41 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pine Island

“The friendliness and the excellent quality of the pizza pie.“

“Love Table 21 The food is homemade & tastes Great. Prices are good“

“They don't treat you like family, when you visit, you ARE family! Asked me what I wanted, made suggestions. Got a personal pan pizza that was fantastic. Fresh and delicious. Staff is wonderful, food matched. Will go again, and again, and again. Love this place!“

“Pizza & service was great! I recommend trying the chicken bacon ranch slice!“

“Ordered Maria’s Rice con Dondulos and Pegnil. Wow! Keep an eye on their Facebook page for this occasional special! It is primo Puerto Rican fare!“

“Firstly, they were open on Labor Day so kudos for that! Secondly, I ordered a large cheese pie tonight it was done right around the time they said it would be, I picked it up and they threw a few zeppole to me on the house to go with it! Staff was friendly, price was good and the pizza was awesome and the zeppole not bad either would def recommend!“

“They have the best chicken cutlet parm and best sicilian pie around! We order from here every Friday!! 🍕“

“Delicious New York pizza 🍕 I was exploring the area and searched Maps for pizza joints. This one was close the the area I was photographing and highly rated, so I stopped in and placed an order!
The interior is classic pizza restaurant. The service was fast and friendly, answered my menu questions. Wait was relatively short and the pizza was served hot with gooey cheese 😁
I decided to eat on a table outside the shop and enjoy the people watching.
I forget which slices I ordered, but do know that one had potatoes. Both had chicken and peppers. Both slices were delish 😋
If you're in the area, definitely give them a try 💯“

“Fantastic food, eclectic menu, charming atmosphere, wonderful staff! There is everything to love about Ana Restaurant.“

“Nice variety, tasty food, helpful staff, comfortable family-friendly atmosphere inside and out. It's a nice place to grab a slice to go or dine in!“

“Our family was looking last minute for a place to have a family dinner to celebrate our daughter’s ninth birthday after our original reservation fell through at another place. Pelligrinos is our favorite pizza spot so I called them. It was 5:30PM on a Friday night and I asked if they could accommodate our party of nine at 7:00. They were happy to prepare a table for us! I was shocked. They brought us the most incredible plate antipasto and placed it in front of our daughter and said happy birthday! Then we have the most delicious apps, pizza and an incredible pasta special for dinner. We couldn’t have been happier! They then brought complimentary fried dough for dessert for the table! What an incredible experience! We were so grateful that they not only came to our rescue at that late hour, but they went above and beyond to make sure we had a great night. If you want a five star experience with both food and service, go to Pelligrinos!“

“A lot of reviews about Pizza. I would be remiss if I didn't mention this restaurant has the best baked pasta I have had and I ate everywhere in NYC for 20 years. Try the baked ziti. Also the bread is from another planet, nothing else like it anywhere.“

“We were visiting our son on the Appalachian Trail and stopped by for 6 different pizzas to bring to him and his fellow hikers on the trail. All were absolutely delicious! We were happy and so were the hikers!“

“we're new to the area and took a shot. It was the best decision and best pizza I've had. thin crust Sicilian...fantastic!“

“Good job for driving and fast!!!And good pizza“

“Barrel 28 is a wonderful place to have an event in their private room. We recently had our daughters bridal shower there. Everyone raved about the food, which was wonderful. The wait staff was amazing, very friendly and attentive. All other staff we interacted with were also great. Would definitely recommend Barrel 28 for your next party“

“Ordered two cheese pies yesterday. Well done. It was the best pizza I’ve had since moving up here. Crust was thin and crispy. Can’t wait to do it again.“

“We love Napolis! The food is great and everyone is so friendly. They greet you the second you walk through the door and everyone is always so happy to help, which isn't always the case everywhere.“

“Fabulous pizza. Will definitely return.“

“I am so Addicted to this place great food sweet people don't take my word order from them everything is so good and I'm very picky“

