11 Best Ice Cream Shops near Pompey

“My husband and I love Perry's Ice Cream. Although Hilltop Ice Cream no longer carries the almond milk non-dairy vanilla or cookies and cream flavors they do have a nice lemon sorbet. Catching up with neighbors as you enjoy your chosen flavor adds human interaction to the experience. I recommend the queen of hearts, my husband loves white lightning, both are dark chocolate bases. In the stores you can't beat orange dark chocolate twist or bittersweet symphony. ??“

“This sweet little shop was a little confusing to find but if you follow your navigational system exactly, you'll find it! Tucked behind the gas station on the way out from Jamesville Beach Park, it's a quiet and sweet little spot. A couple young folks minding the counter with a system in place (one took money, one did toppings, one did the ice cream) greeted us. They had a ton of options! I got the strawberry cheesecake sundae and it was DELICIOUS after a hot day of Frisbee Golfing. Do recommend!!“

“The best iced matcha latte I’ve ever had. Large portion and it was blended like a slushie. Deeeelicious.“

“We found this place on accident when we were turning around in their driveway. When we realized it was an ice cream place way out here, we figured it must be a sign and we might as well impulse buy some.It ended up being one of our favorite spots for the summer. We went way out of our way a bunch of times just to come back here and try whatever we could. My favorites were the Pebbles flurries. I added a marshmallow flavor burst to the base vanilla for the Fruity one, and mixed in Reese's for the Cocoa one. I came back and got both at least a few times. Something about the way they use Reese's I really liked. The fact that they're using real Reese's Cups broken only into moderate pieces was awesome. It went great in the Sundae too.I'd never heard of Gifford's as a brand before coming here, and they introduced a whole slew of new flavors. Every single one of them were great. Why is Gifford's not more of a thing around here?Also, we saw a bunch of people working here, but there was one girl in particular who really seemed to have us down. Our orders usually require some explaining, and if they're any good, sometimes some problem solving. Not only was she on board with everything we said, she understood everything on the first go, and she was super enthusiastic and enabling for us. She gave us some great ideas (like adding the marshmallow flavor burst to the flurry). I wish we had gotten her name, after getting her so many times in a row we just assumed she was one of the only people there. Maybe we'll see her there next year.The only thing we wouldn't get again is a milkshake. We got it with hard ice cream and a mix in but it was super runny and felt like it was mostly milk. Not a big deal, this was one of our favorite spots for ice cream this summer. The price, the service, and the ice cream are all great.“

“The best section of homemade ice cream in town. I love the artwork and the vibes are very cool. The server was nice and patient while we decided. You can do samples if you're undecided! Honestly even with the longer line we still weren't sure by the time we got to the window“

“Gabrielle's Chocolate is a chocolate and ice cream haven that surpasses expectations. With its diverse selection of chocolate confections, artisanal ice cream creations, inviting ambiance, quality ingredients, and exceptional staff, it truly deserves the title of the best ice cream chocolate candy shop in town. Treat yourself to a sweet escape atand savor the irresistible combination of chocolate and ice cream bliss.“

“Imagine a Dairy Queen that is older than your grandmother and is a local legend. The best soft serve ice cream found in the NY state. Sit and enjoy your ice cream, hot dogs, fries, or your choice while sitting on a picnic bench and looking out onto a field. Popular with locals and vacation visitors.“

“Always a great experience! I've been enjoying Carvel ice cream since I was a kid! They have all their classics as well as new things I haven't tried! It's a small shop, no stairs, very clean and everyone is just so friendly. It's so easy to start up a conversation! It's very clean and just a great treat for the whole family. My pup Coop did for sure!“

“I will start this as I always do by saying that I don't give out five stars, unless I am really blown away.I was passing through Tully and saw a sign for coffee. I turned around and went down the street and found this little shop. Just before I went in this little shop, I smelled a wonderful smell. It smelled like ribs on a smoker. I turned and saw a large smoker on the back of a truck and a gentleman next to the truck happen to be the owner of the shop. Big Mike was his name. I asked about the smoker. He said he and his do some catering as well. Mike invited me into the shop. Got me a cup of coffee and chatted with me for a little bit of time. The coffee was awesome. They had breakfast sandwiches other things there as well but I had already eaten. I will be stopping back to try a snack, and especially to get more coffee. Big Mike was awesome. I took his card so that I could possibly ask him to do some catering at some point. This place is worth your stop whether it be baked treats, coffee, or ice cream. As the menu look great. I will follow up after I eat some snacks.“

“Great ice cream options, and the staff are always smiling and helpful. Wish there was some indoor seating for those hot and stormy days, but the outside tables and grass areas are nice. The pond is also a great little walk, and a nice way to enjoy the Sno Top treat. If in Manlius, you have to try!“

“Love Artic Island! Ice Cream is so good and such a great environment! I was so excited to hear that they also can make treats for your pups! I contacted them about making a little cake for our dog Lunas gotchya day and they made the cutest unicorn cake for her! She loved it!! Will definetly keep coming for summers to come,for family ice cream outings!“