18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Phelps

“It’s been a long time since I’ve had a favorite pizza place and I’m pretty sure Otis and Lisa’s is now my new favorite pizza place! Their food is so good! The pizza topping portions are perfect and their wings are fantastic! That home sauce is amazing! 🤩. I won’t be getting pizza or wings from anywhere else!“

“Pizza and wings are both very good. Wings are crispy with extra sauce in the container. Cheapest bestest value around.“

“finally got to try this last weekend after moving to newark a year ago was delicious and upset I've been missing out all this time. will for sure be ordering from here more often.“

“very expensive and horrible service…the waiter had to be told what we needed instead of asking us first,food was COLD not warm but COLD…we were sat down without plates or napkins when given our appetizer and when asked it took almost 15 minutes to recieve them the waiter also never asked how the food was or anything else…FIRST AND LAST TIME GOING HERE!!!!“

“Today my wife and I grabbed slices for lunch, and I must say it was pretty delicious, cooked to perfection, with zero flop. I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza and would happily eat there again and will be. Bravo Guys!“

“Twisted Rail Geneva is a beautiful venue for music!“

“Wings are really good and a good price.“

“Always bright and cheerful! Their vegetables and meat are the best around. I am pleased that Wegmans stays informed about health trends and the general public’s desire and offers a variety of products. Also Wegmans is community oriented and frequently involved in ways to help out💜“

“This place used to be a Pizza Hut. They kept everything the same where possible, and so that old-school atmosphere is there. The food is great! Best Salvatore's in this area! On this visit, we dined in and got slices. But we've also gotten take-out several times and have not been disappointed. The owner is nice and personable. Keep up the good work!“

“Never had a bad experience. Great place to eat, enjoyed every meal.“

“So good, so good 👍. Tried their cheese spinach Alfredo pizza 🍕 on our way to NYC. One of the best pizza we have tried so far. The staff girl who took our order made an amazing pizza ans she was so nice and friendly, she helped choosing the pizza. Highly recommend 👌“

“Do NOT miss out on this gem of a quick eatery and pub hang out! My friend and i had traveled from out of state, it was late and we were hungry and exhausted. Even though it was close to closing we were welcomed in by the main bartender Blake and Angie who was in training. She did great btw. The chef Juan was out in the main area since it was late and gave us not only great recommendations for our food but also for our trip around the wine trail we had planned for tomorrow. We both had sandwiches with their roast beef. The meat was tender and flavorful and the bread was so good! Our meal really hit the spot after such a long day and what made it even better was the amazing and welcoming service we received. If you live in Geneva, make this your regular hangout!!!“

“Amazing staff always helpful the food is amazing also!!“

“I just had one of the best fish fry’s ever! Way to go Joe Shell!“

“Great pizza and wings tonight! And I love the new to go boxes for the wings etc. Nice work Mike and staff!“

“9/3/26The lady at the register when I picked up my order was super nice. There was a little old man trying to place an order and she told him 20 minutes and he told her he had to go to work he didn't have 20 minutes she skipped a mobile order and went ahead and got him food ready for him. Used the mobile app to order 8 honey bbq chicken wings, a medium thin crust pepperoni pizza, small Memphis bbq chicken pizza and 2 lava cakes. I paid 57 dollars. The lava cakes were a 10/10 as always, my husband loved his pepperoni pizza, and my bbq chicken pizza was okay! The wings however looked under cooked and they seriously just squirted some bbq sauce on top of them. They look NOTHING like they advertise them and then not being cooked was the definite deal breaker.
11/16/25>Really nice people! Told me about the offers they had available and offered to bring my pizza and wings out to me when they were done! 10/10 definitely recommend. It only costed 30$ for 2 medium pizzas and 2 orders of wings.
The photos were taken after I drove 35 minutes home so the food had cooled off a lot by then. I will add photos later“

“Pizza is always hot and on time.....and delicious!“

“I got a fish fry with extra fries and lemon.
It was very yummy and I had plenty of left overs for afew days. Always a nice thing to have. There sweet and sour is also really good. Nice and sweet. I wish they had Baja Blast Moutian Dew.“