had available and offered to bring my pizza and wings out to me when they were done! 10/10 definitely recommend. It only costed 30$ for 2 medium pizzas and 2 orders of wings.
The photos were taken after I drove 35 minutes home so the food had cooled off a lot by then.“

“Great pizza and wings tonight! And I love the new to go boxes for the wings etc. Nice work Mike and staff!“

“I just had one of the best fish fry’s ever! Way to go Joe Shell!“

“Never had a bad experience. Great place to eat, enjoyed every meal.“

“Twisted Rail Geneva is a beautiful venue for music!“

“Amazing staff always helpful the food is amazing also!!“

“I had low expectations ordering from here. As many other sub places have disappointed me. This place however, blew my expectations out of the water. The sub was huge and so flavorful. They dont skimp on the meat, ect. (Looking at you Wegmans). I hope this place never decides to cut corners, because this place just became my new favorite sandwich place.“

“Pizza is always hot and on time.....and delicious!“