“Best food, I hardly recommend this place!!!! Very friendly. LOVE IT 😍“

“Been a customer of Frank’s for a long time, close to 30 years, the food is always consistent, it never disappoints and never wavers. Nothing fancy just good quality American - Italian! Good portions at a fair price. IMO the best pie in the area, especially when I ask for pizza made the way I like it! They know! The staff is wonderful and the family of owners are all top notch people. We love Frank’s!“

“Best customer service around plus everything on the extensive menu is delicious and large portions. Something for everyone and always open.“

“Rt This place is one of the BEST pizzerias in Sussex County! The pizza is always delicious especially extra cheese & pepperoni! It is very appealing to the eye, perfectly cooked and seasoned to perfection! I have also had hot sandwiches from here which were delicious! I want to give the highest review for them specifically their Eggplant parmigiana, Cheese steak and Cheese calzone!! Thank you for your Service in our Beautiful town of Sussex!!“

“Their Sicilian Chicken Bacon Ranch / Regular Chicken Bacon Ranch is THE BEST around. I am super picky about my pizza and theirs is always delicious. I would say their garlic knots could use a bit more oil on them but that’s just me being picky 😄 highly recommend! Hands down best pizza in the area.“

“A long time family favorite of ours. Lovely, comfy environment and super delish unique dishes. They’re always changing up their menu to include something new and exciting, in addition to their fantastic menu main-stays.“

“I got the Strawberry salad from here today. It was really good. The staff was really friendly. They treat you like family. I from out of town (Michigan) and felt cozy and comfortable eating there. I hope to go back tomorrow and try the pizza.“

“Highly recommend Carlos Cucina in Goshen,NY. The food is wonderful, they have gluten free options, their staff is very friendly and attentive, and the restaurant has a bright and welcoming atmosphere.“

“I Ordered a Extra large extravaganza pizza about 30 minutes before close. I'm ngl I felt incredibly bad doing so but the employee Bret was incredibly understanding and very professional. Probably one of the nicest workers i have met in recent years.“

“Once again the hubs brought REAL pizza back home to PA! The selection of specialty pizza slices is absolutely insane, the garlic knots are the size of your head, and the rice balls are absolutely phenomenal. Love when he stops and today we FaceTime’d and I got to pick my own slices!!!“

“Recently used them for catering, the food was fantastic, well priced, and they delivered right on time.“

“I eat here often and the food is always fantastic and the prices are great too compared to others in the area.“

“I can’t say enough about the catering we got yesterday from here! The food was so yummy thr trays were JAM PACKED! The staff was so friendly and hospitable! And the price was right!“

“Great Store! Excellent Service! Ken the owner, Debbie and the rest of the staff always greet you warmly great people all around. Beautiful view of lake from inside! Cute dock outside perfect for sunrise pics! The perfect stop when you don’t want to be bothered going to a supermarket. Love it! Wouldn’t trade them for anything!!“

“The absolute best pizza anywhere. The sauce. 😋 mussels fra diablo me and the wife’s favorite“

“Best pizza in town, hands down! Every time I stop by, I’m blown away by how good the pizza is. The crust is perfectly crispy, the sauce is amazing, and the toppings are always fresh. You can tell he puts real love into his food. The boss is super Italian (in the best way possible!) and his humor alone makes the visit worth it. I always leave smiling and knowing I’m about to eat great.Authentic, delicious, and full of personality. Highly recommend!“

“the martinis were outrageous and the pizza was even better. the rustic pizza is too . die. for.“

“Dynamite chicken thighs. Not sure if blasting Indian music so the white and black customers had to yell their orders is best for business, but chicken thighs were great. Oh and mac & cheese was old and heat light overcooked. But the chicken thighs were worth it, lol.“

“Fabulous Restaurant & Bar!! Food was fantastic!Service was top notch! Our waitress Lindsey was unbelievable! They accommodate all size groups! Buffalo Chicken Pizza delicious! Bartenders On Point!! Shot Ski’s!! Go have some fun with your friends & family like we did!“

“My family went for a Christmas Eve dinner the food was fantastic the service was wonderful I will be going back often“