12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Phelps

The Pizza Coop Pizza • $
112 Main St, Phelps

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Meat Balls

“Very friendly staff and a beautiful location with a decent amount of seating to eat in. The pizza was great, crust is the perfect thickness and good sauce and the right amount of it as well. Love that they have cupped char pepperoni on the menu and it is phenomenal. Wings were a nice surprise at a good price and they're not tiny either. The buffalo sauce runs a bit on the hotter side FYI.“

4.8 Superb42 Reviews
Otis & Reds Pizza Takeaway • $
85 Main St, Phelps

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza

“My 1st time going n the atmosphere was great food great n the people were awesome I won a gift card from 101.7 the wall listening between 6n9am n took my friend we had the Swiss mushroom burger w ff n it was very tasty n sloppy lol a sloppy burger good burger very much enjoyed the food n I got 2meet the owners Andy n Lisa n chuck n doug who also work there very friendly people n do alot 4 their community so if your ever in Phelps go to Otis n reds n tell them Joan on da phone sent you n enjoy the food n the patsy cline music lol thank you all my 1st visit was GREAT❤️“

4.6 Superb44 Reviews
Craft 120 American • $$
120 E Union St, Newark - 6.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Flatbread Pizza
Bang Bang Spicy Shrimp
Fish Tacos
Poutine
Burger

“I was in town for business and Google led me to this fine establishment. Beer was stellar and the food was great. I had trouble deciding on a dish because they all sounded so good. The waitress, Michele, was super friendly and helpful. I couldn't recommend this place enough.“

4.5 Superb31 Reviews
Twisted Rail Brewing Geneva Brewery • $$
499 Exchange St, Geneva - 6.7 miles

“Set within a former theater, this spacious tasting venue offers a delightful combination of craft beers, brewing tanks, and music. You can expect around ten different craft beers to choose from, with their stouts and IPAs being particularly noteworthy for their distinctive flavors.“

4.3 Superb62 Reviews
Sugar & Slice Pizzeria Pizza Delivery • $$
535 W Union St, Newark - 7.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Brownie
Chicken Wings
Pizza

“We have tried sugar and slice twice now and each time we had picked up, it’s been a nice atmosphere every time we gone in,The first time we had the pizza it was really good with flavor, the kind of pizza we get which is your normal pepperoni pizza with bacon and onions, the dough was nice and flavorful as well with it being cooked to perfection for us, now the only thing was it could of had alittle more cheese but that’s just my own opinion I just like cheese, not everyone does so they had enough cheese probably for the average person lol!!!So our 2 time going I made sure to add extra cheese, and that was the best pizza, just all in all a really good pizza!! We sure will be regulars and ordering her more often!!!“

4.4 Superb38 Reviews
B B's Pizzeria Pizza • $
103 East Ave, Newark - 7.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Pepperoni Cooked Perfectly
Chicken Tenders w Fries
Large Wings & 36 Wings
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Well Done Hot Wings
Chicken Wing Pizza
Cheeseburger Sub
Roast Beef Sub
Bread Sticks
French Fries

“BB's is not what you would call a photogenic restaurant. It looks completely run down both inside and out, but they do offer solid "upstate New York" style pizza, which I recommend you take away. The wings (Buffalo, hot, of course) are also good, although mine were unevenly sauced. Coming from Lyons, Bb's is the closest decent pizza place, and despite its shortcomings, I definitely recommend it.“

4.3 Superb48 Reviews
Trom's Restaurant Salad • $
11 Pearl St, Lyons - 7.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

New England Clam Chowder
Nacho Platter

“I really like Trom’s the food is great the place is clean and service is pretty good. I did have a mixup there because of a misunderstanding about the menu and my waitress was pretty inexperienced, I messaged troms on Facebook and they responded and remedied the situation. I’ve never had another problem there again. Hubby and I frequent now for date night.“

4.3 Superb38 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
1 Exchange St, Geneva - 6.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Chicken Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Tater Tots
Lava Cake

“All and all a very good experience!! Food was excellent! The loaded tots have been consistently great since they were added. The spiniach cheese bread is always spot on as well. Tables, floors, and restrooms have been clean each time I have visited! Very well maintained. Cashier was very polite!Parking: In the old Family Video lotKid-friendliness: There is a plexiglass panel so you can view the process of your food being made! A great opportunity to learn and teach kids about cooking!“

4.2 Good32 Reviews
Pontillo's Pizza • $
120 E Union St, Newark - 6.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parm Sandwich
Chicken Wings
Pizza

“I haven’t had Pontillo’s pizza in awhile, but it has always been considered the favorite pizza in my family. The pizza and wings were just as I remembered and ready for pickup exactly on time. Staff was friendly and polite. It was nice to see that an order of wings is still 12 good size pieces as most places now only serve 10. Will definitely order again. Thank you Mike for all the years of serving delicious food to the people of your home town!“

4.2 Good26 Reviews
Cam's Pizzeria Pizza • $
476 Exchange St, Geneva - 6.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza Slice
Grilled or Crispy Chicken
York Style Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Chicken Wings

“Best thin crust pizza you can get outside of New York City. generous size and inexpensive. Single slice for lunch or snack is huge. They have some seats but it’s really for takeout or delivery. Locally owned and not part of the chain that serves our area. Owners are great people, deeply involved in the community. They are always busy so call ahead.“

4.1 Good42 Reviews
Halsey's Restaurant American • $$
106 Seneca St, Geneva - 6.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Speciality Pizza
The Halsey

“A wonderful gem of a restaurant.They do Italian and wood fried cuisine very well.Not only do they have pizza from a wood fried oven , they also create other amazing dishes to use the oven with as well.Servers are very knowledgeable and make very good recommendations.The wine list is extensive, moderately priced.Overall atmosphere was wonderful and inviting.Not overly decorated or too lavish.I want to come back and try.more of the menu and experience that is Halsey's“

4 Good57 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $$
241 E Union St, Newark - 6.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kicker Hot Sauce Sweet Mango Habanero
Cali Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken Habanero
Buffalo Chicken
Sweet BBQ Bacon
Boneless Wings
Chicken Wings
Deluxe Pizza
Tater Tots
Lava Cake

“THE FIRST DOMINOS I’VE EVER TRULY ENJOYED! Thanks everyone at this dominos. The food, time, and experience has been great. I usually don’t do chain pizza places but had to a couple of weeks ago and was pleasantly surprised. So I had to try them again. It wasn’t just a fluke. This pizza place got it right. I do recommend and I’ll definitely be back.Keep up the great work. Your efforts don’t go unnoticed. Thanks!“

4.1 Good22 Reviews
Loading...
map Map