15 Best Italian Restaurants near Pine Island

“Super cute and small diner! Incredible service , our waiter was quick and efficient and also very friendly. My son had dance practice nearby and it was perfect for lunch. It wasn’t busy at all, yet a decent amount of people there. Despite it being a smaller restaurant with a few of the tables filled, we got our food within less than 10 minutes, and everything was super delicious!Moving on, the decoration was so cute! I loved the interior and decor, lights weren’t too bright, music wasn’t too loud: and a decent amount of space as well!The food definitely reached higher compared to me and my sons expectations, we’ve been to a ton of diners in the area and this one was absolutely phenomenal!We will definitely be returning! I definitely recommend this diner to anyone in the area. ❤️“

“Don't sleep on this italian restaurant if you are in the area visiting. The food is excellent! Service was great too. If you are there on a weekend night, definitely make a reservation, it was packed when we went on Saturday evening for dinner.“

“Don't sleep on this italian restaurant if you are in the area visiting. The food is excellent! Service was great too. If you are there on a weekend night, definitely make a reservation, it was packed when we went on Saturday evening for dinner.“

“My friend visits this restaurant very often with her husband and decided to take me there today, and I couldn’t be happier. This restaurant was absolutely amazing! The food OMG,I can not wait to go again! The service was just WOW! It was beyond my expectations!!! ????????“

“Food was excellent, no complaints. Stayed at legoland and picked up, staff was great, prices were super fair. This place checks all the boxes you will not be disappointed ( steak hero was awesome as well). This place takes pride in their business and it shows!“

“We moved to Florida and we wish we could bring Cuginos with us. Well actually, don't judge... but we have packed up food to fly home with us a few times! We CRAVE the food and we look forward to dining here every time we visit NY. We love everything we have tried but a few of our favorites are the Pizza, Garlic Knots with Cheese, Thai Chili Wings well done, hot honey espresso slice with pepperoni, Eggplant Parm, Chicken Parm and Penne Ala Vodka. We have ordered trays of the Penne Ala Vodka and Eggplant Parm in the past as well, and it's a guaranteed hit at parties! My husband has always said you can put their Vodka sauce on a shoe and it will taste good. It's a family owned and operated restaurant. The owner Maria is an absolute gem and the staff is friendly and attentive. The restaurant is always clean and nicely decorated. This place remains at the top of my list and the quality of food is highly deserving of the best rating!“

“Their pizza is excellent!! I would call myself a pizza lover (I could always go for a slice of pizza). This is the best pizza in the area. The s⁸auce is way better than Pizza Express, and Rookies has gone downhill lately. The owner, Sal, is a great guy and is much nicer than the previous owner. Portions are sizeable, and the lunch specials are ridiculous. I would definitely recommend you give them a try. You won't be disappointed.“

“The owner and the young guys working tonight were amazing. My coworkers and I were the only ones in the restaurant and they treated us like we were guests in their house. The pizza with all meats was the best I've had in a long time. When he said that he was gonna put all the meats they had on it, he wasn't lying. And it wasn't too much to where it took away from the consistency with the pizza sauce and crust. Altogether it was great and I would recommend to anyone wanting pizza dining in. And they deliver too!“

“Ambiance and service were excellent, harbingers to the simply delicious entrees which followed our very unique and tasty appetizer- petite potato pancakes and deviled eggs. Main course was lamb shank Wellington (outstanding) and crab cakes (delicious), both presented with a gourmet flair, by friendly and attentive waitstaff. A truly wonderful dining experience, in this bistro-like gem of a restaurant, situated in a rural country area. Highly recommend this great place.“

“I had heard good things, and then read good reviews... but nothing could've prepared me for "The Italliano"!!!! This is one of the best sandwiches I've had in my life. THICK, FRESH, and DELICIOUS. I will absolutely be returning and can't wait to try more things. Also, the people working were incredibly friendly, and I got the sense that they take a lot of pride in the great food and service they provide. So glad I came in!!“

“I’ve held meetings at this location quite a few times. This was the first time I actually sat down and did a full meal. It was absolutely extraordinary go out of their way to make sure that you are attended to.Manager and the whole team go over and above in every aspect, I highly recommend the restaurant it’s become one of my new favorites in this area“

“There with my daughter,son and grandchildren.My daughter wasn't happy with her steak. It wasn't wasn't as good as the one's I make, but I've been telling her 20years not to order steak out because she will never get a steak as perfect as I make. I've been working at it for fifty years.Ha ha.“

“Really attractive restaurant with creative menu. Reasonably priced for quality of fare. Only four stars due to the very sloooow service. We sat with our water for at least 15 minutes before our server was actually fetched by my dinner companion to order drinks, and by then, our food.“

“I recently tried out Carlos Cucina in Goshen and was pleasantly surprised by their burgers, which were some of the best I’ve ever had. Despite being known for pizza, their burgers are a standout with juicy, well-seasoned patties and fresh, crisp toppings. The atmosphere of the restaurant is welcoming and the staff is friendly, making it a great spot for a casual meal. I’ve been here a few times now and it consistently impresses, easily living up to the 5-star rating I’ve given it. Highly recommend if you’re in the area and looking for a delicious burger (or pizza)!“

“Went out for dinner, my S/O and I diddy-bopped into Benito's and saw Beef Wellington on the specials board. I've been jonesing to try one for years and tonight was the night! Let me just say, if you live anywhere close to Warwick, NY you need to TREAT YOURSELF and try the Wellington. Everything that makes a great Wellington is magnificently brought forth, the beef done to perfection, the puff pastry light... oh my goodness. Call ahead because it's not a regular menu item, you won't be disappointed!Parking: It's a strip mall, plenty of parking.Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly.“